Favorite Ben & Jerry's Flavor?

Cherry Garcia!

Arse.

Gimme S'mores was pretty good. Had it last week.

Used to be Chubby Hubby but last time I had it it didn't seem to have as much flavor as I remember. Maybe my tastebuds are just old (55 yo).

Brownie Batter

Chunky Monkey, here.

Literally.

Vanilla Caramel Fudge. I had a pint for breakfast.

Some of the best ones are in the Flavor Graveyard.

I've had some of their "core" editions -- don't know if that's what they're called -- and they were pretty good. Anything chocolate and peanut butter and I'm happy.

Pistachio Pistachio and my favorite extinct flavor is Wavy Gravy

Americone Dream

R11 It is the best!

It WAS Holy Canoli, but that's long gone. Damn!

Peanut Butter World, Mousse Pie, Cherry Garcia, and Vanilla Caramel Fudge are mine.

I know, I know...

Baby Batter

Peanut Butter Cup

Karamel Sutra Core. I like to keep it simple.

Loved their grape-lemon sorbet

Pfish Food

I just tried the Chocolate Peanut Butter Split and it might be my new favorite. I just love banana! I wish I could find Sunny Honey Home here, was that just limited time?

I haven't had Ben & Jerry's in years. All my favorite flavors get discontinued so I have no loyalty to them. If I had to go to the store today and pick one I'd get Stephen Colbert's Americone Dream. Now that his show is cancelled they'll probably pull that one too

"Phish Food", and the closely related; "Everything But The Kitchen Sink"

My favorite was Oatmeal Cookie Chunk.

Americone Dream is just the right blend of ingredients.

Don't like the new flavors with the hard chocolate coating on top of the pint. Too much work to eat ice cream.

I was beyond obsessed with this one for years. B&J pulled it a few years ago. I mourned its loss.

Their Chocoate Therapy flavor is the best form of therapy overall.

I don’t like Ben and Jerry’s. Lots of unnecessary ingredients. You might as well eat store brand.

On a whim I tried the Publix brands "Heavenly Hash" and "Otter Claws". Bland and boring.

Me too, OP!

Nuclear Fukushima Kelp!

Marshmallow Sky. I tried it at the factory in Vermont and have sadly never seen it anywhere else.

Haagen Dazs is better. Fewer ingredients. The peanut butter chocolate is heavenly.

Ben & Jerry’s Vanilla Caramel Fudge is good, as is Chocolate Fudge Brownie.

Half Baked.

Like me.

No longer made, Dublin Mudslide.

Most overrated brand ever. I fully remember when they were one of the only decent pint games in town, but they really rely on the "Lets add a bunch of sweet shit people like to ice cream" idea that just doesn't work for me. And the quality of their mix ins has gone downhill. Give me Van Leeuwen.

[quote]Dip me in chocolate and throw me to the lesbians

Pics please.

heath bar crunch RIP

I know I sound boring but I’ve always loved the original three flavors that they debuted with (if I remember right) in the 90s.

Chunky Monkey, Cherry Garcia, and New York Super Fudge Chunk.

Perfection!

Agree with some of the above. I feel like some of the endless “gimmicky” flavors are too much, too much candy and junk added… it seems like so they can just advertise on the front all the wacky ingredients (wasn’t there one with Pop Rocks?) to grab people’s attention. Granted I’m sure some of them are good, but some of them are just dumb. It’s like they’re just tossing crap into a trash can. You can’t even enjoy the ice cream.