Premieres Sunday night (July 19) on TNT.
Starring Daniel Bruhl, Luke Evans, and Dakota Fanning.
It was a smash hit with Dataloungers last year. Will you be watching?
Hello and thank you for being a DL contributor. We are changing the login scheme for contributors for simpler login and to better support using multiple devices. Please click here to update your account with a username and password.
Hello. Some features on this site require registration. Please click here to register for free.
Hello and thank you for registering. Please complete the process by verifying your email address. If you can't find the email you can resend it here.
Hello. Some features on this site require a subscription. Please click here to get full access and no ads for $1.99 or less per month.
Premieres Sunday night (July 19) on TNT.
Starring Daniel Bruhl, Luke Evans, and Dakota Fanning.
It was a smash hit with Dataloungers last year. Will you be watching?
|by Anonymous||reply 241||11 hours ago|
I love this show. I hope there will be more seasons even though there aren't any more books to adapt aside from a prequel and a story set in modern times.
|by Anonymous||reply 1||07/16/2020|
|by Anonymous||reply 2||07/17/2020|
Yeah, the first season was fantastic.
|by Anonymous||reply 3||07/17/2020|
I wish Daniel Brühl would present dong one more time before her gets too old.
|by Anonymous||reply 4||07/17/2020|
Did he do it before, R4?
Are there photos?
|by Anonymous||reply 5||07/17/2020|
here you are, R5
|by Anonymous||reply 6||07/17/2020|
|by Anonymous||reply 7||07/17/2020|
Bruhl is unremarkable looking but I find him very sexy.
I liked the book better but the first season was decent and of course the cast is terrific. I'm in for season 2.
|by Anonymous||reply 8||07/17/2020|
Same here, R8.
Bruhl has a quiet sort of attractiveness.
Luke is just gorgeous in season one.
I'm hoping that Brian Geraghty returns as Theodore Roosevelt. I loved him in Chicago P.D., and I think he was good in The Alienist.
I also liked Douglas Smith as the police detective. Especially when he bared his ass!
|by Anonymous||reply 9||07/17/2020|
Will there be more "boy whores" this season?
|by Anonymous||reply 10||07/17/2020|
Fuck YEAH!! Can’t wait!!!!!
|by Anonymous||reply 11||07/17/2020|
I'm in. I loved Caleb Carr's novels and find this era in NY fascinating.
|by Anonymous||reply 12||07/17/2020|
I'm watching season one On Demand, and it's really good.
Very suspenseful, and it also showcased not only NYC but the wealth disparity happening at that time.
Interestingly, it's very similar to today.
|by Anonymous||reply 13||07/17/2020|
What happened to the Luke Evans character, after he was drugged in the boy whore bar?
I think that someone "took advantage" of him.
|by Anonymous||reply 14||07/17/2020|
I loved Luke Evans in the Alienist
|by Anonymous||reply 15||07/17/2020|
I liked the first book more than this one. Still will watch.
|by Anonymous||reply 16||07/17/2020|
The first series was good but not outstanding. I wish they'd replace Dakota Fanning as she was the weak link in the cast.
Will still watch this new series as I didn't read that novel. The only other Carr book I read was the more recent SURRENDER NY, which was nothing more than an overwritten James Patterson-level novel.
|by Anonymous||reply 17||07/17/2020|
Season one, episode two was amazing.
For anyone who doesn't think that Italians weren't the "Mexicans" of the early 1900's, then watch this episode. It shows them crowded in tenements, not speaking English, and living in squalor. It's a real eye-opener.
The grittiness of New York that the episode captures, is so vivid.
Throughout the series, you really get the feeling that you are transported back in time.
That is of course, until you hear some of the characters speak (as if they were living in 2018).
The scenery, the costumes and the styling were spot-on. The characters, not so much.
I give Bruhl and Evans a lot of credit, for being right in character. As mentioned above, Fanning really is the weak link.
|by Anonymous||reply 18||07/17/2020|
Carr also wrote "The Italian Secretary". About Mary Queen of Scots, Earl of Bothwell, and, well, her Italian Secretary (Rizzo) who was murdered by her batshit crazy husband and his friends. Pretty good Holmes story.
|by Anonymous||reply 19||07/17/2020|
R14 I thought that they stripped him naked and that the prostitutes all posed on bed with him while the owners of the brothel took pictures to use as blackmail material.
|by Anonymous||reply 20||07/17/2020|
R20, I like to think the boy whores also took turns riding his cock.
|by Anonymous||reply 21||07/17/2020|
I agree that Fanning is the weak link
|by Anonymous||reply 22||07/17/2020|
I loved the first season, I didn't realize they would do another one.
Where will they go?
|by Anonymous||reply 23||07/17/2020|
So we have to tune in weekly?
No binge-watch unless I wait until the end of the season?
|by Anonymous||reply 24||07/17/2020|
I swore that the sequel was about a female serial killer, but the trailer and wiki write up didn’t sound like that?
|by Anonymous||reply 25||07/17/2020|
Did Luke Evans attend the DeForest Kelley school of acting?
Oh, I think so!
|by Anonymous||reply 26||07/19/2020|
[quote] I thought that they stripped him naked and that the prostitutes all posed on bed with him while the owners of the brothel took pictures to use as blackmail material.
No, R20. The boy whores definitely raped the Luke Evans character, as a warning to him to back off from the investigation.
I'm watching last season On Demand, and at the end of episode two, the bartender drugged him and right before he passed out, two more men came in the room. One was some kind of crime boss, and the other was the dirty Irish cop. Then the gangster guy said, "Come in here, girls." The scene ended with them surrounding him on the bed.
But confirmation that he was raped came in episode three. The dirty cop was recounting what happened to Moore, and he joked that Mr. Moore wouldn't be able to sit for a week. So clearly, the boy whores fucked him.
It is hard to miss though, because there was no other reference made to it.
|by Anonymous||reply 27||07/19/2020|
[quote] I loved the first season, I didn't realize they would do another one.
I'm hoping it'll be good, but my expectations will be low.
Second seasons of hit shows are never as good as the first.
|by Anonymous||reply 28||07/19/2020|
I hadn't seen Evans in a good long time and everyone on DL was complaining what a withered old crone he is. So when I tuned in, I was so surprised that Evans was very handsome! The clothes, makeup and cinematography no doubt help.
|by Anonymous||reply 29||07/19/2020|
The original program was mediocre at best.
For R18, the production design was crap. The made-for-the -film costumes were awful. For a film about prostitution, they knew nothing about how corsets were worn. Budapest looks nothing like 19th century NY and the interiors were more continental than American.
There were also some real clunkers as far a historical accuracy. The Dakota Fanning character would never smoke on a train. She would be thrown off at the next stop, if not while it was moving.
|by Anonymous||reply 30||07/19/2020|
Once I saw Series 1 on DVD with no interruptions I loved it (although Fanning was still something to be endured). I'll wait again for Series 2 to run its course on broadcast TV, then watch it without commercials.
|by Anonymous||reply 31||07/19/2020|
Raped by boy whores!
|by Anonymous||reply 32||07/19/2020|
It's on tonight!
|by Anonymous||reply 33||07/19/2020|
So is Dakota Fanning the "STAH" this season?
Last season it was hard to tell, because each of the characters seemed to get equal time. Even though Daniel Bruhl got top billing.
If this is going to be all about Dakota Fanning and "girl power," in the early 1900's, then I'm out.
I've had sufficient on that topic.
|by Anonymous||reply 34||07/19/2020|
R23 There are two books in the series. They’ll go to book 2 - that’s why it’s called angel of Darkness . R28
|by Anonymous||reply 35||07/19/2020|
[quote] The original program was mediocre at best.
Yes, but it featured Luke Evans getting raped by boy whores. A DL fave is born!
|by Anonymous||reply 36||07/19/2020|
Dear Lord In Heaven!
|by Anonymous||reply 37||07/19/2020|
Will there be more boy whores rapping in season two?
|by Anonymous||reply 38||07/19/2020|
There was a third book but it’s in modern times. A fourth is due in ‘22
|by Anonymous||reply 39||07/19/2020|
I simply must know how corsets ARE worn, dear R30. Be a doll and inform the hoi polloi. Thanks. I'd like to work the trottoir along Avenue Foch.
|by Anonymous||reply 40||07/19/2020|
R40, well, for one, they are never worn directly next to the skin.
|by Anonymous||reply 41||07/19/2020|
Forty five minutes into the first episode and I keep focusing on how tight Dakota's blouses are and how they appear to be squashing her boobs down flat.
Holy crap - they just showed a dead baby!
|by Anonymous||reply 42||07/19/2020|
Gay character alert: In the second episode, Sarah (Dakota) and John (Luke Evans) visit a ritzy department store and one of the workers knows Dakota. He's very fey and he gets very flirty when he claps eyes on Luke.
|by Anonymous||reply 43||07/19/2020|
Is that the guy who played Roose Bolton as the man who authorized the execution of the mother of the missing child? I know I've seen that guy before somewhere.
|by Anonymous||reply 44||07/19/2020|
I like the show & she’s fine in it.
|by Anonymous||reply 45||07/19/2020|
I can't believe I missed it!
How was the premiere?
|by Anonymous||reply 46||07/20/2020|
Why does Bruhl sound like he got mush in his mouth....
the googley chick, Fanning, could do w/o her....miss sufragette chain smoking: how very independent, virgina.
|by Anonymous||reply 47||07/20/2020|
I missed it dangit, 90 Day Fiance!!!
|by Anonymous||reply 48||07/20/2020|
I'm Dakota Fanning's acting coach.
|by Anonymous||reply 49||07/20/2020|
I thought it was coming out next weekend not this past weekend.
|by Anonymous||reply 50||07/20/2020|
gory shlock. Trying way-yyyyyyyy too hard.
|by Anonymous||reply 51||07/20/2020|
When will Caleb Carr be fucking canceled already?
|by Anonymous||reply 52||07/20/2020|
Nobody is forcing you nasty bitches to watch it, if it's not your cup of tea. Sheesh!
|by Anonymous||reply 53||07/20/2020|
Its awesome, like the first one was too.....cept for fanning, who seems to be in some horse pageant...
|by Anonymous||reply 54||07/20/2020|
I love it. It's a period drama and the recreation of NYC at that time has been stunning. Season one was excellent. I Read the books years ago. I'm glad they made it into a TV series. I like the first book best, but the Angel of Darkness was very good. And I have always adored Dakota Fanning. I loved her screaming and screaming at Tom Cruise in War of the Worlds. My God she was a horrid child, but a brilliant actress. I also like the political message the casting sends that an openly Gay man who is out and proud can play a straight character who is the love interest of the woman character. I mean. We know Gay men have been playing straight for years, but this is up front in you face Gay man.
|by Anonymous||reply 55||07/20/2020|
[quote]When will Caleb Carr be fucking canceled already?
Why? What did he do?
|by Anonymous||reply 56||07/20/2020|
The (very international) supporting cast in season 1 was really good, including the creepy/incestuous Van Bergen family (with Sean Young playing the mother of Willem "Silver Smile" van Bergen, played by British actor Josef Antin, who is of Turkish descent and has an interesting look). David Wilmot, Ted Levine, and Ronan Vibert are also excellent in this.
|by Anonymous||reply 57||07/20/2020|
[quote] the googley chick, Fanning, could do w/o her....miss sufragette chain smoking: how very independent, virgina
[quote] Willem "Silver Smile" van Bergen, played by British actor Josef Antin, who is of Turkish descent and has an interesting look
I agree! The first time I saw him, I thought he was cute.
Granted, his character was creepy, but the actor was pretty good looking.
[quote] I also like the political message the casting sends that an openly Gay man who is out and proud can play a straight character who is the love interest of the woman character
Last season, I thought that it was the Kreizler character who had a crush on Dakota Fanning.
The Moore character didn't seem to be into her at all.
|by Anonymous||reply 58||07/20/2020|
If you missed it, TNT will be running back to back re-run episodes of the premiere tonight.
|by Anonymous||reply 59||07/20/2020|
you mean you watched all of Season one and never figured out Kreizler was in love with his housekeeper, Mary? The one who didn't speak? She was desperately in love with him and when he finally allowed himself to admit it he was in love with her too. Sheesh! In fact, Luke Evan's character keeps dropping hints and he adores Dakota's character. Finally admits it.
|by Anonymous||reply 60||07/20/2020|
All of you who saw this please tell me, because I checked and it won't be on in my area until next weekend. Two hour premiere.
|by Anonymous||reply 61||07/20/2020|
[quote] Luke Evan's character keeps dropping hints and he adores Dakota's character
But what about the boy whores?
I honestly thought that Luke was going to adopt one of them.
|by Anonymous||reply 62||07/20/2020|
It will be rerun on TNT tonight, R61.
|by Anonymous||reply 63||07/20/2020|
I'm starting to watch it right now. I wonder why I couldn't access it a few hours ago......
|by Anonymous||reply 64||07/20/2020|
Alice Krige is in it. I love her.
|by Anonymous||reply 65||07/20/2020|
Dakota looks like she could be Daniel Brühl's mother!
And her insufferable intonation!!!!!!!!!
|by Anonymous||reply 66||07/21/2020|
Well, IMO none of them distinguished themselves in these first two episodes. Well...Luke did.... except he needs to get rid of the hats.
|by Anonymous||reply 67||07/21/2020|
Two episodes, R67?
I thought there was only one so far? It premiered on Sunday.
|by Anonymous||reply 68||07/21/2020|
TNT showed two episodes in a row, R68
|by Anonymous||reply 69||07/21/2020|
A lot of shows do that these days. They air two or three episodes to get viewers hooked and then make them wait for new episodes.
|by Anonymous||reply 70||07/21/2020|
|by Anonymous||reply 71||07/22/2020|
The first two episodes were excruciatingly dull. I miss the boy whores.
|by Anonymous||reply 72||07/22/2020|
Same here, R72.
I never realized it until now, but I just watched because of the boy whores.
Speaking of, I'm glad that Stevie (Matt Lintz) is back! I missed him as Henry on the Walking Dead, so it's nice to see him on a regular basis on The Alienist.
|by Anonymous||reply 73||07/22/2020|
I also enjoyed Douglas Smith’s ass.
|by Anonymous||reply 74||07/22/2020|
It's a slower boil, that's for sure.
|by Anonymous||reply 75||07/22/2020|
Two of Matt Lintz' siblings were also on The Walking Dead.
Most notably, Madison Lintz who played Carol's daughter Sophia.
|by Anonymous||reply 76||07/22/2020|
R76, I love her on Bosch. She has such elegance.
|by Anonymous||reply 77||07/22/2020|
I can't watch anything with Dakota Fanning in it. I really wanted her character in War of the Worlds to die.
|by Anonymous||reply 78||07/22/2020|
Dakota looks like she lost a lot of weight since last season.
|by Anonymous||reply 79||07/22/2020|
Is it just me or is Dakota less wooden and more relaxed?
|by Anonymous||reply 80||07/23/2020|
I saw the first episode last night. I tried to be positive. I tried to ignore the opening that seemed to be basically a direct steal from Babylon Berlin (I don't remember that part in the book), but the fiance in her Joann's Fabric, Disney Princess dress is where I just lost it. DK seems to be wearing a modern orthopedic corset rather than a period corset; yet, she still has terrible posture. Her costumes are not only weirdly made to accentuate he coat hanger shoulders, but fit poorly as well. And, dresses with trains were not worn to walk your baby in the park. While I am at it, where was the lady's maid or nanny? A woman of her status, particularly a Spanish lady, would not leave the house without a servant. Indeed, the entire Spanish Embassy was weirdly devoid of servants.
I would love to know why the set dresser has a fetish for machine embroidered Indian fabrics. This was a problem in the first series as well. There would be a scene in a rundown tenement attic, and there would be a curtain of embroidered Indian silk. WTF?????
Needless to say, I would not notice all of this shit if the story or performances were engaging.
|by Anonymous||reply 81||07/24/2020|
Sorry, DF (Dakota Fanning) not DK.
|by Anonymous||reply 82||07/24/2020|
naw, she more wooden, playing the part as if she a wooden indian on porch of some general store down the street,
to think chloe sevigny had the part almost.
gagging with discretion.....
|by Anonymous||reply 83||07/24/2020|
Dakota Cornball i meant....
|by Anonymous||reply 84||07/24/2020|
[quote]to think chloe sevigny had the part almost.
Isn't she about two decades too old? Or was the production really in development for that long?
|by Anonymous||reply 85||07/24/2020|
R81, that was brilliant!
I'd love to see you call out the costume and set designers with your observations.
They would be fucking humiliated!
It just further shows how low Hollywood standards are, and how lazy the people who do the research are, as well.
|by Anonymous||reply 86||07/24/2020|
R86, I don't know how brilliant my comments were. I suspect the designer's response would be that only a "fag" would notice details such as that (though the costume designers are both male).
|by Anonymous||reply 87||07/24/2020|
Trust me R81/R87 you know your shit.
These people making movies now, and doing costumes and set design, seem to think that they are all "experts." They relish in the accolades and awards.
Someone like you could totally blow them the fuck out of the water.
|by Anonymous||reply 88||07/24/2020|
R88 To their credit, aren't they filming this in Budapest or something? It’s not like they can Uber to Mood and get some great period fabric or hit up the Hollywood prop houses in the valley.
|by Anonymous||reply 89||07/24/2020|
R89, I am aware of that and I was actually going to mention it in my post* and then I deleted it because it really isn't an excuse. Fabrics can be ordered well in advance and shipped to location. Since everything is made in either China or India nowadays, it is not as if one has to worry about getting material from a US mill. For my bitching about the Indian, machine embroidered silks, India does produce some wonderful period appropriate fabrics.
There is no reason for that horrid lavender gown (and it is lavender not "Violet"). (Though, I would also like to know the excuse for the "actress" and I use the word loosely. ) These shows are planned way in advance. There are numerous costume houses in England and Italy with good period stock. To get really technical, the actress is only seen from the waist up as I recall. They could have made a decent period bodice and faked the skirt.
As to the Indian fabric, there is no reason why the crib should be draped in a floral fabric. A plain white or ecru lace or netting would have been more accurate. The embroidered fabric made it look like a gypsy caravan.
*Actually, I did mention it in R30.
|by Anonymous||reply 90||07/24/2020|
I heart you, R90.
It's so nice to hear from someone who actually knows what they're talking about. For once. In 2020.
Most people nowdays, are fucking clueless and ignorant.
|by Anonymous||reply 91||07/24/2020|
The shots of the Spanish envoy’s house being adjacent to what I guess is supposed to be Central Park with their streets paved in cobblestones was breath taking. It captured that time period for me even if it wasn’t authentic and made me envy those who still live in such beautiful places and glad to know they exist.
|by Anonymous||reply 92||07/24/2020|
R91, some are clueless and ignorant, but a lot is intentional. I don't mind playing fast an loose with period as was done in the 2016 War and Peace. It was clearly a choice. I suspect a lot of what was done in The Alienist was done with intention, but of the "I don't really care." kind.
|by Anonymous||reply 93||07/24/2020|
99.999% of people (even knowledgeable ones) aren't going to care about Indian fabric. Whining about how "people today" don't know anything is silly because old movies and shows are so much worse with period accuracy
|by Anonymous||reply 94||07/24/2020|
R94, I suspect we have had this discussion before. First, there is benchmark by which film design is judged, basically before Merchant/Ivory- Masterpiece Theater, and after Merchant/Ivory-Masterpiece Theater. The hyper-accurate production of the two made is basically impossible to be historically inaccurate without it being an intentional design choice. The early films may not have been accurate, but the had a style. Their historical world exists in a cohesive whole. Again, the same can be said for the 2016 War and Peace or any other film that play fast-and-loose with historical accuracy with intention. The problem is productions that have the intention of being historically accurate and have glaring sloppiness. I am not talking about productions that use Teddy Bears 10-15 years before they were invented. I am talking about throwing in a 1950s dress and expecting us to accept that it is 1890s.
R88, I am seeing episode two tonight. I will post my thoughts, even if you are the only one who is interested.
|by Anonymous||reply 95||07/24/2020|
R90 Are you sure the dress was not mauve? I’m sure you know the history and importance of that color.
|by Anonymous||reply 96||07/24/2020|
R96, yes, and yes.
|by Anonymous||reply 97||07/24/2020|
R97 I think I’m going to have to disagree with you. The 1890s are literally known as the mauve decade. And by this time Perkins had developed extensive variations of tints of mauve dyes, making a wide range of variations on the color. The character’s name is Violet and she is shown wearing the color twice in both her scenes and it’s one the detonates upper class and wealth, so they are obviously reinforcing all these ideas with her clothing.
On the website below you can actually read a statement for the micro shift in fashion for 1897 and the way her clothes reflect that. For 1898 it goes on to specifically mention the return of the princess line and most likely she’s a trend setter and actually establishes the on coming trend if recently returned from Paris and a visit to Worth. I don’t think the costume designers are coloring outside the lines as extreme as you would make it seem.
The website is the a Greater Bay Area Costume’s Guild and looks to be quite reputable, it’s not just some crazy lady with a vintage clothes collection.
|by Anonymous||reply 98||07/24/2020|
Sorry, this is the link for 98.
|by Anonymous||reply 99||07/24/2020|
Here’s a nice behind the scene look at costuming for the show. Michael Kaplan maybe best know for Star Wars and Blade Runner, but he has done extensive period costuming as well.
|by Anonymous||reply 100||07/24/2020|
U CAN have the most fab costumes/sets/ in the world, but when that lame hen dakota eff comes out with her bug fish eyes, u know the jig is up.... lite the ladys cig : she is a libber !
|by Anonymous||reply 101||07/24/2020|
Oh my mercy, in that above pic, miss fanning looks like the whore my daddy left my mommy for, she took in washing for years, but after marrying dad, she was so rich she smoked Pall Mall menthols and wore red pretty ribbons from her spectacles.
|by Anonymous||reply 102||07/24/2020|
I'm so into this season. The two episodes flew by.
|by Anonymous||reply 103||07/25/2020|
R97, by definition mauve has more grey than blue. The designers may be intending mauve, but they are using lavender.
E2 wasn't as bad as the first episode, but something is definitely up with Violet. You have a actress with no period look, no period style, who is consistently filmed in gowns that are more 1950s than 1890s. I wonder if the actress who was to play Violet pulled ou at the very last minute and they were forced to pull costumes from the local opera house.
|by Anonymous||reply 104||07/25/2020|
Got a cheap thrill out of seeing Melanie Field in the first episode. I wasn't initially sold on the Heathers TV show, but I rather liked it and with no small part because of her hilarious performance.
|by Anonymous||reply 105||07/25/2020|
This is from last season, but insightful in regards to the costume design. He sounds very rigorous and did scour costume houses in L.A., London, Paris, Rome and Vienna to flesh out the clothes for the extras. He also chooses a color palette for each character and did dress Dakota in mauve for a scene in Delmonicos. I love that he mentions Luke’s vanity at the end.
|by Anonymous||reply 106||07/25/2020|
The set is quite amazing.
|by Anonymous||reply 107||07/25/2020|
This video is very cool as you can move your device 360 degrees, or swipe with your finger or cursor, to view the whole scene, ceiling to floor or side to side.
|by Anonymous||reply 108||07/25/2020|
So, there are going to be two episodes every week?!?
|by Anonymous||reply 109||07/25/2020|
Pity those lovely gowns, cept for the smarmy violet one, are wasted on the vacuous blonde lead lady.
|by Anonymous||reply 110||07/25/2020|
Two weeks per episode? In the past that was considered as burning off the remaining episodes of a flop. Though in the times of binge-watching that might be a compromise between old school TV and Netflix streaming (aka binge-watching an entire season within days).
|by Anonymous||reply 111||07/25/2020|
[quote] Two weeks per episode?
LOL. Sorry, Of course I mean two episodes per week.
|by Anonymous||reply 112||07/25/2020|
Each episode just *feels* like two weeks.
|by Anonymous||reply 113||07/25/2020|
Two new episodes tonight!
|by Anonymous||reply 114||07/26/2020|
Why does everyone on the show this season speak in "breathy" whispers?
It's really annoying.
Last season they all spoke normally.
Is this their version of "acting?"
|by Anonymous||reply 115||07/26/2020|
Did everyone whisper in tonight's episode?
|by Anonymous||reply 116||07/26/2020|
Laszlo mumbles...cant understand his words, wtf with him????
|by Anonymous||reply 117||07/26/2020|
At the end of the 2nd episode tonight, did it look like the red-haired nurse had black teeth? I was distracted during the show, so did I miss something or does my TV needs adjusting?
|by Anonymous||reply 118||07/26/2020|
I missed it tonight. Did Luke Evans wear those ridiculous hats again? I love him. I want to see him have sex with whoors.
|by Anonymous||reply 119||07/26/2020|
Where are the boy whores this season, goddammit??!!!!
|by Anonymous||reply 120||07/26/2020|
R118. Yes, she had black teeth, charcoal, as in the antidote to the poison used on the first baby.
|by Anonymous||reply 121||07/26/2020|
I do enjoy this show, it’s very atmospheric. The sets and costuming are well done, reminds me of “The Knick”, which was amazing.
|by Anonymous||reply 122||07/26/2020|
You know which character I can’t stand? That humbling crying señora. One doesn’t feel sympathy for her.
|by Anonymous||reply 123||07/26/2020|
|by Anonymous||reply 124||07/26/2020|
Can't they replace Dakota Fanning? With anyone really. Terrible casting.
|by Anonymous||reply 125||07/26/2020|
This is the second historical drama a Fanning girl has ruined. Elle never should have been chosen to play Catherine the Great. Awful, awful casting.
|by Anonymous||reply 126||07/26/2020|
Ooh, I love Daniel Brühl. He looks more Spanish than German.
|by Anonymous||reply 127||07/26/2020|
Does bruhl have throat cancer? his voice sounds as if he is deep in a dank well.
Miss fanning's character should be eliminated before her eyeballs roll out of her buggy head, and tht little hat is put bak on some forelorn barbie doll..
only Prince Luke saves the show.
both this one and Perry mason are knee deep in dead babys......tiresome.
|by Anonymous||reply 128||07/26/2020|
Luke is the worst thing about the show R128, gruff expressionless voice and lines on his face that reek of cigarettes.
|by Anonymous||reply 129||07/26/2020|
D Fanning is the bottom talent in this cast , and alas this season has so much of her. tedious and fanny one note....
last season had more interesting sub plots, the boys whores, the slum people, ruffians, etc
IM TIRED OF THE KILLING OF THE BABIES STUFF
|by Anonymous||reply 130||07/27/2020|
The Alienist isn't that good. Babylon Berlin is far better in terms of story, costumes, and acting. Even World on Fire is better. Both shows also give gay characters.
I'm not at all educated in history & fashion like the expert who commented before, but even I noticed how unflattering Dakota's costumes were, or maybe her terrible posture/proportions. And, like he said, I did think it unusual that the rich Spanish lady was about town with no servant. Dakota's W's pronunciation is jarring and the story this season is bland. Disappointing.
|by Anonymous||reply 131||07/27/2020|
R130, for us to care about the taking of the babies, we have to care about the mothers. And none of the mothers have any character development to warrant caring about them.
|by Anonymous||reply 132||07/27/2020|
How does it compare to "Penny Dreadful"?
|by Anonymous||reply 133||07/27/2020|
Anything is better than the dreadful Penny Dreadful, flop of the season.
But Alienist getting more shitty with each episode. Why must we be forced to look more and more at FAnning's turgid face, she in it too much. More laszlo and luke la evans.
Needs new characters too, same 3 is jus to much/little, alas. Is like a replay of first season, but with dead babys thrown it for shit effect.
|by Anonymous||reply 134||07/27/2020|
R134, unfortunately, you complaints go back to the original book series. The second book was not anywhere as good as the first. The author simply did not know where to go with the characters. The "third" book, set in contemporary times also bombed as I recall.
|by Anonymous||reply 135||07/27/2020|
I'm watching it for the costumes, the atmosphere and Luke Evans. I wish he's do more work. Get better parts. He should be more famous and more successful. He can look sexy just sitting there reading a news paper. I'm not a huge Bruhl fan. He seems like a sneaky fellow. I think Dakota doesn't work for me because she has no range, and it's hard to think of her as an adult, when she still has the face of her 10 yr old self and every time I look at her I expect her to scream the way she did in War of the Worlds. When the aliens took her I was glad.
|by Anonymous||reply 136||07/27/2020|
R136, I am not sure what you mean by "sneaky", but Bruhl is definitely an actor who is only in it for the money. It is a business to him, nothing more.
|by Anonymous||reply 137||07/27/2020|
I really disagree with the poster upthread who hated Elle Fanning in The Great. I thought she nailed it, comedically and dramatically. She is, by far, the more talented sister.
|by Anonymous||reply 138||07/27/2020|
honey she dint nail this one...
|by Anonymous||reply 139||07/27/2020|
What I meant by "sneaky" is his physicality. His looks don't appeal to me. He looks like he is underhanded or something. Shifty. I'm probably wrong and he's a wonderful guy and maybe we should have dinner some day, but that's just how he strikes me. And of course standing next to Luke there's just no contest. Luke is The Sex. He is lovely, talented, charismatic, and I'd love to have dinner with him...and breakfast after that.
|by Anonymous||reply 140||07/27/2020|
[quote] IM TIRED OF THE KILLING OF THE BABIES STUFF
I totally agree.
Bring back the BOY WHORES!
|by Anonymous||reply 141||07/27/2020|
I'm enjoying the show, but aren't the accents a little all over the place?
|by Anonymous||reply 142||07/28/2020|
R142 Actually I would think late 19th Century NYC that would be very true to history.
|by Anonymous||reply 143||07/28/2020|
I want Luke to fondle me....
|by Anonymous||reply 144||07/28/2020|
Agree 100% with the comments upthread about Violet being completely wrong for the period - her body type, her costuming, her entire bearing and presentation. Fanning looks similarly out of place in a ball gown, plus she walks like a truck driver, not like a society lady. It takes me out of the story. If they’re going to adopt period speech and not use contractions, then they should learn how to carry themselves appropriately. Oddly, the minor female characters are much better in this regard.
|by Anonymous||reply 145||07/28/2020|
Violet is wearing modern eye makeup.
|by Anonymous||reply 146||07/28/2020|
Were bachelor parties really a thing then?
|by Anonymous||reply 147||07/28/2020|
R147 They go back to Ancient Roman times.
|by Anonymous||reply 148||07/28/2020|
Agree that the Laszlo actor needs better diction,,,,,drumble city, too bad.
shitty script this year, but yay luke, nay on blonde bitch with the tiny straw black hat in ev scene....BORING FANNING
|by Anonymous||reply 149||07/28/2020|
Violet looks too old for the role. I thought she was about 5 years younger than her godfather. I can't imagine her being about 20 years younger.
|by Anonymous||reply 150||07/28/2020|
Interview with the three leads, for those interested:
|by Anonymous||reply 151||07/30/2020|
Was the female alienist at the party played by Lara Pulver? She looked like it only older.
|by Anonymous||reply 152||07/31/2020|
At least Doyle is back even though he's a bad cop, he's kinda hot.
|by Anonymous||reply 153||07/31/2020|
wish doyle played Fanning's part....him purdy, she aint.
|by Anonymous||reply 154||08/01/2020|
I thought there was one boywhore that John befriended and worked for him?
|by Anonymous||reply 155||08/01/2020|
i think in the book its....clear he is bi, if not total homo....xoxox
|by Anonymous||reply 156||08/01/2020|
Those multiple scenes of the dude breastfeeding from crazy Libby is making me cringe.
|by Anonymous||reply 157||08/02/2020|
Why do I think something fatal is going to happen to John's fiancée? She has to go so John can be with Sara. I vote that Libby kills her in a mad frenzy of revenge for being caught.
|by Anonymous||reply 158||08/02/2020|
mmmm nice chest/tit shot of the cute gangster guy who is fukin/sukin the crazy nurse murdereress
so far them 2 are the only fun ones in this series
|by Anonymous||reply 159||08/02/2020|
Why did they make the pop eyed Fanning the main protaganist this season???
|by Anonymous||reply 160||08/02/2020|
I like it but I cam mot remember to watch it.
|by Anonymous||reply 161||08/03/2020|
You missing nothing, its the story of a goldfish detective lady.
|by Anonymous||reply 162||08/03/2020|
R151 Thanks for that. They can put expression into their voices. Yet they use a monotone on TV.
|by Anonymous||reply 163||08/03/2020|
R160 I see what you did there. Are you basing that on an actual announced medical diagnosis of Fanning or just making and extended joke?
|by Anonymous||reply 164||08/03/2020|
Im a bit disappointed with the slow plot, but all in all its better than most of the crap on tv
|by Anonymous||reply 165||08/03/2020|
Luke Evans is so damn sexy, but he's kind of a hard looking 41.
|by Anonymous||reply 166||08/03/2020|
Damn shame his part so small this season, prob why viewership is down.
|by Anonymous||reply 167||08/03/2020|
Ratings are down because The Alienist is now competing with Yellowstone, which is a juggernaut.
|by Anonymous||reply 168||08/03/2020|
So Moore and Howard fuck. But the previews do not look good for our sweet Luke Evans. Not good at all. And there's definitely something very spooky about Lazlo's new love interest. Although one dares not call it love, no?
|by Anonymous||reply 169||08/03/2020|
|by Anonymous||reply 170||08/03/2020|
R168 there are only 2 books so kinda moot. Then with streaming it just lives forever. (A third book was set in modern times)
|by Anonymous||reply 171||08/03/2020|
Is the 3rd book set in modern times but w/the same characters?
|by Anonymous||reply 172||08/03/2020|
R172 no- new set of characters. There is a proper follow up due late next year or 2022
|by Anonymous||reply 173||08/03/2020|
I'm new to this series, and I'm enjoying this season. I'll have to backtrack and watch the first season for sure.
|by Anonymous||reply 174||08/03/2020|
[quote]Luke Evans is so damn sexy, but he's kind of a hard looking 41.
Oddly, he's got a marionette line on one side of his face. If he added some fillers that will refresh his face and plump it up a bit, as long as he doesn't go overboard.
|by Anonymous||reply 175||08/03/2020|
Luke evans was great in taboo - at least i remembered him as great. Then i heard his album & it wasn’t good. That is all
|by Anonymous||reply 176||08/03/2020|
cAN THEY repLACE LA fannING IN THE nexT ONe ?
|by Anonymous||reply 177||08/03/2020|
Luke is a heavy smoker, that is why is face is melting.
|by Anonymous||reply 178||08/03/2020|
[quote]If he added some fillers that will refresh his face and plump it up a bit, as long as he doesn't go overboard.
Men should NEVER get "fillers"--they look even worse on them than on women. Grotesque. Quitting smoking will do more for his looks and at least won't distort his face.
|by Anonymous||reply 179||08/03/2020|
I got bored and just stopped watching after episode 4.
|by Anonymous||reply 180||08/04/2020|
[quote]Men should NEVER get "fillers"--
I'm just talking about that divet on his right side that looks like a marionette line.
|by Anonymous||reply 181||08/04/2020|
Though, I agree he should give up smoking.
|by Anonymous||reply 182||08/04/2020|
It seems to be getting lots of press this seasons with articles and interviews around every corner.
|by Anonymous||reply 183||08/04/2020|
R183 That's because it's an Emmy winning series. It deserves it.
|by Anonymous||reply 184||08/04/2020|
I have only watched up to episode 3. But The Entertainer was written in 1902 and could not be played in 1897.
|by Anonymous||reply 185||08/04/2020|
emmys can be bought like the golden globes, common knowledge.....same with oscars
|by Anonymous||reply 186||08/04/2020|
So what if he has a line on his face? It gives him character.
|by Anonymous||reply 187||08/04/2020|
R187 Okay, Luke. Premature lines are not okay for your age and career.
|by Anonymous||reply 188||08/04/2020|
R186 No Emmies bought for this show, because there is no need for it.
|by Anonymous||reply 189||08/04/2020|
You got me, R188.
I'm Fucking Luke Evans. Rolling around here to see what you knuckleheads think of my face.
|by Anonymous||reply 190||Last Wednesday at 7:42 AM|
I personally liked, "Angel of Darkness" over the first novel. Even though Moore's fiance's appearance was ghastly (eye makeup?!), it was to show to new viewers how completely unsuitable she is for him, as Sara so succinctly points out in Ep 3 or 4. I still can't stand Dakota as Sara- she's supposed to be plucky and have a sense of humor, always whipping out her gun at the slightest affront.
I do love Lara Pulver as the possible love interest/colleague of Kriezler, she was a terrific Irene Adler in, "Sherlock".
|by Anonymous||reply 191||Last Wednesday at 8:29 AM|
We got Luke's side-butt.
|by Anonymous||reply 192||Last Thursday at 11:15 AM|
Luke has what they used to call "rugged good looks." Any work will make him look like that disaster Rupert Everett.
|by Anonymous||reply 193||Last Thursday at 12:59 PM|
Was Laszlo drinking absinthe with the lady doctor?
|by Anonymous||reply 194||Last Thursday at 1:03 PM|
Yes, r194. That's the only drink that I can think of that involves a green liquid poured over a sugar cube.
|by Anonymous||reply 195||Last Thursday at 1:05 PM|
What happened that got Absinthe banded.
|by Anonymous||reply 196||Last Thursday at 1:09 PM|
R196, absinthe is pretty gross -- tastes like anise and black licorice. I remember you could only get it in the Czech Republic and a few other places before the bans were lifted.
In other news, Luke has a nice ass. Will they show Laszlo's ass?
|by Anonymous||reply 197||Last Thursday at 2:23 PM|
Luke is Welsh. He drinks and smokes. A lot. Sometimes he looks so rough I wonder if he isn't five or ten years older than he admits to. But I love him and he is sexy hot.
|by Anonymous||reply 198||Last Thursday at 7:05 PM|
|by Anonymous||reply 199||Last Thursday at 9:27 PM|
[quote] Why did they make the pop eyed Fanning the main protaganist this season??? Grave error...
She's why I stopped watching. I tuned into the first episode, and I was done. Dakota Fanning cannot carry a series like this by herself.
They have relegated Luke Evans and Daniel Bruhl to the background this season, which is a huge mistake. They're why people tuned in last season.
I don't know why Hollywood tries to take a successful series carried by men, and then tries to twist it around and make the female the main character. Of course, in hopes that people will all of a sudden watch for the female character. WRONG. It's a bait and switch that will never work.
I'm not at all surprised that the ratings are down this season. I'm usually really good at predicting which shows will be popular and which ones won't, and I knew that this season would be a flop.
The minute I knew that they were making Dakota Fanning the star, I could tell it was over.
Thankfully, the finale is on Sunday. Poor Luke.
|by Anonymous||reply 200||Last Friday at 2:25 AM|
The second book is about Sarah, and this season is based on the second book. So, what is your point, now, R200?
|by Anonymous||reply 201||Last Friday at 3:06 AM|
And I like her in the role.
|by Anonymous||reply 202||Last Friday at 3:18 AM|
Does anyone else think the female alienist is a figment of Kriezers imagination? No one else has met her or seen her. He only sees her when he drinks absinthe.
|by Anonymous||reply 203||Last Friday at 3:43 AM|
It seemed to me Sarah was the main character in the first season as well.
|by Anonymous||reply 204||Last Friday at 4:04 AM|
Dakota had to transition to a grown assed woman with a romance attached at some point. She is far too talents to be relegated to Rom Com bullshit. Honestly. I always felt if she could recover from War of the Worlds with Tom Cruise, and all that fucking screaming, she can do anything. Her screaming traumatized me.
|by Anonymous||reply 205||Last Friday at 4:12 AM|
This is just DL hating on women.
Yawn. I think she's fine but my momma didn't fuck me up.
|by Anonymous||reply 206||Last Friday at 6:39 AM|
F203 no one thinks that.
He met her at a public event (no drinking) and he saw her before the absinthe was poured.
|by Anonymous||reply 207||Last Friday at 6:42 AM|
the female part deserved a more accomplished actress than fanning. her range of emotion covers the gamut from a to b..
|by Anonymous||reply 208||Last Friday at 7:57 AM|
She's doing the same thing as Gillian Anderson and there were no complaints with her acting in the X-Files.
|by Anonymous||reply 209||Last Saturday at 2:21 AM|
I am not compelled by this baby-napping villainess. Her boyfriend is kinda hot, though. The narrative needs some reveals and surprises and we aren't getting enough of them. I enjoyed the simulation of one of the Vanderbilt 5th Ave fauxtaux.
|by Anonymous||reply 210||Last Saturday at 3:10 AM|
Many complained about G Anderson in x files as a jonny one note....she was awful....the hot guy in that show, and the good writing carried that show to success, not the pitiful gillian. she ruined many a movie...but she has name value cause of X.
|by Anonymous||reply 211||Last Saturday at 3:40 AM|
The actress playing Libby Hatch could play a sister or a younger version of Nicole Kidman.
|by Anonymous||reply 212||Last Saturday at 8:13 AM|
Agree, this plot not as compelling as last one, wish had more of hottie Bruhl...
|by Anonymous||reply 213||Last Saturday at 10:13 AM|
[quote] anyone else think the female alienist is a figment of Kriezers imagination?
That would be an interesting concept. It would mean Kreizler's psyche is messed up.
|by Anonymous||reply 214||Last Saturday at 11:58 PM|
[quote]The actress playing Libby Hatch could play a sister or a younger version of Nicole Kidman.
I was thinking the same thing. Well, the Nicole Kidman, younger sister thing.
|by Anonymous||reply 215||Last Sunday at 12:15 AM|
Dakota's sister, Elle, would have made an excellent Sarah. She's prettier and quite a good actress.
|by Anonymous||reply 216||Last Sunday at 12:35 AM|
Indeed, elle is on thousand times better actress than her fugly big sister.....dakota is an insult to the show
|by Anonymous||reply 217||Last Sunday at 12:37 AM|
I really don't mind Dakota. I think she's a good actress. It's her bad posture that bugs me.
|by Anonymous||reply 218||Last Sunday at 1:15 AM|
I like Dakota. But she has no sex appeal. No chemistry with my Luke. Nada.
|by Anonymous||reply 219||Last Sunday at 4:43 AM|
im pissed they killed off Laszlo's cute bf, that kid who hung himself....bummer
odd the director did not see they were undermining this series with too much emphasis on fanning, and not more on the studs: bruhl and evans. he mus be str8, alas.... i wager ratings are down from last series
|by Anonymous||reply 220||Last Sunday at 4:47 AM|
RIP paulie....cute boy.
|by Anonymous||reply 221||Last Sunday at 4:50 AM|
What does Bruhl smoke? his deep damaged craggy voice must have seen punishment from thousands of cigs. 2 bad. throat cancer is not pretty.
|by Anonymous||reply 222||Last Sunday at 4:57 AM|
He rolls his own R222
|by Anonymous||reply 223||Last Sunday at 5:18 AM|
R218 Isn’t she rigid like that because of the corsets?
|by Anonymous||reply 224||Last Sunday at 5:30 AM|
Luke Evans' next project:
|by Anonymous||reply 225||Last Sunday at 6:38 AM|
I prefer this project and like the entire cast, even the German drug addict.
|by Anonymous||reply 226||Last Sunday at 7:16 AM|
So it wraps up tonight, somehow this seems even quicker than a bingeable streaming series?
|by Anonymous||reply 227||Last Sunday at 8:41 AM|
So, I’m a getting this right? Libby’s boyfriend supports her in stealing babies because it will prolong her ability to nurse and he too wants her breast milk? Also, what did women who lost babies or gave them up for adoption do before breast pumps were invented to relieve them of the fluid?
|by Anonymous||reply 228||Last Sunday at 5:14 PM|
Did the costumers hat Fanning? tht black barbie doll hat on her head, its ridic and makes her look like a fool. Makes her eyes look enormous.
This season so weak, letting tht woman lead the show is a poor decision.
|by Anonymous||reply 229||Last Sunday at 10:22 PM|
The crook who is sukiin the tits of the killer red head is hot, more of him! he can drain my tits and fuk em up if he wants.
|by Anonymous||reply 230||Last Sunday at 10:28 PM|
That actress playing Luke Evans' bethrothed has a chin from witches hell.
Let us pray its fake.
|by Anonymous||reply 231||Last Sunday at 10:54 PM|
I think Dakota looks different this time, as she has gained considerable weight.
Luke looks even hotter, in that tight white shirt.
Hoping for a part 3....love this series, despite this seasons disappointments.
|by Anonymous||reply 232||Last Sunday at 11:10 PM|
I hope that cute young lab/investigator the crook shot does not die...hid adorable. marcus, his name
dont die marcus!
shit i hate this show~ he does die. FUK FUK
|by Anonymous||reply 233||Last Sunday at 11:55 PM|
Bummer, was hoping luke evans and dr laszlo would dance off into the sunset hand in hand.
Luke throws Bruhl onto the sand, tearing his clothes off, fucking his ripe hole with every fibre of passion in his soul.
Dakota stands in the distance, weeping, slowly walkiing into the ocean ahead of her, putting an end to her 8 episodes of misery.
Throngs of people on the dunes cheer !
|by Anonymous||reply 234||Yesterday at 12:09 AM|
What was the relationship between Hearst and Violet? The use “Godfather” but it almost seems like she’s supposed to be his illegitimate child.
Did Byrne ever tell anyone to put the lotion in the basket?
|by Anonymous||reply 235||Yesterday at 1:00 AM|
who did luke wind up with? messy ending. and bruhl, he went off with the witchy lady? dakota, i dont care...
|by Anonymous||reply 236||Yesterday at 2:02 AM|
This can't end like this!!!!!I want Dakota to be with Luke. I want that Viollet creature, to get with Hearst. YOu know he wants her.
|by Anonymous||reply 237||21 hours ago|
This season was horrible.
I was expecting so much more, especially after a fantastic first season.
Unfortunately, it was extremely disappointing.
Whoever was responsible for Season 2 should be FIRED.
|by Anonymous||reply 238||17 hours ago|
Yup s2 was terrible. I didn't like almost everything about it. The production design and how it was shot was good, everything else - the storylines and performances sucked. Dakota was the worst of it, her exaggerated 'W' pronunciation so jarring.
|by Anonymous||reply 239||12 hours ago|
I enjoyed it. I did think Season 1 was better than the second season, but to be fair, Caleb Carr's first book was better than the second one in the series.
I would love for this same director and cast to do a series based on Upton Sinclair's "The Jungle."
|by Anonymous||reply 240||12 hours ago|
Boring season. The obvious lesson learned is that boy whores make everything better.
|by Anonymous||reply 241||11 hours ago|
Yes indeed, we too use "cookies." Don't you just LOVE clicking on these things on every single site you visit? I know we do! You can thank the EU parliament for making everyone in the world click on these pointless things while changing absolutely nothing. If you are interested you can take a look at our privacy/terms or if you just want to see the damn site without all this bureaucratic nonsense, click ACCEPT and we'll set a dreaded cookie to make it go away. Otherwise, you'll just have to find some other site for your pointless bitchery needs.
Become a contributor - post when you want with no ads!