James Franco vs Dave Franco: Who was the hotter brother during their prime?

James is deliciously sleazy.

James in the Spiderman movies helped me through puberty. I could no longer deny my lust for men after watching the first Spiderman film.

Dave has a tighter bussy and gets really freaky in bed.

This was my introduction and the start of my deep crushing on Dave and my fantasy of seeing him pounded unrelentingly by a big Black man.

Tell us more R3 assuming you're not yanking our chains

Tom for me. I just like that facial structure more, is all.

^ All three brothers have that same huge grin it's really endearing. There aren't alot of pictures of momma franco or daddy franco online.

Mom’s a prominent children’s book writer, the smile looks to be hers.

James Franco has always looked sleazy, he has the face of a person not to be trusted.

That's definitely true as he's gotten older R9 but young James Franco in his prime had a smile that could melt Hearts and plenty of charisma.

Their Grandmother thought Dave was the more attractive. She came into a store I was working at at the time in NYC. One of the Spiderman movies with James Franco was filming at that time. She was a very cute old woman and very proud of her grandson. I had no idea who she was at first, obviously but she made it known why she was in NYC and who her grandson was. I was telling her how handsome he was and she agreed. But then she said, if you think he's something wait until you see his brother.

None of the above

James looks like he could eat out my ass with aplomb. Dave looks like he likes video games.

Dave is pretty but kind of asexual. James looks will give you a good time and possibly a STD.

James Franco. I've been in love with that man since I saw him in "Whatever It Takes" (2000). One of the last gasp of the harmless 90s teen flicks.

I can't choose, they're both completely adorable.

Fuck. I’d never seen Dave until now. He has the distinctive looks of a classic Hollywood male beauty.

Dave has sensitive nipples...you can make him cum if you know how to work 'em.

I watch Dave Franco movies just to see Dave Franco.

Isn't Dave married to that annoying actress whose name escapes me.

She's super annoying when on talk shows, she always tries to be so perky. This actress always mentions she's married to Dave!

^^^ The cheesy one?

I did love that bit with Dave fucking himself and cumming in his own ass.

They were both fun in The Disaster Artist. Nice lighthearted film.

I'd choose based on how the cum spurts out of their cock heads.

I'd like to have Franco Bukkake with all three brothers.

OP = Chris Mintz-Plasse

Dave Franco thinks the answer is Dave Franco

Fags, both of them.

I've met Dave Franco. He's adorable and very nice, but about 95 pounds soaking wet.

James Franco can take me and own me.

Cook pics?

Dave Franco used to annoy the hell out of me when he was on AfterScrubs, but I've enjoyed him in the last few comedies I saw him in and he seems nice enough in interviews. Plus no accusations of sexual misconduct that I'm aware of, which puts him quite a few behind James.

Dave doesn't seem all that sexual to me plus James is the one with the nice ass, it's even given interviews haha

A close-up of James' beautiful ASS. I'd definitely stick my tongue 👅 back there

Dave by a mile. James Franco has never done anything for me even though the media tells me he's hot

I wouldn't throw either one out of bed.

Franco.

Both are hot. Dave is the better person though. James just comes off as creepy. He is a great actor though.

R17 they both fall into Classic Hollywood Archetypes with their looks.

Dave Franco is Montgomery Clift while James Franco is more along the lines of a brooding Marlon Brando. Marlon Brando types look like they'd be freaks in bed. Montgomery Clift types are pretty and you just want to stare at them.

I've always thought James the hotter one. He has that aura of a bad boy sexual athlete and looks like he'd be up for most anything.

James was the hotter and slightly more handsome one. His dirty and sleazy side added to it, as well as that whole arty man of letters manic identity. He was full of shit but at least I could have discussed a lot with him between filthy sex. However, Dave has the genes to stay handsome longer and is more handsome now of course.

Dave is truly a Short King, and I bet his oral sex skills are on point, which is how he gets and keeps the ladies.

The hidden brother is the real freak.

James and Dave are both classically goodlooking. James channels that hot rough bisexual trade that James Dean and Al Pacino had. Dave may be short but so is Cruise and Efron and Dave isn't any less pretty nor worse an actor than them. James will be seen as the Marlon Brando of his time. Just mark my words. I can't think of any actor who took as many risks as James today..

They're half-brothers so if they had sex with each other, would it only be half as creepy?

Dave had exceptional tits.

Well. Shit. I didn't know James Franco even had a brother.

Dave is very handsome and has a great body, but he is too short. He also doesn't have James's weird charisma.

I used to think James was gorgeous, but his grotesque narcissism and sleaziness became too much for me. He reminds me of a very handsome guy I knew in college who once admitted he loved degrading girls not only just sexually but by also breaking up with them when they seemed to have finally fallen for him, just because he loved making them so heartbroken.