Which Tony Award winning Best Musical was the worst?

No contest.

Billy Elliot sucked

[bold]C A T S

Dance, Vivian Vance!

Need more choices in the poll, idiot

MEMPHIS.

[quote] was the worst?

Do you mean the worst in the last decade? The last half century?

R5 is right. Memphis was the absolute pits.

Kinky Boots was thoroughly mediocre (Matilda was far superior).

Spamalot was far from the worst winner, but considering it beat the brilliant Piazza, I have to give it honorable mention.

Raisin is bland; there’s a reason it’s never revived. Same with Redhead.

no question

Dear Evan Hansen

But Redhead and Book of Mormon are close behind. Very close for the latter.

Cats. Forty years later, I still can’t figure out what the hell I was watching.

R8 Yeston's PHANTOM was so good though? (superior by far to Webby's POTO...)

What went wrong with TITANIC?

CONTACT

The Music Man. The songs had a certain charm for their time. But the book!

"Jamaica" by Yip Harburg & Fred Saidy

R4 it’s irony. Idiot.

"La Plume de Ma Tante"

R1 LESTAT never won a Tony or even got within sniffing distance of one, but if it had you'd be all be saying it.

The badness is a massive part of its charm, though. I adore that it's a pile of shit shamelessly squished into a facsimile of a musical. Elton just dngaf!!

How ironic that neither Gypsy nor West Side Story nor Follies won a Best Musical Tony and yet are revived more than most that did.