Christopher Welles' book about her father Orson is very engaging. It's not scandalous so much as interesting. As a child & teenager she was overwhelmed by her elusive father's cult of personality. In adulthood she wrangled with his shortcomings as an actual parent. It's brief, decently written, and moving. Lots of incidental Hollywood tidbits from a child's eye (being "mothered" by long-suffering Rita Hayword; being the star guest at a weekend luncheon at Olivier & Vivien Leigh's castle).
My ratings:
The Hornes: An American Family - C. Dull and evasive.
Detour - A for the reasons mentioned above. Sadly, Crane was less forthcoming in later endeavors, like the special she did on her mother for TCM
Mommie Dearest - A. I have the 20th anniversary edition as well as the original. The former is her unedited manuscript, plus contemporary testimonials from witnesses to her abuse, especially during the Chadwick years. The edits made to the orig manuscript were apt.
=> A fabulous (if dubiously transcribed) Joan book is "Conversations with Crawford" by Roy Newquist. There's never been a truly good biography of her, so this is as good as it gets thus far. She talks about her movies and some socio-political views (disparaging Bette Davis for her popularity among gays, for one), as well as her personal and parenting philosophies with some pointed remarks about Christina and Christopher. Of course she lies about herself.
Haywire - A+. She should have written a sequel as well, as she had a fascinating, if somewhat circular life after the period depicted.
My Mother's Keeper - This is a "D-" unless you enjoy unintentional hilarity, which I do. So I also read her sequel, "Narrow is the Way," which is even worse. It details her spiritual conversion amidst the trauma of fatally betraying her mother by writing the previous book. I bough both books used and loathe Hyman, but I can't help but read them periodically. They are laugh out loud funny in their delusion. Poor Bette.
=> By the way, don't read Barbara Leaming's biography of Bette, which was entirely colored by the cooperation provided by Hyman. It is incredibly negative about Bette's work, and deceptive about her marriages and mothering, as subsequent biographies have proved.
Me and My Shadows - B
Thanks to all the posters who suggested Maria Riva's book. I just ordered a used copy