Buttegieg talks about immigration from 30:00 on the Ezra Klein podcast from today.
Definitely want to keep people coming in, but legally. Increase legal immigration if needed by industry and for family reunification (close family including first cousins). Fine with birthright citizenship. I don't like that there's a huge population who are unknown to our systems. I want order and total awareness on the part of the state. Everyone having ID, everyone being legally present, everyone properly taxed. It's both a practical policy-oriented position and even an aesthetic value (orderly, technocratic state - more Singapore, less Wild West).
I also resent, but understand the necessity of, providing healthcare and free public education to illegal immigrants (the latter is required under a Supreme Court ruling), the former is just good public policy). My insurance is $400+ a month out-of-pocket, post-tax income (Kaiser platinum, Southern CA).
Absolutely agree that until AI becomes really advanced, we need to keep our population growing. Don't want to end up dying like Europe or East Asia (well, not just yet until AI can allow for UBI). And I love that newcomers' rates of reproduction decrease in one generation after becoming Americans; it contributes to limiting population growth overall, which is good for the planet. But keep immigrants coming, with a healthy regulated balance of people from Asia, Africa, and Latin America. As long as the melting pot or the more contemporary less-assimilative acculturation process keeps working, I'm happy to keep immigration going. Increase legal immigration, especially those with needed skills, including farm labor and low-skill service skills (e.g., elder care).
The Spanish thing:
I'll admit that in part it's aesthetic (the mediocrity/failure of Spanish-speaking countries for reasons including American interference and colonialism; subjective repulsion at the sound of the language, as spoken by white Spaniards and Latin Americans and everyone else (yes, I know there's a difference, but I still don't like Spanish aesthetically as spoken by anyone; yes, I find nonwhite languages beautiful (e.g., Japanese, Korean). Another part is that I don't like the possibility that the acculturation process (the best from newcomers mixed into the national fabric, but with their integration in larger society) will start failing (see, e.g., Koreatown in LA; there are students who graduate from UCLA who've been here almost all their lives but who can barely speak English, and that often leads to their not meeting others outside the Korean/Korean-American community). I have a fear that acculturation failing will mean the closing-off of entire communities from being acculturated into American society, which is informed by aesthetics (how I want a national cultural system to work) and practical policy and security concerns).
Just being honest here. Dialogue is welcome, critical to the process. Please change my mind, etc.