The best Salt Water Taffy!

gross

There used to be some good shit in P'town. Haven't been there in a long time, though.

It looks delicious but I've got too many crowns to chance it.

I can't eat that crap. It pulls my fillings out.

the crowd here might enjoy salty loads but most of them can't afford dentures.. so taffy is out.

I absolutely love it! A friend of mine visited Pismo Beach and brought me some from there. I did not like all the flavors. But what I did like was delicious!

You lost me with "daytona beach."

Fuck floriduh!

I love taffy, but worry about my teeth. However, I have found I can freeze the taffy, then suck it and it work fine.

I love the stuff. My favorite flavors are the citrus flavors plus vanilla and molasses. MMMM-mmm. I generally avoid it though, because it's hard to stop eating it and before you know it you've consumed about 100,000 calories worth of taffy.

My favorites are Fralinger's or James' (owned by the same company), classic Atlantic City brands that are available on line.

We always have made our own.

Sad to think about people buying crap Chinese shit poured out of a trash bag into the bin.

^ Didi von Cuntington

And Consuela made it.

[quote] Sad to think about people buying crap Chinese shit poured out of a trash bag into the bin.

r10 The factory is in the store. I saw them making it while I was there.

You all sound fat.

Did you ever go to a taffy pull party? They were big in my parent's day.

Hate salt water taffy.

Love candy corn.

Go figure.

I like taffy when it is flattened and made brittle. I can still remember eating it when we visited Niagara Falls on a family vacation in the late 60s.

[quote] I has been there over 75+ years

Wow. How old are you?

I'm generally not a taffy person, but I like the chocolate and licorice taffy from this place on the Wildwood, NJ boardwalk

I love salt water taffy!

[quote] I has been there over 75+ years

At that age I am surprised you have any teeth to chew it.

I grew up going to Atlantic City, so I love SWT.

I like blue taffy

I was molested by a taffy salrsman

I love shalt watah taffy!

^shalt or shit?

A coworker brought boxes of it from Rehoboth Beach. Not a lot of flavor, but because it was fresh, it wasn't a crown buster.

No lying. Zeno was a family friend. He died a few years ago—he would send us candy for years from his store. The taffy was good, but the rest of the candy was amazing.

Btw Zeno’s son is really hot and made commercials for Noom.

More sour than salty, really, like you give a fuck.

Only if it’s pure and made the old-fashioned way by pulling.

[quote] Did you ever go to a taffy pull party?

Is that a euphemism for an orgy with guys who can't get hard?

I prefer soft salt water taffy to the hard taffy that French Canadians make.

American, soft salt water taffy is wonderful. Lost a filling to a Tootsie Roll and that was the last, sticky candy I will eat. No more Bit O Honeys or Sugar Daddies/Babies. Farewell, Charms Blow Pops.

I loved the SWT at a dive in Kenosha, WI called The Brat Stop. I'd buy a bag every time I visited.

One summer we went to Mackinaw Island and had the best fresh taffy. On a health kick, I liked orange and lime.

I really want to order taffy from OP’s link. But there’s so many flavors! Which ones do you guys recommend?

All of them! They are all delicious! I just told them I wanted a five pound bag of everything. They are used to that.

This Taffy--

Peanut butter taffy.

I like Shriver's Salt Water Taffy from the boardwalk in Ocean City, NJ. The business is even older than most DL bitches (1898).

R26 … from Dolle’s? We used to get that when I was a kid and my family went to Ocean City, down the beach from Rehoboth, every summer. My mother thought it was superior to Candy Kitchen (the taffy brand most prominently sold then and now in OC). Yes, mama trained me right for a lifetime career as a prisspot.

R35, how can you have salt water taffy on the Great Lakes? Is it called fresh water taffy?

R41 you best brush up on your saltwater taffy history!