Who is the hotter cousin? Robbie or Stephen Amell???

Stephen is nice to look at, especially while younger, but Robbie 100%. He’s more handsome, tighter more lean body, and more talented.

No poll, OP?

Anyway, I'm glad Stephen did some tasteful nudity before he made it big on Arrow.

Stephen. No contest.

Robbie is friends with Aaron Samuels, right?

Robbie...all the way - every day Robbie.

There's a reason why Robbie gets referred to as the superior Amell.

They are both hotter

Robbie has a weird thing going on where he's muscular but all the parts look mismatched, like he's a walking Photoshop collage. Stephen definitely gets my vote.

Robbie. Stephen has the secret smirk of someone who has skidmarked underwear.

R6 by who????

R10 by those who think Stephen's a douchebag e.g ONTDers.

Robbie is a hot top. Stephen is a hot bottom. They make a great team.

They’re related. Not hot r12

r12 just cousins..what you never wanted to fuck your daugh...err. I mean cousin?

Stephen IS a douchebag - but in that smug, really bitchy straight-guy way that actually endears himself to you. Plus he a is a total supporter of gay rights and has plenty of gay friends for receipts. Stephen all the way.

Never heard of Robbie.

I’ve been following Robbie ever since he worked for Nickelodeon and Disney Canada. It’s a shame he never had a big breakout role.

I mean it’s never too late but ... I do love Upload though.

neither

They both seem inconsequential.

[Quote] It’s a shame he never had a big breakout role.

He was charming in The Duff, but I can't say he's done anything to blow me away.

Robbie is more talented. He is far more charismatic and charming than Stephen, and is good at emotional scenes etc.

Stephen gets by 100% on his looks.

[quote] Stephen gets by 100% on his looks.

Which are not exceptional, by movie standards. If he read the weather at a regional television station, yes. He would be extremely handsome. But Hollywood is not going to do back flips for that man.

Stephen, by a long shot. Robbie is very generic looking. Handsome, but bland.

Robbie’s face and build work better in films. Stephen is more for TV.

Stephen...fills out his costume nicely.

Robbie Amell's nipples are the Eight and Ninth wonders of the world!

Stephen has more of a sexy swagger and mature hunkiness...

Back in his early days of Arrow, he had a more muscular body as well. Robbie has the more classically handsome face though.

stephen comes across as handsome and manlier, robbie more boyish and pretty.....

stephen for the win in regards to the body especially the 1st couple of seasons of ARROW....

Robbie.

But neither is hot until they play a slutty, gay role.

R28 Stephen has played gay

Robbie.

I watched "The Babysitter" after someone mentioned it on the "Upload" thread and immediately lost interest in the movie after his character died. Didn't know who he was until "Code 8". Stephen and Robbie look similar and I thought they were brothers.

No. They’re first cousins r30.

Robbie, definitely. But I have a feeling that if he gained weight he'd become a schlub like Sean Astin.

[Quote] But neither is hot until they play a slutty, gay role.

Does Dante's Cove count?

If not, surely his role as a bisexual rent boy on [italic]Hung[/italic] is close enough?

Both were prime fap material R33/R34 though I don't recall the rent boy being bi.

Wasn't he out-competing Thomas Jane's character partially because he had no problem with servicing male clients?

R36 I'm pretty sure it was just because he was younger and hot. I wouldnt kick either out of bed but FUCK

Stephen Amell was only on season 3 of Hung, and he was fucking women. Not men.

He was doing better because he was very young and hot.

Back when Stephen was a personal trainer in Toronto he was known to be into birth guys and girls. That’s how he got the roles on Dante’s Cove and QAF. But once the bigger Hollywood roles came within his grasp he “ straightened up” for his career. And that’s why he’s so gay friendly.

R39 that is a lie. He was never known to be into men. He was ALWAYS into women.

He is gay friendly because he grew up around gays and his family is very pro gay. 🙄🙄🙄

Doesn't he have an open relationship/threesomes with his wife??

Robbie has sporty body which I prefer

Robbie is more lean muscle framed.

Stephen is more thick muscles.

R[40] Were you there to know otherwise. And while he is gay friendly - that doesn’t mean he hasn’t tried out men before. How many straight guys hot tub with their gay costars. (Barrowman). Come on.

He hasn’t. R44

You’re making this up. As usual.

I’ve been in hot tubs with straight friends and not had their dicks in my mouth. Unfortunately.

R[44]. Ok Stephen. We get it. You are straight.

[Quote] How many straight guys hot tub with their gay costars. (Barrowman). Come on.

Are you serious?? What logic is this?? 😆

Stephen used to be super hot. But now it's Robbie no question.

It’s not about Logic. I’ve been in many a gay hot tub parties. The only straight guys there are really bi.

Who cares if Stephen sucked some cock. That just makes him hotter.

Agreed!,, R[51]

R51 think it’s the other way around. Some lucky ass fags sucked his cock.

I bet he let Barrowman suck his cock.

Barrowman is obviously infatuated with Stephen. Not sure if anything went on between them. But you can tell by how Barrowman looks at him.

I always thought Matt Lanter was related to them. They all look like brothers.

You are all wrong. Stephen and I went at each other. We did everything. John Barrowman just watched us in a corner jerking off.

So now a straight man can’t sit by a gay man?

Stephen. Sit by as many gay men as you want.

R50

Robbie looked fantastic in that FBI suit in X-Files.

The attached pic to this comment doesn't do him justice, but it's the only thing I was able to find.

R61 is that Lauren Ambrose??

Yes, R62.

Stephen.

I've always liked him since I saw him in Hung years ago.

Call me skeptical, but I don't think a closeted celebrity would be happy to pose for this photo:

Stephen. Robbie is handsome but in a total Basic way

R66 Robbie’s nosejob is too obvious.

Who cares? A lot of your favs have had work done.

Stephen is a man and Robbie is a boy.

Has no one asked the most important deciding factor yet, which one is more hung?

Stephen has this confident attitude where he doesn't seem like he needs to pull all the toxic masculinity bs. Very cool and very laid back.

Stephen is laid back.

Robbie is def more uptight but still cool.

Which one can take a bigger dick up the ass?

Stephen is strictly a top. Robbie is a huge bottom.

And I got to be the filling in that sandwich, Barrowman, you jealous fuck hahaha!

Oh Colin, Ive seen your cock pics. I don’t think either would be too happy with you.

If Colin is "piggy in the middle", his cock won't the be what's getting worked over.

Which guy is which in OP? Or should I just turn in my gay card?

R78 left is Robbie

Right is Stephen

Definitely Robbie for me. Never even heard of him until Upload and now I'm in love.

So you never saw "Tomorrow People" or the final season of "X-Files" or the movie "The Duff", or "The Flash" on The CW, or "A Series of Unfortunate Events" (the series, not the movie)?

Sorry R81. I don't watch the CW or teen movies and I couldn't get past the first 10 minutes of "A Series of Unfortunate Events".

[Quote] and I couldn't get past the first 10 minutes of "A Series of Unfortunate Events".

It's that bad??

I thought Neil Patrick Harris was miscast R83. I usually like him but I couldn't get past that it was him trying to act wearing a bunch of makeup. I just saw him and it ruined it for me. I think that lesser known or unknown actors work better in those types of parts.

My sister love A Series of Unfortunate Events, the movie and the books. He hated the Netflix series.

Robbie is more classic and Stephen has a little more character.

Thank you R79

Thank you R79

Stephen is the original version. Robbie is the generic form.

Robbie is disproportionate. Chicken legs and not much of an ass. Stephen's got a nice ass and based off the often bulge in his pants, he's hung too. But Stephen can be a little arrogant/intense and Robbie is better actor. Stephen has next signed up to play a wrestler on ' Heels' (not the shoes but wrestling term) with Alexander Ludwig playing his brother. So we should be getting some skin from him

[quote]he was known to be into birth guys

Fucking pedo.

[Quote] Stephen has next signed up to play a wrestler on ' Heels' (not the shoes but wrestling term)

I love that you needed to clarify 😄

Didn't he do a guest stint as a WWE wrestler a few years ago?

I like a man with some mileage on his face so Stephen all the way.

Btw, forgive me if this was mentioned up-thread, but I ain't scrolling through all of this shit again.

They're in a Netflix movie together and that's how I came to my final decision.

Robbie is boyish; Stephen is rugged & mature. I disagree with whomever said Stephen seems hung based on his bulge. Still wouldn't kick him out of the bed.

Having a full bulge doesn’t mean big dick. Some men have a lot of “potatoes” but a little bit of “meat”, as my friend would say.