1d members - who was gay all along?

NONE

Louis Floplinson LOL

Judge them during auditions to see who pings. You can also see how truly ordinary they were.

Nobody pings. Louis has a thin voice like a baby crow.

Faulty poll. Should have had "who are these people?" as an option.

ALL of them

All of these except Harry Styles have sunk into oblivion.

Is Zayn still a junkie?

Niall and Harry.

[QUOTE] Is Zayn still a junkie?

Yes, and ugly. Louis and Liam are raging alcoholics.

Why did gay rumours start about any of them in the first place? And why the hell do they persist now when all the made up boundaries to a coming out have long since been left behind?

Because of their insane fans and the Larries.

They were pretty boys.

Were they though?

sure I just looked at their audition tape. All charming pretty boys.

[quote]All of these except Harry Styles have sunk into oblivion.

Niall is on tv every week as a judge on The Voice.

Louis. And I'm not saying it in a "I want to fuck him, so I want him to be gay", he just pings to me and he didn't have a girlfriend for a long time.

It's all very Jason Orange from Take That.

I think Niall is adorable and very charming as a Judge

None of them seem gay, just young and not masculine. Fun to fantasize, though, OP!

I am a Larry shipper, a Larry believer if you will.

Louis is a grubby little runt but he's not even Datalounge gay. He lived with his girlfriend Eleanor Calder for eight years. He also hates the gays and banned his fans from throwing pride flags onto the stage at his concerts.

So working class.

Either way... some of their careers have been ruined because their handlers told them to have children with random sluts. If they had only listened to the Larry shippers or just hinted to liam and Larry (liarrym?) being a secret couple... I guess then they would be at least as famous as Niall. Zayn has ruined his life too with drugs and having a child with a hollywood prostitute. I think there was an agenda here. That all of them are told to get children so that they lose fans. So that Harry can rise. Niall, a full blown gay, wasn't having none of it and made another deal probably. On the beyond the blinds podcast on spotify it was said that he and Shawn Mendes are a thing.

That’s the first I’ve heard of Niall being gay. What are the rumors or evidence?

R24 on the Kelly Clarkson show he said the 30s are the new 20s. Only Fraus and gay men bother to think about topics regarding aging. If you want all the gay rumors about him, listen to this episode about him:

R20, you beat me to the punch

They ended up hating being in the group, They weren't friends to begin with and were just put together by Simon Cowell. i would have thought that their sniping at each other after the breakup would have resulted in a leak if one or more were gay.

God I hope r23 was being sarcastic

Niall isn't gay. He lives with his girlfriend Amelia in a mansion in north London.

Gigi is worth twice as much as Zayn so the only prostitute was him.

R29 That's what they said about Hugh Jackman and his grandma beard too.

The Reality

Harry - got wasted and made out with a guy at a party one time and is now convinced that he's bisexual despite only dating women.

Louis - aggressively straight because he loathes the Larries so much. Won't even dye his nasty grey hair. Homophobic too.

Liam - straight and into young girls. Dated a 17 year old when he was 25 and is currently living with a girl seven years younger than him.

Zayn - straight and into curvy fat women. A member of Woo Plus, a plus size dating site. Screenshots exist of him on the site.

Niall - devoted to his pretty skinny girlfriend of three years, Amelia, who is 26. All her socials are private so he managed to snag a rare non fame hoe instead of a wannabe influencer like Liam's girlfriend.

[quote]Harry - got wasted and made out with a guy at a party one time and is now convinced that he's bisexual despite only dating women.

I think you're giving him too much credit. More like straight but saw how much attention and adoration he got from the Larries by hinting he might not be. Plus I guess it helped distract from the various women he was fucking.

I think it also says a lot about him as a person that Louis, who was one of his closest friends at the time, hated the Larry stuff, and yet Harry kept stirring that pot to keep the attention going.

Louis = straight and ugly

[quote] who was gay all along?

Barzini.

Zain was so beautiful.

Zayn got fat and grew an Old Testament beard.