All the threads of the Australian woman poisoning her dinner guests with mushrooms made me want to revisit one of the greatest detective series of all time, Midsomer Murders. I've decided to start from the beginning and I've been contemplating what my favorite episode is.
Of course, my all time favorite is the first one, The Killings at Badger's Drift (1997). Nothing will ever top the insanity of the eccentric mother and son duo of Iris Rainbird and her son Denny. There's incestuous overtones as well as incest driving the main plot. No, I won't spoil it.
And then there are a few other episodes that stand out. The Black Book (2009), Beyond The Grave, (2000), Destroying Angel (2001) [which also happens to be the same plot of the Australian mushroom murder saga], A Talent for Life with Honor Blackman (2003), The Christmas Haunting (2013), Murder On St. Malley's Day (2002), The House In The Woods (2005), and I'm sure there are countless others that I have forgotten -- which is why I am starting to rewatch them all.
My favorite episodes are usually the earlier episodes as they're more quaint and eccentric just like the earlier episodes of Murder, She Wrote. However, there are gems in the later seasons as well. I cannot believe they are about to start airing season 24. This series has been on since 1997! My favorite Barnaby is definitely Tom Barnaby played by John Nettles but I also do have a soft spot for his "cousin", a younger replacement, John Barnaby played by Neil Dudgeon. There have also been 5 different detective sergeants: Sergeant Gavin Troy (Daniel Casey), Sergeant Dan Scott (John Hopkins), Detective Sergeant Ben Jones (Jason Hughes), Detective Sergeant Charlie Nelson (Gwilym Lee), and Sergeant Jamie Winter (Nick Hendrix). Troy, Scott, and Jones have been my favorites.
John Nettles was 54 when the series started and 68 when Neil Dudgeon replaced him. Neil Dudgeon was 50 when he started and is now 62. I wonder how long before he will be replaced by a younger Barnaby if the series continues for a few more years. How long can it actually go on!? The writing and acting are still up to part so I hope it continues for a long time.
Anyway, what are your favorite episodes and why?