Who was better-looking in her prime: Debbie Harry or Belinda Carlisle?

Debbie Harry without a doubt. Natural beauty.

Belinda Carlisle was well-known for the extensive plastic surgery she had and was creepy.

Debbie Harry was like the Michelle Pfeiffer of rock. Classic, striking beauty. Those cheekbones so sharp they could cut glass. The camera just loved her.

Belinda was a very attractive woman after she lost the weight and glammed up, but never in Debbie’s league imo.

BC was a cute girl. But you know, cute next to gorgeous - gorgeous is gonna devour cute. Debbie was breathtaking.

Belinda looked her best in the “La Luna” video. You could arguably make the case that she’s beautiful here, vs merely pretty. That said, very few could hold a candle to Ms Deborah Harry.

Is this a serious question?

Debbie Harry. Are you kidding?

R5, why not?

Debbie Harry was one of the hottest chicks ever. Sharp and striking face, tiny petite body. I get hard as fuck watching the music video for Rapture. Belinda Carlisle is pretty but not a head turner. If I saw a prime Debbie walking down the street I wouldn't be able to get her out of my head for the whole day.

Harry was and is a goddess.

Carlisle wasn't even a wood nymph.

Before the plastic, Belinda was gorgeous. La Luna, Mad About You, that beautiful cover photo of her first greatest hits collection is stunning. Debbie’s head is too big for her body but she looked best in Videodrome.

Both were beautiful - hard to choose

[quote] I get hard as fuck watching the music video for Rapture.

R8 That made me laugh. You don't, sweetheart

Bitchlinda looked okay in Mad About You, for sure.

But Debbie was stunning.

I was prettier than BOTH those bitches.

[quote]Who was better-looking in her prime: Debbie Harry or Belinda Carlisle?

Tony Danza

R12 I sure do, she's extremely hot in that video.

Op go jump in a lake.

Madonna was more beautiful than both combined

Fuck off with your pathetic trolling Janbot @ R18.

R19 how on earth is a Madonna fan Janbot?

What about ME!!!

What about me, it isn't fair. I ain't go none and I want my share. Can't you see? I want to live. But you just take more than you give!

Janis Ian vs Phoebe Snow

Debbie was beautiful.

Belinda looked way better before her weight loss and plastic surgery. More natural.

When did Belinda first lose the weight? At what age?

Comparing Blimpa Carlisle to Deb Harry is like comparing a sow to a swan.

Debbie

She looks pretty hot here.

Madonna looks like a mixture of both of them.

Madonna looks like their feet if said feet were dirty and blistered.

Vanity

I saw both of them up close back in the day. Blondie at the Santa Monica Civic ca.1979 and The Go-Gos at the Starwood ca. 1980.

There was really no comparison. Debbie was absolutely STUNNING. Belinda was "cute" but really pretty average (imho).

What about Lisa Lisa?

Stevie Nicks

Debbie Harry gave good face.

Debbie obviously. You couldn’t take your eyes off of her. I love Belinda, but I know what all of the other GoGos look like, so…

R35, which Go Gos do u think we're prettier than Belinda?

Belinda is a basic pretty suburban girl. Always on the verge of being fat.

Debbie has a great, unique look. And she can actually sing. Belinda can't. Not even a little.

What do Debbie and Belinda think of each other?

What band was better: Blondie or The Go-Go's?

Debbie was all right, but Belinda was a real...HAHAHAHA!!

Just kidding!

(Was this a serious question?)

R41, what do you mean?

Tied

Sheila E

Is this a serious question, OP?

[quote]Harry was and is a goddess.

[quote]Carlisle wasn't even a wood nymph.

I agree with R9 and everyone else in this thread, OP. Maybe you should have your eyes checked.

Even with professional makeup and lighting Belinda Carlisle was still nothing more than average.

[quote]Before the plastic, Belinda was gorgeous.

No.

What plastic surgery did Belinda get?

Madge over both

R36 why are you so stupid? Why do you create stupid threads and reply to yourself so much?

Debbie was voted the most beautiful girl in her high school. She’s beautiful. Belinda is cute/pretty and I thought she looked great in the during Mad About You/Heaven era. Debbie is naturally beautiful and sexy and I thought she would have a film career after Blondie.

Both beautiful but I prefer Debbie

Stevie Nicks

Debbie. Belinda has moments of looking amazing, Debbie has had them more frequently.

Madge should pray she looks as good as 77 as Debbie does.....

Tied

Deborah Harry.

I think Belinda was stunning around the time of her first two albums. Definitely NOT before that. She looks great in the Heaven is a Place on Earth video.

R58, why not before that?

R59, she was cute but unremarkable before she lost all the weight. She looks really great in the Mad about You and Heaven videos.

Debbie

Belinda but only for a few years