Who was the most talented member of CSNY?

Whoever wrote and sang this:

Young

DO you mean "CSI:NY," OP?

I liked Stella Bonasera.

‘If I Could Only Remember My Name,’ by David Crosby is my favourite musical offering from any of the foursome. From a business perspective, Neil Young is to be lauded, although that may in part be due to the late Elliot Roberts.

George Eads because that ass and dimples made me feel funny.

Let’s be real: Stephen Stills was the master behind the music. While the others certainly made important contributions, Stills created the musical tone and wrote the beat songs

He went through several hairdos, r6.

I always thought Steve Stills was the most talented. He and Young wrote Everybody I Love You. I got that album in 1970, and still have it

Stills was also a an exceptional guitarist with a unique tone, quite underaged in his skills

Stephen Stills is one of the most talented musicians of our era, from songwriting to singing and brilliant guitar playing. But he has always been very mainstream, which Neil Young has not been. Young is either terrific or way off the mark. I don’t think Crosby or Nash were quite in the same league as Stills or Young.

I love proto-retard Neil Young but he was a horrible fit. CSN.

They all brought something that the others didn’t. That said, Neil Young is still kicking so maybe a vote for him. Maybe some Canadian bias too. 😊

Graham Nash is the most mild-mannered.

Judy Collins

I have to go with Norm Crosby.

Graham was the nicest according to many, including Rita Coolidge.

I think they were all very talented - in different and complimentary ways.

I am yours, you are mine, we are what we are

Great lyrics well sung.

This is painful.