I think people are reacting intensely to the word "winning" here. It is clear in the detail that Ana Sorensen (the writer) means "winning" as in "getting what he wants". Which he is, in many cases. But she does not mean "winning" as in actually being a positive thing for the US economy.
From Ana's detail:
"While the president’s plan for global trade now looks like a political victory, whether it will be an economic success remains much more debatable. The Trump administration has essentially embarked on a vast economic experiment, with tariff levels not seen in the United States since the early 20th century. The rates Mr. Trump is asking other countries to agree to are typically used by poor economies trying to protect nascent industries, not by industrial powerhouses like the United States.
"Mr. Trump and his supporters argue that higher tariffs will encourage many more companies to produce in the United States, creating U.S. factory jobs while having minimal impact on businesses and consumers. The president also insists that foreign governments, not U.S. businesses or consumers, will pay the tariffs, despite longstanding research that shows Americans ultimately bear the brunt.
"Clyde Prestowitz, a former U.S. government official and the founder of the Economic Strategy Institute, said Mr. Trump’s America had “a lot of similarities” with the United States before 1946 and other countries, like China, that built their economies with so-called mercantilist policies, using protectionism to try to amass trade surpluses and wealth.
"But many economists continue to predict that Mr. Trump’s tariffs will result in higher prices both for businesses that import products and for the consumers who buy them. They expect that to slow the economy and backfire, at least somewhat, on the president’s efforts to rev up manufacturing.
"In recent weeks, automakers like General Motors and Volkswagen have reported hits of more than $1 billion from tariffs.
“What’s lost in translation is even as these deals are being cut, the eventual tariff rate is likely to peak around 20 percent, which is up a lot from below 3,” said Diane Swonk, the chief economist at KPMG.
(end of article)