Who was more beautiful in their prime: Sharon Stone or Michelle Pfeiffer?

Who is posing such questions on a gay forum?! First Pamela and Anna Nicole, now this. I can't imagine lesbians comparing, say, Brad Pitt and Tom Cruise for hotness. WTF?

Michelle Pfeiffer. She is classy, has a good career, and would stay home to help raise the kids.

Sharon Stone would ruin your life.

This thread is suitable only for lesbians and/or hairdressers.

Michelle was always prettier to me and I love her voice.

Sharon Stone for me.

Sharon has more of a hardness about her (resting bitch face?) but her statuesque figure and long legs made her a stand out.

Michelle's jawline is as outsized and distracting as Rachel's

Stone; no question.

Team Pfeiffer

I asked my het brother, for fun. He replied, "Stone. I've seen her pussy."

I'm with the Pfeiffer camp. She is white woman "exotic". But my opinion probably doesn't matter, as is made obvious above.

Sharon Stone is the more traditional beauty.

Pfeiffer has a unique face which isn’t quite as accessible

Yes, R11, I don't access it.

Stone is sexier but Pfeiffer is more luminous and the superior actress. As good as Basic Instinct and Casino were, Stone has nothing that's equivalent to The Fabulous Baker Boys or Batman Returns. That said, Pfeiffer's also done her share of shit.

Oh, and I'm a card-carrying lesbian. (The cards are for Costco and the library since we're a practical people.)

Stone is very very pretty and has loads of charisma. Phieffer is a beauty to the point that she would have been successful with a third of her talent level. Amazing bone structure.

"Michelle Pfeiffer, that white gold!!!"

Sharon is the prettiest. Michelle is a bit bland.

Michelle Pfeiffer is less generic-looking. However, once somebody (here on DL) pointed out her nose job, I started noticing it. I'm sure Sharon Stone has had plastic surgery here and there, but I can't point something out as obvious.

Michelle Pfeiffer

Michelle...Stone was/is more generic.

R18, yeah I hate to say it but her nose does look quite unnatural ... a shame she didn't just leave it alone or at least go to a better surgeon and get a more subtle result. It almost reminds me of a Jackson nose.

Sharon was a marvel of reinvention. The nerdy PA farmgirl teen lost weight, straightened/bleached her hair and became a stunner. Unfortunately in the 80s she had poor management and no direction, losing valuable ingenue years.

"Total Recall" saved her from obscurity.

I have to go with Sharon because Michelle had extensive plastic surgery to become “beautiful.”

Michelle is cold on screen

Sharon Pfeiffer.

Michelle before surgery

No contest

I don't think Michelle was ever really beautiful in the classic sense. She's charismatic, sexy and alluring on screen. Talented. But Sharon is more conventionally beautiful. I find Michelle more interesting to look at personally. Sharon is boring.

Michelle was very pretty in high school

When she had her original face?

Sharon also went under the knife.

Sharon is more masc, Michelle more fem/vulnerable.

I love them both.

R31, what did she have done?

Sharon originally looked Jewish

She looked Jewish? How so? I didn't know only Jews had dark hair.

She looks like a typical white American woman before and after. This site cracks me up.

Pam Lee, Anna, Michelle,

I don’t care for Sharon Stone or her looks.

Sharon has changed her face many, many times.

Sharon seems more for straight guys and lesbians. Clearly a lust object. Michelle more for gay guys and straight women. Interesting, quirky and more stylish.

Sharon looked attractive in high school. She's naturally pretty. Beautiful cheekbones and eyes. All she did was dye her hair blonde and voila became a model.

They both win for MOST plastic surgery.

[post redacted because linking to dailymail.co.uk clearly indicates that the poster is either a troll or an idiot (probably both, honestly.) Our advice is that you just ignore this poster but whatever you do, don't click on any link to this putrid rag.]

Yikes. Sharon wants to speak to the manager.

I think Madonna was more beautiful than both of them.

"I don't think Michelle was ever really beautiful in the classic sense."

Only on DL, ladies and gentlemen. Step right up.

Sharon Stone

Michelle has those wide set eyes that really made her stand out. Sharon was more classically beautiful. An American ideal. I found Michelle much more striking and interesting to look at.

Team Pfeiffer!

Stone

It's a tie...

Pfeiffer, aside from the terrible 80s hair, frosted and permed. She's perfect in Age of Innocence, save the hair, for example.

Sharon is sexier, pheiffer is more delicate . Both are knockouts.

Stone

Sharon Stone.

Tiebreaker Halle Berry for the win.

Pfieffer

Pfeiffer. No contest.

In the Basic Instinct script, Catherine is described as classically beautiful but not knockout gorgeous like Roxy.

Michelle by far. Never saw the attraction to Sharon physically. Also kind of a low rent actress other than Basic Instinct.

Madonna looks like a cross between both of them.

I'd love to see Michelle P-Feiffer give Sharon Stone a slap in the p-face.

Not sure I could tell them apart if you gave me $1000.

Stone had energy, Pfeiffer had elegance. Two looks but if I had to choose, Stone by a pubic hair.

Michelle Pfeiffer hands down. Much more beautiful than the hard-looking Stone.

R59 is blind and has dementia.

Stone has a very sexual beauty. Michele is more of a classic beauty.

Kim Basinger beats them both.

Cathy Zeta Jones in her prime easily defeated both.

Fire and Ice.

The Sharon troll who insists she was AMAZING in Basic Instinct and Casino is back. She was fine in two very stilted performances. She can never disappear into a character and inhabit.

R69, what do you think of Pfeiffer's acting?

An early '80s Heather Locklear smoked both of them.

Heather was beautiful but she had crazy eyes. That's why she was so good at playing crazy bitches.

Sharon Mitchell, MD to the porn stars.

Pfeiffer. Always.

[quote]Kim Basinger beats them both.

Ahhh, "9 1/2 Weeks," she and Mickey Rourke were beautiful then. (You can leave your hat on.)

Heather Thomas was the hotter Heather of the two.

I was never a Basinger fan, but I certainly rank her a lot higher than Sharon Stone. Her work has aged better than I remember.

Madonna

Sharon looks divine in the first scene of this screen test, maybe (and I’m not intending to be mean) because the video’s gone a little fuzzy with time.

In general I prefer Pfeiffer, though. Sharon’s a little soulless, as a rule. Great performance as a hard edged survivor in CASINO, tho.

This should've been a poll

R34 She was still a beauty even with the Hasidic curls.

Sharon Stone.

Mary Grace Canfield or Nancy Kulp?

Sharon Mitchell or Seka?

Annie Sprinkle or Little Oral Annie?

Stone

Pfeiffer.

Michelle Pfeiffer. Even today she’s still drop dead gorgeous.

Some people were just born to be stars.

Madonna over both combined

Stone

Madonna’s latest incarnation is Man in the Moon