"Who all"

Hoosier here. Sounds totally normal.

Well, I've never not heard it in all my life.

"Okay, I mean, who all is even going to the party?" is much more of a 2021 way to ask that question.

The first time I heard it was when I moved to Texas...the answer is usually "You all (Y'all)"

I was in one of the tennis threads and asked “who all is playing today?” - someone linked an article about the phrase “who all” and didn’t answer my fucking question…

What was the question, R5?

[quote] "Who all is going to the party?"

Who all goin'?

Jus Poochie an them.

Rest-a us ain't messin wit it.

Normal speech in St. Louis and environs.

I forget which tournament R6 (maybe the Olympics and I can’t look back since all our threads keep getting deleted!) but I just asked “who all is playing today?”

I just thought it was funny that I got called out for that and still didn’t get an answer. 😂 Why take the time to link an article about my random phrase?

R9, you should’ve asked “Who all is GOAT?” That would’ve generated numerous vitriolic responses.

Yup, I’m 50 a d although haven’t lived in Kansas since I was 22, I still say it.

Who all says this?

Haha! “Who all”.

Todo el mundo!

I've said that on more than one occasion and was born and raised in Chicago. But I would never say you all or y'all, but you guys... that's Chicagoese second person plural.

[quote] The first time I heard it was when I moved to Texas...the answer is usually "You all (Y'all)"

"All y'all" would be an an alternate, acceptable answer.

If you're invited to a party and you're not sure if you want to go to the party, then you ask:

[quote] Who all is going?

R17, why not just ask “Who is going?”

I heard this whenever I made my First Communion. The priest asked: who all is going to the reception?

Is “who all” the cousin of “y’all”?

I heard they totally fucked, btw. 😱

Pennsylvania here. I am sure I've said it more than once.

Youse is an acceptable alternative.

R22 = Pittsburger.

[quote] Is “who all” the cousin of “y’all”? I heard they totally fucked, btw. 😱

They must be native West Virginians.

Haha! “Who all”.

From Maryland and I say both “who all” and “you all.” I never say “y’all” and I find it annoying when non-Southerners try to adopt “y’all” and act like it’s natural.

Chinese Texans greet one another with a "Ni hao y'all".

[quote] Chinese Texans greet one another with a "Ni hao y'all".

Sum Ting Wong!

Sounds normal to me. The second person plural equivalent is "all y'all." "Y'all" is a polite form of address and it grates on my nervous when people use it in an impersonal way.

Do the children on Welcome to Plathville use this?

New Yorker and Floridian and I have heard / said... Y'all, We all, and Who all. I don't think it's a regionalism.

It's commonly used in southern Wisconsin, as well. Maybe it's just an Americanism?

Haha. “Who all”

I grew up in SoCal and moved to Chicago in the 90s and "who all" and "you guys" is common in both places.

I grew up in New England and nobody said this. I recall hearing it from Texans and Californians I went to school with.

Who all is definitely used in New York by many of its ethnic groups.

“Who all”.

Haha. “Who all”.