This is longish, so forgive me. It's been weighing on me because it's very fresh.
I've been seeing this man monogamously for six months. We have a great time together, have a lot in common, have great sex, and talk or at least text every day. He's been consistently wary of using the terms "boyfriend" and "relationship," but for all intents and purposes, that's what we have been doing. We both put in the effort to spend every other weekend together. Because we live three hours apart, it is an intentional and meaningful choice to use our time to be together, and we tend to go to places we've never been and have cool experiences together. It takes thought, planning, money and time on both of our parts. Thus, there is a heightened sense of excitement and anticipation every time we get together.
So typically, we'll be having a weekend, and it's great. And then at some point, towards the end of the weekend, sometimes even after a round of farewell sex, he might say something suddenly like "What if one of us meets another fella? I don't want either of us to be wasting our time." And it takes me off guard. I'll get upset. Then it's "I didn't mean that, I don't know why I said that." And then a few days later he might send me a gift, like an LP or something.
It was becoming this weird cycle. I started getting anticipatory anxiety about our trips. Finally about a month ago, I put my foot down and say, I cannot keep doing this, this is making me feel crazy. Figure out what you want. He says "I want you. I want you in my life. I love you." He promises that the next trip there will be no sudden shocks, no revelations, only togetherness and fun.
Okay, fast-forward a couple weeks to our next trip. We go upstate. It's idyllic. We go to the theater, and then stop at a bar afterwards. We'd been lovey dovey all night. A couple drinks in, I causally call to the bartender "Hey, are you still making my boyfriend's cocktail?" Well, my guy, right then and there, says very loudly -- "WAIT, WHEN DID I EVER SAY WE WERE DOING THAT?" It was like a sudden slap upside the head. To my mind, I'd just used "boyfriend" casually as shorthand to remind the bartender to make "the guy sitting next to me"'s drink. I was so embarrassed and hurt. We had had THE BEST night. Now there was, once again, awkwardness.
We trudged back to the Air BnB in silence. Inside the apartment, we didn't get into it, but he did apologize. We took our clothes off, got in bed and were holding each other. Then I made the mistake of opening a can of worms by saying, "Can I please ask, what is the big deal about me calling you my boyfriend casually? Like...what is the harm of that? We are exclusive, and you tell me that you love me daily. It just feels like I should be able to say it, even accidentally, without these repercussions. Please help me understand."
He pauses to think for a moment, and then says "I just have this sense - this gnawing feeling in my gut - that there is someone right for me. And it's not you."
I realized recently that my grandmother used to criticize me, my looks, my worth, my hobbies, my friends. But then buy me stuff and tell me that she loved me. So I think my tolerance for ambiguity and emotional fuckery is really high. Like, "you are rejecting me but you're still fucking me, and somehow you still claim that you love me. And that is so much better than nothing."