My high school crush has gotten even cuter

Big face.

Wow, that's a whole lot of MEH!

Maybe he's cuter in person

nice eyebrows and jaw

OP you should've posted a pic of him instead of whatever that fug is.

OP = Helen Keller

Is that fug you OP?

OP by cuter do you mean a great personality?

Quite the attractive young man, OP!

Did he also wear makeup in high school?

He’s fine. The bigger question: OP did you guys fuck?

I never saw a gecko with hair before.

Is this a Halloween photoshop?

He's porking up is op a chubby chaser?

He doesn't mention you, OP. I'm sorry.

Does he know you're posting his pic

I'm sure he has lovely handwriting, OP.

I bet he hasn't thought about you once in twenty years.

He didn't even know I existed. He was a lacrosse player. No hint of him being gay at all. But he had such a swagger about him. His confidence (along with his being a really nice guy) was so hot. And really hairy chest!

I see it, OP. I suppose you have various stories for the "high school gym showers" threads?

Did you ever drop your shower gel on purpose in the shower next to him?

He looks like a thumb.

He looks reptilian.

I’d let him fuck me and maybe even cum in my hole

Damn I am sure glad I didn't go to your high school OP.

Does Dan know you are posting photos of him?

His face looks like a reflection from a funhouse mirror.

That’s just too much eyebrows

Where did you guys grow up? Some hick town? In the South?

He smiles like a sloth 🦥

He looks like a lesbian.

With apologies to Dorothy Parker, but he looks like something that would eat his young.

My high school crush. Well actually college. I took video game programming from him online

He's horrifically unattractive.

R32 looks FtM.

My high school crush had a great name, Charlie Steuber -- this was in North Carolina in the 1980s, and he also had, besides a rocking muscular body and thick, dark hair, a sweet southern accent. He was the captain of the wrestling team. Apparently he never got married and still lives in our home town near Charlotte. Guess being cute then doesn't mean much now. Like OP.

I had no high school crush. I had a summer camp crush. I still think about his lips and eyelashes.

I can’t even remember the names of my high school crushes.

Michael something or other was one

Looks like a brunette Barney Rubble.

Mine was a quarterback and kissed me once in Family Living class as we were getting dressed for a mock wedding we were in . Hes now 350 lbs,bald and on his 4th marriage . bet i know why .

Gross. Mine is now a great big fat person married to the queen of the fraus

My high school crush peaked at 25. He didn't get fat or anything, he just sort of aged out of his looks. I've seen him a few times and he avoids me, mostly because he's afraid I'll tell his wife he used to make out with boys at the gay bars. Which I wouldn't do. I may be a cunt, but I'm not a nasty cunt. There is a difference.