We made a reservation for 4 at Grand Banks Café in New York City, and then at the last minute we couldn't show up. We were then informed that we were to be charged a $435 fee, a $35 cancellation fee, plus $100 per person. Is the Grand Banks Cafe that special? I've never heard of such a thing, is this normal?
$435 cancellation fee?
|by Anonymous||reply 57||Last Saturday at 4:30 PM|
No. Why in the hell would they even have your credit card info??
Humblebrag or full of shit. You be the judge.
|by Anonymous||reply 1||Last Friday at 8:25 PM|
I've heard of places in NYC that charge you if you don't show - that's been going on many years.
But that's excessive - I would dispute the charge.
|by Anonymous||reply 2||Last Friday at 8:26 PM|
Also OP, their website clearly says $25 fee per person for cancellations. You might want to fight that.
|by Anonymous||reply 3||Last Friday at 8:28 PM|
It's been going on for a while at marquee restaurants.
|by Anonymous||reply 4||Last Friday at 8:28 PM|
Why didn't y'all just grab a whopper? Or a double Baconator.
|by Anonymous||reply 5||Last Friday at 8:29 PM|
[quote] We made a reservation for 4 at Grand Banks Café in New York City,
No, you didn't.
|by Anonymous||reply 6||Last Friday at 8:31 PM|
NYC is one giant scam. You got got. Move on.
|by Anonymous||reply 7||Last Friday at 8:33 PM|
Tell them everyone in your party tested positive for COVID the day of the reservation.
|by Anonymous||reply 8||Last Friday at 8:34 PM|
Yes we did! They said we had reserved a private dining room, which was news to us. They also told us there would be a charge if we didn’t show up, but they never said how much. The website says there is a $35 fee for cancellations, but the $100 per person fee was because we had reserved a private dining room, which we had not realized we were doing.
Why is this a humblebrag? Is this a really chic restaurant?
|by Anonymous||reply 9||Last Friday at 8:36 PM|
Why are you speaking in third person?
|by Anonymous||reply 10||Last Friday at 8:39 PM|
Yes I did. We were told we had reserved a private dining room, which was news to us! There is indeed a $35 cancellation fee, but the $100 per person charge was because of the private dining room, which as I said, we didn’t know we were hiring. Certainly nobody told us about a potential $435 charge.
Why is this a humblebrag? Is this a really chic restaurant?
|by Anonymous||reply 11||Last Friday at 8:40 PM|
Sorry about the double post
|by Anonymous||reply 12||Last Friday at 8:41 PM|
Call and tell them you are going to dispute the charge with your card company because they did not tell you that you were being put in a private dining room and the website says 35 dollars cancellation fee. They are trying to screw you over because they need money and figure their clientele generally won't dispute it
|by Anonymous||reply 13||Last Friday at 8:54 PM|
Stick to golden corral OP
|by Anonymous||reply 14||Last Friday at 9:04 PM|
I usually just grab a sleeve of saltines and sit on the curb. No charge.
|by Anonymous||reply 15||Last Friday at 9:10 PM|
Call your credit card company and dispute the charge. The restaurant will have to prove that you were aware of the charges beforehand. The $100 per person charge had to be as clearly stated as the $35 charge.
|by Anonymous||reply 16||Last Friday at 9:24 PM|
It is quite rude to make reservations some where and not show up, or call to cancel.
|by Anonymous||reply 17||Last Friday at 9:29 PM|
Why would 4 people need a private dining room?
|by Anonymous||reply 18||Last Friday at 9:33 PM|
Big fat ugly people that other diners don't want in their field of vision, r18?
|by Anonymous||reply 19||Last Friday at 9:35 PM|
Larry David did an episode on that.
|by Anonymous||reply 20||Last Friday at 9:37 PM|
Here’s what you should do. You should find a police officer and tell him you were assaulted by a horrible man in a restaurant and bring the policeman to the restaurant. When you see the manager let out a high pitched scream and then point at him and cry “THAT’S the man, officer!”
|by Anonymous||reply 21||Last Friday at 9:37 PM|
I'm not sure I like what you are implying r21.
|by Anonymous||reply 22||Last Friday at 9:43 PM|
We have never had that experience at The Cracker Barrell!
|by Anonymous||reply 23||Last Friday at 9:44 PM|
Today I ordered the double hamburgers off the McDonalds 2 for $3 menu and they only gave me single hamburgers. I didn't realize it until I got home. I feel your pain, OP.
|by Anonymous||reply 24||Last Friday at 10:38 PM|
Yeah - unless that had communicated that you would be in a private dining room and there was an additional charge, then they can't do that.
Besides, most places in NYC will have drop-ins or last minute calls to fill the table. Particularly for 4 people.
This is bullshit - and leave a really awful review.
|by Anonymous||reply 25||Last Saturday at 5:16 AM|
OP, you cannot make a reservation for something that you don't even know about.
A dishonest staff member can place your reservation in a private dining room without telling you, but then that staff member is the party booking the room. Not you. Staff was not following your instructions. That is what matters. Let the management exact its revenge on its staff member.
Also look at the statute of frauds. There should be a writing memorializing an agreement for a charge over $500. No writing... no obligation.
|by Anonymous||reply 26||Last Saturday at 5:36 AM|
I don't believe this at all. How did they charge you? How did they have your credit card information? I've never had to give my credit card info out when making a reservation. This is a FAKE story OP.
|by Anonymous||reply 27||Last Saturday at 5:40 AM|
I don’t believe any of this for a single minute!!
|by Anonymous||reply 28||Last Saturday at 5:53 AM|
Were you going to sample their Autumn Harvest?
|by Anonymous||reply 29||Last Saturday at 6:10 AM|
A sample would be more Once Around the Garden.
|by Anonymous||reply 30||Last Saturday at 6:18 AM|
R27, some of the fine dining establishments, you do have to leave a credit card for a reservation, especially if they have a cancellation policy that charges you for no shows or last minute cancellations.
|by Anonymous||reply 31||Last Saturday at 6:25 AM|
Lucky for me we don’t have that problem here.
|by Anonymous||reply 32||Last Saturday at 6:28 AM|
When did DL become Yelp?
|by Anonymous||reply 33||Last Saturday at 6:37 AM|
Every time a bottom gets entered.
Oh, you meant the website. Whoops.
|by Anonymous||reply 34||Last Saturday at 6:41 AM|
R27, R31 is right. Higher end restaurants in many cities, not just NYC, do require a credit card and will charge you a fee for no-shows or cancellations.
There was a story about a couple in Chicago who couldn't get a babysitter and brought their baby to Alinea and it cried the entire time, ruining the meal for everyone in the dining room. They didn't want to be charged the $500 or $600 cancellation fee.
Alinea is ranked among the top 5 restaurants in the US and it's a pre-fixe, but it stands that it isn't unusual to give your credit card at reservation time.
|by Anonymous||reply 35||Last Saturday at 6:43 AM|
Dispute the “private room” fee, but the $35 is fair.
My husband got an indoor seat at a neighborhood bar last night (indoor seating at 25% capacity) and he was happy to get it (pays to be a regular and a good tipper!). I’m sure those spots will be at a premium now that the weather is turning cold.
|by Anonymous||reply 36||Last Saturday at 6:48 AM|
[quote]It is quite rude to make reservations some where and not show up, or call to cancel.
"at the last minute we couldn't show up. We were then informed that we were to be charged a $435 fee, a $35 cancellation fee, plus $100 per person." Sounds to me like they informed the restaurant they were cancelling.
This is an arrangement with a business, not a social contract. Not a question of manners. The point is he's being charged over 400 dollars for cancelling when he should be being charged 35 dollars.
|by Anonymous||reply 37||Last Saturday at 6:49 AM|
I think charging for no-shows in a restaurant is just wrong. Yes, I know hotels do that and am not a fan of that either; but I can (sort of) understand why hotels do it.
I would think at this point restaurants would be trying to generate goodwill with diners who are actually willing to eat inside at your establishment. I cannot believe that you cancelling your reservation prevented several other parties from being able to make a reservation.
Credit card companies need to disallow restaurants from doing this.
|by Anonymous||reply 38||Last Saturday at 6:58 AM|
|by Anonymous||reply 39||Last Saturday at 7:04 AM|
R27 - I guess I didn't know that "fancy" restaurants required CC info when taking reservations. If I were asked my CC info when making a reservation, IO would politely decline and make plans for another restaurant.
|by Anonymous||reply 40||Last Saturday at 7:09 AM|
[quote] I cannot believe that you cancelling your reservation prevented several other parties from being able to make a reservation
If restaurants are allowed to operate with reduced, it's highly likely that, by holding this reservation, they had to turn away other potential diners. Because of the lack of nightlife and tourists, there aren't a lot of people roaming the streets looking for a place to eat, everything these days is pretty much planned out, so drops ins are rare, especially at a destination restaurant on a boat in the river.
I looked at photos and I don't see any 'private dining room', but that doesn't mean there isn't one.
Their website states there is a $25 fee (not $35) for reservations not cancelled within 24 hours. I think that's reasonable. They do not accept cancelations by phone so you don't even have to talk to a person.
The restaurant sets aside a table for 4, thereby precluding them from accepting another party of 4 or two parties of 2, and these clowns don't show up? If the average ticket is $125 (which is what it seems to cost every time my partner and I go out) that's $500 in lost revenue. I think a cancellation fee is definitely in order, but unless they agreed to a higher fee, the $25 stated fee is what should be charged.
|by Anonymous||reply 41||Last Saturday at 7:25 AM|
R34, that made my day.
|by Anonymous||reply 42||Last Saturday at 7:29 AM|
R41 - but they probably had some walk-ins or stand-bys who would gladly take the table. People still call or show-up at last-minute to see if there are openings.
I don't have a problem with a reasonable cancellation fee - but this is outrageous.
I also believe that, if you show up more than 15-30 minutes late for a reservation, you lose it. I had a friend who was a host in a restaurant and people showed up late ALL THE TIME. Like 30 minutes or an hour late.
Their usual excuse? Traffic or parking. That's not an excuse and you can't hold tables making no revenue for an hour.
|by Anonymous||reply 43||Last Saturday at 7:39 AM|
There is no "Grand Banks Café" in NYC (it's the name of a novel). There is a "Grand Banks" oyster bar at the Piers. Is that what you meant, OP? I never heard of them having a private dining room.
|by Anonymous||reply 44||Last Saturday at 7:40 AM|
Only the most in-demand restaurants can get away with this.
|by Anonymous||reply 45||Last Saturday at 7:50 AM|
[quote] There is no "Grand Banks Café" in NYC
Thats important. OP's thread collapse is now complete. Even if there was a GBC, he didn't have a reservation, four friends or $435.
|by Anonymous||reply 46||Last Saturday at 7:57 AM|
"Only the most in-demand restaurants can get away with this."
Only the most in-demand restaurants in NYC = mediocre joint in any other burg in the USA.
The self-described sophisticates of NYC wouldn't know true sophistication if it bit them in the ass.
Aren't Rudy Giuliani and the entire Trump clan "sophisticated" New Yorkers?
|by Anonymous||reply 47||Last Saturday at 7:59 AM|
Sounds like the kind of slow turnover place where the ingredients for their specialty items have been sitting in a freezer for months or years. That's why I go to MacDonald's (Or lately a MacDonald's drive through).
|by Anonymous||reply 48||Last Saturday at 8:09 AM|
[quote] Aren't Rudy Giuliani and the entire Trump clan "sophisticated" New Yorkers?
|by Anonymous||reply 49||Last Saturday at 8:13 AM|
I just called Grand Banks Oyster and they have NO SUCH policy!! You are a liar OP!!
|by Anonymous||reply 50||Last Saturday at 2:27 PM|
OP here...I'm talking about the restaurant on 25 Hudson River Park, is that the one you mean? I've never actually been there.
As I stated earlier, we had inadvertently booked a private dining room, and was then charged $100 per person for that. If you're calling them up, ask about the fee for missing a private dining room reservation.
|by Anonymous||reply 51||Last Saturday at 3:25 PM|
Restaurants are in rough shape financially, so it’s possible they’re going to be very restrictive and gouge customers to try and recover lost revenue from period of closure during the pandemic. But, yes, that sounds extreme.
|by Anonymous||reply 52||Last Saturday at 3:33 PM|
[quote]That's why I go to MacDonald's (Or lately a MacDonald's drive through).
Is this some new restaurant? I’m sure the McDonald’s corporate office would like to have a word or two about their potential trademark.
|by Anonymous||reply 53||Last Saturday at 3:49 PM|
[quote]We have a 15 minute grace period on reservations, after which your table may be given to another party. If you arrive after the grace period, we will still honor your reservation by providing you with the first available table. In the event of a completely missed reservation without 24 hour notice of cancelation, a fee of $25 per guest will apply.
|by Anonymous||reply 54||Last Saturday at 4:20 PM|
Oh, dear, R35.
Pas de gâteau pour vous ce soir.
|by Anonymous||reply 55||Last Saturday at 4:28 PM|
I would have just gone alone.
|by Anonymous||reply 56||Last Saturday at 4:30 PM|
r47 is correct.
|by Anonymous||reply 57||Last Saturday at 4:30 PM|