Starting a new thread because the previous one was Muriel'd.
I'm rewatching early Sheffer era ATWT. I'm into early 2001 now. Summer 2000 was just so delicious with the long-awaited end of the Lily/Rose storyline and Rose getting revealed and then Holden catching Lily making out with Simon on an island. It was all so well done. Bringing back Iva to retcon Rose into Lily's twin just worked for me for some reason. I also love the whole Endicott Awards with Katie finally getting revealed as faking her own stalking to steal Molly's job and knowing about the Lily/Rose switch all along. That material is all dynamite, and pretty much from July 2000 - September 2000, ATWT is firing on all cylinders (for what would be the last time?)
By fall 2000, I started to notice some of Sheffer's more annoying tics start to pop up. In his effort to "give the men their balls back," Jack and Hal become complete assholes. The storylines aren't exactly anything to write home about either -- Craig selling illegal microchips or whatever and Hal trying to nail him on it is all pretty lame. Molly being visited by [italic]Another World's[/italic] Vicky Hudson (in ghost form) shouldn't work at all. And yet, it's clear that Sheffer has earned incredible good will among the writing staff and the actors. The day to day episodes are quite good, even when the storylines shouldn't work. I noticed a particularly witty script, and sure enough, it was a Marie Masters script. And the actors are playing the heck out of the material. Colleen Zenk-Pinter is clearly loving the breakdown of Barbara's marriage, and Barbara has become a TOTAL bitch (lol), but she's clearly enjoying the first material she could sink her teeth into in a long time. I know it's going to get ridiculous eventually after she gets burnt and they eventually have her jumping out of courthouses, but for now, the darker Barbara is just great. Hunt Block was a decent Craig recast for the first few months. Yes, a little darker than Scott Bryce's take on the character, but I can see a through line. But it's starting to go south as he becomes more mustache-twirling.
I'm up thru January 2001. For now I'll keep going. I know it's going to get ridiculous and over-the-top at some point. But it's quite good. I saw Lauren Martin's last episode as Camille for probably the first time since it aired 20 years ago. She had very little to do her last year or so there, but her last episode with her saying goodbye to John at the train station was quite a tearjerker! Surprised no other soap ever picked her up. She was very beautiful. I saw Andy leave. It was sold as just a temporary leave as Andy went to rehab, but that's it.... Andy never appeared again for the next 10 years. At least we never had to deal with an awful recast. Can you imagine Steve Burton or some other ABC actor as a "hunkier" Andy Dixon? Our beloved Scott DeFreitas was the HEART and SOUL of ATWT.
Saw an ad for GL at the end of an ATWT episode... Prince Richard is not the legitimate Prince of San Cristobal. As much as I loved this period of ATWT, I remember this as an awful period for GL. I stuck by GL for the clone, stuck by for the Nursery Rhyme Stalker, but once it became 100% mafia/San Cristobal, I stopped watching. I didn't come back to GL until Millee Taggart's tenure in 2002 (and by then, I remember thinking ATWT had gone south again. They could never both be good at the same time.)
Anyway, sorry for rambling. There is nobody else I can talk about this with outside of DL, lol.