Have you ever turned a straight guy?

In 1983 when I was 19 I talked to a 17-year-old senior into letting me suck his dick. He was a major jock (football, basketball, baseball and wrestling). He had a really hot body and I had heard that he had a big dick (he did and it is a slightly longer than average and really thick) and he had lost his virginity at 14.

The first time I sucked his dick I made him come twice and afterwards he told me he had never been able to come from getting head.

He would come to see me about once a month and I would blow him and then after about a year he got brave enough to try fucking me.

After he started fucking me he started coming around 2 to 3 times a month.

I never question him about his sexuality (I saw no need) but from time to time he would tell me he was fucking this girl or that girl. I didn’t care because I was getting some good dick.

In 1995 our sex did a complete 180 after I rimmed him for the first time. That put him in touch with his back door.

Between 1995 and 2014 he became a very enthusiastic and somewhat bossy bottom. He only fucked me one more time after the first time I fucked him.

There were times he would come over and undress and bend over the edge of my bed with his ass stuck up in the air without saying a word.

The last five or six years we saw each other he would suck my dick, I would rim him and then fuck him and I believe I only sucked his dick three times.

We stop seeing each other by mutual agreement when I met the man I would eventually marry. Within a few months I heard that he had met the man that is now his partner.

I had some of the best sex I’ve ever had during the 31 1/2 years we saw each other and I never felt the need to label him “gay”, “bisexual” or “straight”.

No but I've turned plenty the other way.

R1 I like your story but you went monogamous after being a slut forever?

Meh, if you “turned” them they were never straight to begin with but enjoy your fantasies, ladies.

I knew a straight who claimed I was the only guy who turned him on. He was married and had kids. He claimed I seduced him. I told him I didn't believe it but he insisted it was true. I'm hardly the type to turn anyone gay or at the very least make them want to experiment. Let's just say I'm the polar opposite of JFK Jr. or closer to Shrek.

"No but I've turned plenty the other way."

Wait, you did what now? You converted gay boys?

Never looked at them. There were some who would jack off with closet cases in high school and they turned me off. I strictly looked at the nelly shop bottoms in malls and bookstores. Hated the straights, many of whom married Asians eventually to further be more disgusting in their racism and closet space. Maybe because I have always been a top, but I always sought the effeminate and adorable older bottoms. Heterosexual men are as interesting as Wonder bread.

I guess I’m just not powerful enough to “turn someone gay.”

That’s the secret! Rim a straight guy, and he’ll turn into a bossy bottom. Too bad I found this out so late in life.

I've turned a few over a chair, yes

Today's trade is tomorrow's competition.

Straight men have flirted with me and said they would hook up with me if they were gay but never actually became physical. Suits me, I'd much rather a 100% gay guy who craves my cock like a fat kid wants cake.

Bump

I don't think I'd say I ever turned straight men gay, but I will say I gave some deeply closeted dudes some tense moments. I got hit on by so many "straight" guys in school.

I dated a dongful guy from DC that would come to NYC every other weekend to see me. It became tedious because he always wanted to go clubbing and stay out very late. I was an androgynous club kid (think Annie Lenox) and knew everyone back then, and we went to

I knew I was looking Brad Pitt good that night, and at one point I was walking along the edge of the dance floor, and literally every gorgeous straight dude rolling on Molly chatted me up and flirted openly with me. The boyfriend was in tow and was like “How do you know him?” After the 6th or 7th time, he walked away in a huff and I really wish I’d been alone that night!

We broke up a few weeks later.

Crobar. We went to Crobar, which after Twilo closed was the penultimate place to find a gorgeous straight guy that dabbled in the homosex.

R16 Do you know what “penultimate” means?

It's true that rimming will do it. I had a straight friend who was Italian. Hot, beautiful hair and eyes. Really nice hairy body. Once when we were drunk, I talked him into a blow job. I sucked his cock and then moved down to his balls. And then I started licking his taint..He was surprised at first, but then he started moaning. He loved it. I jerked him off while licking his hot hairy ass and he shot a giant load. After that, we.acted like it never happened, but he asked me a few times if I'd lick his ass. Of course I obliged, but after every time, it was always like nothing happened. J haven't really been in touch with him lately,but he.was married for about a month, had several engagements that always ended up in breakups, and always acted.like a macho man. But I think he misses that ass action. I know from my own experience that once you've had cock and male asshole, pussy just doesn't cut it anymore.

I prefer to avoid straight guys outside of work situations.

Yes!

- Aaron Schock’s Congressional gilded eagle coffee table

I was the first guy to fuck a 26-year-old UW-Madison assistant professor who had recently separated from his wife, but why he ever got married to a woman was the puzzle. He seemed primed for gaydom, despite mooning over his ex.

Can't say I turned him, but I didn't turn him off, either. All I know is he never went back to women.

R21 if he bottomed for you, then that’s off topic and nobody cares. Keep it to yourself!