A lot of interesting explanations in this thread.
I still watch it and enjoy it, and I found Episode 1 of Season 2 very unexpected and enjoyable, but season 2 feels very off to me. I agree it will not continue beyond Season 3. They have other opportunities to pursue…plus most of the cast is 25ish.
Nate is not scary this season, nor is Cal, which is too bad. For me, that level of sociopathy was the unexpected engine of season one. It reminds me of when daytime and nighttime soaps—even Melrose and 90210–made bad characters good. So, Nate is soon to be the neutered Fallon Carrington.
Characters (Nate and Cal) are changing too quickly: it’s not “character development,” but something else, ringing untrue. All a little too neat.
Cal and Derek missed the mark. It was nice that the flashback was not cliche, but it could have been hotter. Meanwhile, it’s hard to believe that the firecracker girl who got pregnant by Cal grew up into the dull, bovine Paula Marshall. As others have stated, the era of the flashback is all wrong for the age of his two sons. And please: I don’t know about now, but 17 year old girls from upper middle class towns (in the ‘80s, 90s, whatever it was) had abortions.
Eric Dane is not a strong enough actor for his “big scene.” Plus, the writing wasn’t very good. Just a conveniently written scene for whatever is being planned. And the reveal from Cal about the other, hotter son’s porn? Big deal. I thought it was going to be amputee porn or something equally icky.
Why does Nate’s face look completely healed after it went through a meat grinder of a beating? Why is Cal not brain damaged after being pistol whipped with a shotgun?
And if I see one more scene where there’s a false alarm…I thought Nate was going to murder Cassie (before I realized he’s nice now), I thought Cal was going to shoot Fez, I thought Cal was going to drunk drive/hit Rue and Jules and the other kid, I thought Cassie was going to fly through the windshield of Nate’s car when he was speeding, I thought Cassie was going to kill herself. I’m glad none of those things happened because they are all lame and cliche, but the audience is being manipulated…and it is annoying.
But I will continue to watch…and I am curious if Rue will be sold into slavery for doing 10K of drugs with no way to pay for it. That was a great line and that female drug dealer is a very memorable character!