I was a marching and concert band nerd in HS and college, so I love that Mahler frequently uses marches and strongly rhythmic dances. Plus he isn’t afraid to have his brass rip your face off with volume. Mahler was my first favorite composer (now, it’s R. Strauss) and was my introduction to long-form classical music in many ways. So I will always love him.
My favorite overall symphony might be 2. My imprint recording is Solti with Chicago, so I’m used to faster tempi.
Starting from most fav, the cycle for me is 2 > 3 > 1 > 4 > 7 > 9 > 6 > 5 > 10 > 8.
Other fav recordings are 3 (rare Haitink recording with VPO), 1 (Abbado and BPO), 4 (tennstedt with LPO), 7 (Abbado and BPO, Although Lenny and NYPO give a better start for the Finale), 9 (Boulez and CSO), 6 (Abbado and BPO), 5 (Abbado and BPO)
Fav moments are:
1 - 2nd mov overall
2 - March of the dead after the low brass chorale section of the 5th movement. It’s so thrilling! I always have to stand up and conduct a phantom orchestra. The climaxes during the 3rd mov are awesome as well, plus the charming clarinet lines.
3 - the 3 buildups and climaxes of the first movement. Exciting and hell to conduct and track the flow of the melodies around the orchestra. The choral movement is also fantastic, as is the adagio. The snippets from his songs and the content shared with the 4th symphony make this one a favorite.
4 - So gentle and welcoming. I heard this one in HS French class as we watched the film “La Maitre de Musique” with Jose Van Dame. The whole first movement is a joy, as is the Ruhevoll. And the last movement donated from the 3rd symphony is lovely.
5 - The horn scherzo is a showpiece and everybody loves the Adagietto.
6 - Many have mentioned the gorgeous Andante. The large orchestral parts to the final movement are also fantastic. He keeps a really nice even meter that makes the music fun to anticipate and feel catharsis.
7 - A gorgeous and often hated work. The end of the first movement is so much fun. The drama with the exaggerated triple meter is excellent, bouncing between the brass and strings. Plus the finale is my favorite in all of Mahler’s music. Just straight heat from the first timpani hits and the horn calls. The brass stays powerful and the strings give such glorious sounds. The meter jumps around, so you really have to pay attention to stay on beat. There’s a portion maybe 2/3 of the way through where the brass have a solo chorale and it’s just. Perfect. Then the strings come in and you get the thrilling conclusion. So good.
8 - hate it
9 - The first mov is lovely. But my favorite is the second movement and the great lines for low brass and horns.