Which Gibb is the HOTTEST?

BIG JUNK!

This should’ve been a poll.

“was” the hottest?

[quote]This should’ve been a poll.

From the look of that pic, there are already several poles there.

ALL have/had huge massive cocks! Barry who is still alive has the largest cock. It's well known.

Barry was the obvious sex machine but I agree with you OP and would.go with Maurice now.

Maurice. [R2], Madonna heard you, Oliver.

Definitely Barry. He oozes sex appeal with those leonine looks of his.

There's something sweet about Maurice, I agree. I used to count him out too. He and Andy win for "best chest hair/treasure trail" for sure. I don't know that I've seen a shirtless picture of Barry?

I think Barry and Andy were the "hottest" but I had a strange affinity for the homely Robin. He was plain looking but boy could he could sing. I liked his voice better than any of the brothers.

Robin, due to his resemblance to Penny Marshall.

[quote] This should’ve been a poll.

Yes, this would have been a perfect time for a poll. 4 brothers, no missing names.

Anyway, Maurice aged like Ringo Star, i.e., aged well.

Barry was hot with the hair, etc.

Robin was, apparently, the most ambitious and hungry for success.

Robin’s chicklet teeth for the win!

Andy's constant moose knuckle comes in second place R13!

I was OBSESSED with Andy Gibb when I was a teenager. So fucking dreamy and he was NOT afraid to strip down to short shorts or wear those tight shiny pants. I'm 50 and still sad that he died so young. I blame Victoria Principal for his spiral into madness!

Andy Gibb had a hairy back.

He could never be a teen idol in today's world without constant waxing.

Bulging Barry, hands down—

R16 right you are! He had hairy shoulders that are visible in lots of his teen heartthrob photos. He gave zero fucks about that shoulder hair apparently. I'd still hit it. What a hirsute bunch of guys they were!

He can barely hold that cock IN...look at that thing bulging out of those pants. Barry all day, every day man! Fuck and what a head of hair on him too. FUCK!

Barry is a Trumper and a known asshole.

R20 I’ve never heard that before. What’s you’re source?

your

I don't believe in showing off the goods like they did in the 70s and 80s. It's not polite...

Andy was adorable.

Now it's all about the VPL and free balling in sweat pants!

Barry...hands down...

My hands down those trousers, that is!!! Woof!!!!

R20 we are not talking about the Barry of 2022. This is a fantasy. NONE OF US ARE FUCKING BARRY GIBB. Inevitably Trump ruins all these threads with the "he's a KNOWN Trump supporter" and all our dicks get limp. FANTASY, PEOPLE- to get us through the day.

Team Barry.

Barry has a serios camel toe in r19 ‘s photo. He looks like he has a vagina

Notorious pussyhound. Big Trump supporter.

Robin had disdended and badly damaged nipples.

*serious

I would constantly jerk off to the thought of their hairy chests. Andy was the hottest by far.

Poor Andy. Has three Number 1 songs in a row, then meets Victoria Principal, then...NOTHING.

Barry.

Team Barry!

Andy was in serious trouble with cocaine the second he picked it up as a teenager.

Victoria Principal had nothing to do with Andy's troubles.

OP, I also watched that recently. I like how they pronounced Maurice like “Morris.” He was by far the most reasonable brother.

Andy’s appeal was that he wanted it the most. He had the thirst of a lead singer while Barry had the looks for it. And they both had the voices.

R37, Victoria was the Yoko Ono of the Gibb brothers.

Who won the sock stuffing contest?

Barry said he doesn’t pay much attention to politics, but said in 2016, he might vote for trump because he thought he could shake things up.

Also he’s considered one of the nicer guys in the music business.

Speaking of Yoko…obviously the Bee Gees were superbly talented. I get the appeal of their music and enjoy listening to it. But after a day or so I need a break from it. It just isn’t as satisfying as the Beatles.

I used to think Robin was the sh.t, but I was sleeping on Maurice. He seems like a sexy rascal.

It was kind of an odd moment in the documentary when the keyboard player from Mott the Hoople was crying about writing How Deep Is Your Love. He didn’t seem upset by not getting the credit - more like he was still upset by whoever he was writing the song about.

Are they gay. If not, why do we care?

Maurice and Lulu made such a cute couple, and always spoke warmly of each after their divorce.

Obviously Marla!

For R21

Barry is a Trumper and obviously not very bright.

Did Barbra and Barry schtup when recording Guilty?

Andy was hot sex on a stick, without a doubt. And brothers really did produce a wide range of eclectic types and trends in pop music.

R38, Europeans pronounce Maurice as Morris.

Victoria seemed like a MILF territory—was she a lot older than Andy while dating?

Maurice aged like fine wine but Robin...well, he had a great voice...

Barry was definitely (IMO) the hottest of the Gibb brothers.

Andy was attractive too.

Andy was the hottest, Barry the sexiest.

I never found the Bee Gees attractive in the 70s. Andy Gibb was the only attractive one to me as a young gayling. I even had his “Shadow Dancing” album, with him wearing his snakeskin socks.

This virtual duet was a beautiful tribute to Andy.

Andy Gibb had a wife in Australia which the record company kept completely quiet about so screaming female (and gay male) fans wouldn’t feel he’s off limits,

The Bee Gees wrote Chain Reaction by Miss Ross. I think it was Barry who did the background vocals.

How was it even comfortable wearing pants that tight back in the 1970s? Were they freeballing?

[quote] Andy Gibb had a hairy back.

But so did Victoria Principal, so she didn't mind.

His shoulders looked freckled due to sun exposure in some photos. He had a nice hairy chest.

Barry is at the height of his sexiness in the Staying Alive video. All the walking, the swagger-sex on a fucking stick!

Andy looks lost in the pic. It gives me the sads, knowing what happened to him.

The sads for sure. His mom was with him when he died and he was clean, but the years of abuse did him in. Just 30 years old.

I absolutely adore the Bee Gees and I like Andy Gibb's voice and records, but no one can deny that 'attractive' isn't exactly the most adequate way to describe any of the Gibb brothers. Robin and Maurice looked like two frigid Polish nuns, Barry has always looked like he would fit right in with a tribe of Neanderthals and Andy, who was the only passable one, was the facial equivalent of butter-on-toast (in short, not interesting at all).

Still, as singers and composers they were simply amazing. I particularly like how well they adapted to ever decade's music trends while remaining faithful to their own very unique style. They were masters of their craft, without a single doubt.

However, hot? Sorry, but NO.

Clean from drugs, but started to drink heavily shortly before he died. He was living in a cottage at robins estate and has signed a deal with island records based on the demos he had done a few months before. He was going there to work on writing new songs but got writers block and fell into despair. His mom came over shortly before he died to take care of him, but he was already abusing alcohol again. One incident he ran into a wall and knocked his teeth out.

When he died, robin found a bunch of empty liquor bottles underneath his bed. At his funeral people were shocked to see how orange his skin was because he was so jaundiced.

Jaundice causes yellowing of the skin R66. I had heard that bout knocking his teeth out too. THE SADS! As a very average looking elder gay it's so hard to imagine being so down when you are just so handsome and magnetic. It goes to show you that looks aren't everything I suppose.

None of them. Way too hairy.

R8 I LOVE that you had the word "leonine" at your fingertips! I agree with you. I can imagine how intense having him fuck me would be. I think that they all had great bodies and really just the right amount of hair. Barry though did have an animalistic quality to him. He's been married to the same woman since 1970 or so. How many times did he step out on HER, I wonder? I have a neighbor who knows a man that fucked Andy. I want to believe this so badly, but I have my doubts.

[quote]I would constantly jerk off to the thought of their hairy chests.

I have a hairy chest too! Why isn't anybody jerking off to the thought of me?

Details r69!

Andy Gibb was very sexy to me during my gay teens until he died. Tight pants, short shorts, open or no shirt exposing a beautiful hairy chest, nice hip action, and he could sing, a very cute adorable guy.

R71 my neighbor knew an elder gay who at one time worked for one of Andy’s record labels. He said that he and Andy were seeing each other for “quite a while.” My neighbor said that he believed him.

Funny how two of the brothers got their noses bobbed and two didn't.

Andy Gibb looks like a young Barry in this video.

Rex Smith.

[quote]OP, I also watched that recently. I like how they pronounced Maurice like “Morris.”

Americans pronounce it the French way. Those gurls is FUNNY!

I've always thought Andy was the hottest. I can see why someone might go for Maurice. In any case, I'm pretty sure I'm not a Robin-star.

[quote] Which Gibb is the HOTTEST?

Ah, none of them?

[quote] Which Gibb is the HOTTEST?

The dead one

[quote]They always came across as very decent, unspoiled and unaffected people.

Barry epitomized the look of the young man of Swinging London

R72 "very sexy to me during my gay teens until he died."

Um, what? Pretty hard to be sexy after you're dead, I suppose.

My neighbor said that he believed him.

Must be true then, R73

Maurice had a quiet, smoldering quality that showed his inner self-confidence, unlike cocky Barry and neurotic Robin. Andy was a lost child.

I fantasized about Andy Gibb and Robby Benson when I was in middle school.

R65 says Barry was not hot, then proceeds to post a video, the thumbnail of which is Barry looking so hot I'd suck his dick till his head caved in. Eh, different strokes.

Maurice aged into a hot daddy.

The beard did a lot for Maurice (and the hat, once it came).

Barry in his prime was mind-blowingly hot but he really aged like milk. Maurice became more attractive as he got older.

BUMP

R77 leave it to us Americans to take a beautiful name like “Maurice” and pronounce it as “Morris”.

R91 that's how Barry pronounces it though. Surely HE can't be wrong and he's not an American.

Too old and hairy.

[Quote] leave it to us Americans to take a beautiful name like “Maurice” and pronounce it as “Morris”.

But Americans don't pronounce "Maurice" as "Morris"...

Andy Andy Andy Andy. Just dreamy- lithe, hairy, cute little nose...

This thread is useless without more hot pics of Barry's Bulge and Andy.

Ew.

R96 it's all there at R19!

How did Americans get Brits to mispronounce the name for this film?