Here is the official thread. This looks like some good shit.
|by Anonymous||reply 323||11/28/2018|
Agree with reservations. It appears to be the only new network show that looks interesting, but what are the odds they settle for making it into "Lost" bullshit.
|by Anonymous||reply 1||08/28/2018|
I will probably check it out, but it is most likely something that works better as a mini-series or two shorter seasons. On a superficial level, I don't suppose they can somehow work it so Dallas is wearing his old Prince Charming costume or at least leather pants (although his non-Charming pants/jeans were usually pretty tight as well..
|by Anonymous||reply 2||08/28/2018|
This isn't one of those shill threads, is it?
|by Anonymous||reply 3||08/28/2018|
I hope they have a plan and stick to it. And Josh Dallas better be naked.
|by Anonymous||reply 4||08/29/2018|
Looks good for maybe two, three episodes.
|by Anonymous||reply 5||08/29/2018|
They just said "goddamn" on NBC. Don't recall any of the big 3 networks going there before.
|by Anonymous||reply 6||09/24/2018|
I'm watching "The Good Doctor." How is "Manifest"? Is it worth catching up with later?
|by Anonymous||reply 7||09/24/2018|
Can you imagine disappearing in 2013 and then landing in 2018 to having Trump as your president, having racists run amuck and being the bitch of the Russians? Talk about harsh.
|by Anonymous||reply 8||09/24/2018|
5 years? That's it?
|by Anonymous||reply 9||09/24/2018|
So how was it?
|by Anonymous||reply 10||09/24/2018|
I haven't watched it yet and I will watch it on On Demand this week. But it seems like a ripoff of Lost. I hope it is not that complicated. It would have been better if they had been flying around for 50 years though.
|by Anonymous||reply 11||09/24/2018|
I think they're also repeating it on Friday night.
Seems just like an extended episode of "Twilight Zone." Not saying it's not good (I haven't watched it yet) but don't know how they're going to stretch this out over a whole season, let alone five years should it be a hit.
|by Anonymous||reply 12||09/24/2018|
First episode was interesting. I won't spoil it but it's not really like lost. There weren't any flashbacks to the life before. You find out about everyone's past real time and it's pretty straightforward that they return a bit changed.
|by Anonymous||reply 13||09/24/2018|
I watched it...I think it was the Greys.
|by Anonymous||reply 14||09/24/2018|
The pilot was pretty good. But they always have a hard time sustaining these types of shows.
|by Anonymous||reply 15||09/24/2018|
I’m not sure where it’s heading. It’s not the happiest of the shows, that’s for sure.
|by Anonymous||reply 16||09/24/2018|
[quote]The pilot was pretty good. But they always have a hard time sustaining these types of shows.
The networks have tried so many of these high-concept shows over the years, most of which crashed and burned after about a half-season ("Flash Forward," "The Invasion," "The Event," to name but a few) but it only takes one to finally hit big (like "Lost") to make all the duds worth the effort.
When you think about it, though, it's actually a good thing -- there are only so many doctor, cop and lawyer shows one can watch before you start to desire something completely different.
|by Anonymous||reply 17||09/24/2018|
If they commit to a show like this, it should be a short, tight season. Not 20+ episodes.
|by Anonymous||reply 18||09/24/2018|
They have a Bible quoting mother? Did I stumble on Christian Broadcasting by accident?
|by Anonymous||reply 19||09/24/2018|
Networkso are greedy. 22 episodes. It they could they would program even in the summer r19
|by Anonymous||reply 20||09/24/2018|
Remember “The Dome”?
|by Anonymous||reply 21||09/24/2018|
Yes I do R21. I was trying to remember what TV show this reminded me of and bingo, The Dome.
|by Anonymous||reply 22||09/24/2018|
There's not enough spooky stuff.
|by Anonymous||reply 23||09/24/2018|
After that failed 4400 rip-off, The Crossing, I am surprised they try another one of these type of family drama, mystery sy fy shows.
|by Anonymous||reply 24||09/24/2018|
Looks like a LOST ripoff. I give it a season.
|by Anonymous||reply 25||09/25/2018|
It does remind me a lot of The Dome, which I felt had a strong start but then got lame. Hopefully when they pitched this, they had more substance for future seasons.
|by Anonymous||reply 26||09/25/2018|
Reviews have been awful.
|by Anonymous||reply 27||09/25/2018|
The Dome started off fantastic but then went downhill.
|by Anonymous||reply 28||09/25/2018|
I thought t had a good story line but I can see it is going to be dragged out. I kept looking at the time to see if it was almost over. I agree that it would have been great as a short mini series where we know we are eventually going to find out what happened instead of waiting several seasons or it just ending because no one is watching.
I love programs like the The Sinner because you know the end is coming in the 10 episodes. Then a different story line starts but with some of the same characters. Also when a good program is coming to the end you don't want it to end so having a new story keeps it going. I find that these short stories hold my attention far better than these dragged out, season after season programs.
|by Anonymous||reply 29||09/25/2018|
I like the premise, but I was unimpressed with the execution.
|by Anonymous||reply 30||09/25/2018|
Any reson why the former fiance cop would have two different last names? On the show he's called Jared Vasquez, on the show's site he's listed as Jared Williams and on IMDB as both. Just sloppiness?
|by Anonymous||reply 31||09/25/2018|
No thanks. I didn't even bother. So dumb. Why do they waste money and shit like this?
|by Anonymous||reply 32||09/25/2018|
Well the show is considered a ratings winner based on overnights.
|by Anonymous||reply 33||09/25/2018|
The production quality is pretty low. Some bad continuity issues here and there. Just overall disappointing.
|by Anonymous||reply 34||09/25/2018|
I started laughing out loud when the sister chick kept whipping around that junkyard lot every time she heard "Set them free!" Also, anyone who didn't see that she was going to find the missing girls from about a mile away...
I'll stick with it for a couple of episodes to see where things are going. I want to see the sister confront her former best friend who is now married to her former fiancé.
|by Anonymous||reply 35||09/25/2018|
Yes the case of the week with the missing girls was far too obvious and a bit of a waste of a pilot storyline. I assume each episode will feature one of the different 191 passengers as a guest star, while the main family and the doctor remain the focus?
I thought the premise was promising and glad the didn’t stay in government holding for long. I will easily continue watching.
|by Anonymous||reply 36||09/25/2018|
At least this garbage is a relatively fresh idea and not a rehash like Magnum PI and Murphy Brown and Will and Grace and the rest
|by Anonymous||reply 37||09/25/2018|
I don't know if that's saying something about Young Sheldon and The Big Bang Theory (which I saw before the first episode of Manifest) but I the biggest laugh I had today was watching the show in the scene where the leading lady reacts to the news of her mom being dead.
|by Anonymous||reply 38||09/26/2018|
Magnum was really bad, by the way.
|by Anonymous||reply 39||09/26/2018|
I don't get the ending of the pilot. They were all called to the hanger to watch their plane explode?
|by Anonymous||reply 40||09/26/2018|
Just watched it. Thought it was interesting, maybe worth another couple of viewings, but doubt I stick with it after that.
I agreed with one critic's assessment, which is that out of a plane filled with almost 200 passengers, the series is only going to focus on this boring brother and sister every week? Perhaps not (we'll have to wait and see) but so not a smart choice if that ends up being the case.
|by Anonymous||reply 41||09/29/2018|
[quote]I hope they have a plan and stick to it. And Josh Dallas better be naked.
Naked? On prime time network TV?
This must be a joke. Though, it was pretty funny today, MSNBC tried to keep censoring Janelle Monae's singing "fuck" every five seconds in a few on her songs she performed at the Global Citizen concert. It was hilarious, no sooner they *bleeped' out a 'fuck', there was another one right behind! Janelle's performance was great. In fact, the entire show has been quite entertaining. It's still on in case anyone is interested.
|by Anonymous||reply 42||09/29/2018|
Mmm, yes, I am definitely down for some naked Josh Dallas.
|by Anonymous||reply 43||09/29/2018|
This is the dopest concept for a primetime show I've seen in some time. Melodrama and all, this shit looks good. I will be tuning in.
|by Anonymous||reply 44||09/29/2018|
r11, Nah I disagree. I think that amount time would make the show too sci-fi and the emotional punch would be lost because so much what have to be focused on how much of the world has changed. 5 years is perfect because it introduces aa supernatural or sci-fi twist while still rooting it in reality.
|by Anonymous||reply 45||09/29/2018|
The NBC voiceover is crowing that the show got the highest ratings of the week. Good for them - now just make sure you keep the show interesting enough so viewers want to keep coming back.
|by Anonymous||reply 46||09/30/2018|
the guy from magnum is sexy but i still won't watch it
|by Anonymous||reply 47||10/01/2018|
The actress playing the lead is really unattractive -- especially those caterpillar eyebrows. And I haven't heard of a single person in the cast. A show like this needs at least one fairly well-known actor/actress--even if it's just in a supporting role.
|by Anonymous||reply 48||10/01/2018|
So how was the second episode?
|by Anonymous||reply 49||10/01/2018|
R48, Josh Dallas is a big star. You somehow missed those 134 eps he did of OUAT?
The second episode was decent. A problem I have is that you can predict everything involving the case of the week a million miles away. The ongoing mystery stuff is much better.
|by Anonymous||reply 50||10/02/2018|
r50 Yes, I missed every single one of them. OUAT was never a huge pop-culture success.
|by Anonymous||reply 51||10/02/2018|
Manifest is a wild sex club in Atlanta
|by Anonymous||reply 52||10/02/2018|
Still not spooky. Just tedious.
|by Anonymous||reply 53||10/02/2018|
How many episodes until Daddy gets it on with son's cancer doctor?
|by Anonymous||reply 54||10/02/2018|
I was thinking the same thing R54. I'm actually enjoying the show, but I don't know how long they can go with the premise. I hate when something seems unfinished and it did with the dogs and the girls. Why did he kidnap the girls? The dogs obviously were docile, what happened to them?
|by Anonymous||reply 55||10/02/2018|
R55, you can’t get hung up on the details of the case of the week. Just like this week’s case, we never found out much about the son who robbed the jewelry shop. Why did he do it? Wouldn’t he inherit the store anyway? Was he in financial trouble and needed money ASAP?
None of it matters. You solve the case of the week and move on to next week’s.
|by Anonymous||reply 56||10/02/2018|
Hopefully they will resolve the issues I had R56 in later episodes. I know what you are saying, but, like I said it is unfinished. I just don't see them revisiting. Maybe I need to step back and look at the picture they are trying to paint.
|by Anonymous||reply 57||10/02/2018|
[quote]Hopefully they will resolve the issues I had in later episodes.
SPOILER ALERT: They won't.
|by Anonymous||reply 58||10/03/2018|
I hope we find out that there's a really stupid reason why the plane disappeared for 5 years.
I enjoy the sassy black flight attendant.
|by Anonymous||reply 59||10/05/2018|
Of course is a network show. It's trite and jejune. Could've been cutting edge TV back in 2002.
|by Anonymous||reply 60||10/05/2018|
So when is it on?
|by Anonymous||reply 61||10/05/2018|
I give it til December.
|by Anonymous||reply 62||10/07/2018|
I didn't hate it, which surprises me. I couldn't stand Lost, and probably didn't bother with any of the other shows you're citing.
|by Anonymous||reply 63||10/07/2018|
Josh Dallas's voice sounds just like some other actor's. Does anyone know who I mean?
|by Anonymous||reply 64||10/07/2018|
So where were they?
|by Anonymous||reply 65||10/07/2018|
Great premier but believe it has already run out of steam. Reminds me of how Salvation began quite strong, then just fizzled out. I may watch it again.
|by Anonymous||reply 66||10/07/2018|
Josh Dallas is so hot. Shirtless scenes please.
|by Anonymous||reply 67||10/07/2018|
There are also some elements of Sens8, or should I say Sens828.
|by Anonymous||reply 68||10/07/2018|
[quote]Any reson why the former fiance cop would have two different last names? On the show he's called Jared Vasquez, on the show's site he's listed as Jared Williams and on IMDB as both. Just sloppiness?
I doubt it’s sloppiness, especially on IMDB, and I have a feeling we will find out in future episodes.
|by Anonymous||reply 69||10/08/2018|
Who is playing the role of Grace's new boyfriend/husband? I hope he is as hot as Josh Dallas and Jared.
|by Anonymous||reply 70||10/08/2018|
They all wear too much makeup. Even the men are rouged and lipsticked like they are doing Moliere in community theater.
|by Anonymous||reply 71||10/08/2018|
Are we ever going to meet him, r70, or will he be tossed away like yesterday’s newspaper?
|by Anonymous||reply 72||10/08/2018|
I have a solution: throuples -tons of them! The brother and sister leads couldn’t possibly have been the only ones in that whole flight who got replaced by their spouses or significant others.
Another thing we could see from space was that it was not going to end well for that obnoxious woman who demanded sodium-free snacks. They worked so hard at making her unlikeable.
|by Anonymous||reply 73||10/08/2018|
COMPLETELY UNREALISTIC because they handed out peanuts on the plane. Airlines don't do that anymore! I lost all sense of belief at that point.
|by Anonymous||reply 74||10/08/2018|
Well R74, they boarded 5 years ago and they served peanuts then.
|by Anonymous||reply 75||10/08/2018|
It’s true that in 2013 an airline could still have been serving peanuts. The show is taking place in the present, not five years in the future.
|by Anonymous||reply 76||10/08/2018|
They probably threw that line in as a cue to a different era, like a restaurant hostess asking if someone wants “smoking or non-smoking”.
|by Anonymous||reply 77||10/08/2018|
Yeah, I got that after they revealed the flight was actually in 2013. Was a jarring detail. Although it would have been funny if the children had suddenly developed deathly peanut allergies because they didn't exist in 2013.
|by Anonymous||reply 78||10/08/2018|
I thought last night was better than the second episode. The case of the week was more integrated into the ongoing plot, but the reveal that it was the housekeeper was especially disappointing. Also, why throw in that the husband was running businesses with illegals and abusing them, only to have no resolution?
|by Anonymous||reply 79||10/09/2018|
The twin kid with the disease is a terrible actor.
The brother dad is super cute.
|by Anonymous||reply 80||10/09/2018|
Is this show the most interracial thing ever or is it just me? Every couple seems to be mixed race.
|by Anonymous||reply 81||10/09/2018|
Wait, the cop in the flashback from 5 years ago said she was calling UBER! But Uber wasn't around in 2013, at least not that widespread. BAD WRITING! FLAW!!! Illusion ruined!!
|by Anonymous||reply 82||10/09/2018|
Uber was founded in 2009, and it was certainly already thriving in New York by 2013.
|by Anonymous||reply 83||10/09/2018|
|by Anonymous||reply 84||10/09/2018|
It’s turning into a cop procedural with a dash of sci-fi.
|by Anonymous||reply 85||10/09/2018|
Interesting premise but seems like it'd play itself out very quickly.
|by Anonymous||reply 86||10/09/2018|
Pilot episode was quite well done. Very intriguing premise. I enjoyed it a lot. However, I could also easily have dropped it right there and been satisfied.
But since it is the best new series I've seen this year, I figured I would give the second episode a shot. It was rather dull. And very dark, both in terms of tone and lighting. I was fairly bored, but made it through to the end of the episode.
Had already scheduled the third episode to record, so I have that in my DVR. Was planning to delete it, but someone upthread said the third episode was better than the second. So, maybe I'll give it a try.
As many have said, I don't see how this premise can sustain itself over a 22 episode season. Seems like it should have been done as an 8 or 10 episode miniseries.
|by Anonymous||reply 87||10/09/2018|
I like the show so far. I won't miss it if it gets cancelled but I'll keep watching.
|by Anonymous||reply 88||10/09/2018|
[quote]The twin kid with the disease is a terrible actor.
There’s terrible acting pretty much all around. The lead girl and her Julia Roberts wannabe trembly voice to indicate upset, The Dallas Posturing, the wife’s permanent wince, Jared’s frozen soap opera acting techniques (he even has a cliché soap name!), ... only the older daughter gets a pass.
|by Anonymous||reply 89||10/10/2018|
It’s all about the interesting premise, acting and writing be damned.
|by Anonymous||reply 90||10/10/2018|
Episode three was good, but Astronauts could see whodunnit. Still good enough intrigue that’s not gonna win any major awards.
|by Anonymous||reply 91||10/11/2018|
I am enjoying it. I never like shows like this. The fact that I want Josh Dallas to cum in my mouth may have something to do with it.
|by Anonymous||reply 92||10/11/2018|
So the mystery of where they were is supposed to last four or five seasons or more?
|by Anonymous||reply 93||10/11/2018|
Yes - the mystery of the week might be the weakest, most contrived part of the show, but think they are doing a better job showing the fall-out of being gone 5.5 years and the family members moving on. They have been pretty even-handed at showing the wife being in a no-win situation and paint all sides being more victims of the situation then good or bad guys, and simply showing how Cal's old friend was so much bigger than him and outgrown him was simple and effective. While I cringed a bit at the daughter/sister;s reaction to her Mom's death, I thought she did a good job today. Dallas also did a good job with his scene at the end, and shows he can act when they have him do more than be a cardboard hero.
Once Upon a Time largely sidelined him and his wife once she became pregnant in the third season, but he had some moments of princely hotness the first season, and in his last season he had a breakdown with Hook.that was more interesting than watching Regina continue to whine about being a hero now or seeing Rumpelstiltskin go through his tenth redemption while continuing an abusive relationship with Belle which was disturbingly meant to be seen as romantic.
Onice might have been a huge hit, but it did have a following when it was first on although that devolved into a rather crazy fanbase by the end.
|by Anonymous||reply 94||10/11/2018|
This short might have given Dallas more to do than Once did in most of episodes his last three seasons (he usually got one episode a half a season where he was more heavily featured). It is actually pretty well done.
|by Anonymous||reply 95||10/11/2018|
NBC never knows how to handle high concept. It will never make it to a second season.
|by Anonymous||reply 96||10/11/2018|
The ratings don't suck (for 2018).
|by Anonymous||reply 97||10/11/2018|
I think it will get a second season and then will start to run into problems of maintaining the concept.
It is not the best written show, and for all the high concept premise, it has an old-school network TV feel to it. and can be a bit cheesy. However, that might be part of the reason I like it. It is like some comfort food -- escapism that does not require a lot of thought while watching it with a competent cast that provides enough real moments to keep it watchable.
|by Anonymous||reply 98||10/11/2018|
[quote] escapism that does not require a lot of thought while watching it
I don't want a shitload of detail that doesn't make much sense. That's why I gave up on Lost.
|by Anonymous||reply 99||10/11/2018|
I loved Kings about 10 years ago and NBC didn't know what to do with it. I predict a similar fate for this show.
|by Anonymous||reply 100||10/11/2018|
[quote]So the mystery of where they were is supposed to last four or five seasons or more?
Well, some of it is rearing its head, What with the mystery stroke protein in their bloods. Of course, the single renegade doctor gets to find it while the bumbling NSA medical and investigative staff of dozens of professionals who tested all the passengers are busier treating them like aliens, staring at their navels, and chasing their own tails by saying things like “that’s impossible!”
|by Anonymous||reply 101||10/11/2018|
I loved Kings! How many episodes is Manifest? Are they shooting for the whole 23 episode season? Or will it be a shorter season show?
|by Anonymous||reply 102||10/11/2018|
Right now they have not picked up a back 9. They may not get a full 9, but maybe a few extra eps and a season two pick up. New Amsterdam, NBC’s other new drama, did receive a back 9, as did The Resident on FOX.
|by Anonymous||reply 103||10/11/2018|
What’s a back 9?
|by Anonymous||reply 104||10/11/2018|
[quote]Of course, the single renegade doctor gets to find it
In fairness, that would make the most sense. How many of the other passengers would have had a complete blood workup within a relevant time period — both the more critical before and as quickly after arriving back after the time jump — so that the investigators would have had the data to compare?
But yeah, overall, not a good show. There are plot points so obvious that not even Helen Keller could miss them.
|by Anonymous||reply 105||10/11/2018|
In general, most new network shows are only given an initial 13 episode order; this is changing more and more, but traditionally it was the case and is for Manifest and New Amsterdam. If a show does well in the ratings the network will order the “back 9” episodes for a full 22 episode season. While this isn’t a guarantee of a renewal for season two, it’s usually a strong indicator this will happen. Conversely, if a show does not receive a back 9 pick up and simply plays out the initial 13 episode order, that usually means cancellation is in store.
The Resident was a mid-season replacement last year and when it got picked up for season two they only order 13 episodes. FOX was happy with the first three weeks of ratings and gave it the back 9 for a full season.
Lethal Weapon only got 13 eps ordered with their new cast reboot. News of Damon Wayans quitting after the 13 eps all but guarantees the show will be canceled with no back 9 or subsequent seasons.
|by Anonymous||reply 106||10/11/2018|
Thanks r106. Good information there.
|by Anonymous||reply 107||10/12/2018|
Sorry, but IMO, if you waste a lot of time and energy into this show, you're kind of a fool. I don't mean people watching it with a passing interest or out of intellectual curiosity, but getting heavily invested in it.
This is another b.s. "mystery/conspiracy" series in which the writers have no real end game, will wing the "mystery" as they go along and then come up with an explanation that has zero payoff or will be a cheap cop out. Every show of this type has played out this exact same way, even the critically acclaimed The Prisoner. Even if this were the first show in the history of TV to have a decent payoff, NBC will cancel the show years before it gets the chance to resolve the mystery.
|by Anonymous||reply 108||10/12/2018|
I like the show even though it has a filmed in Canada feel, but I think they shoot in New York. The mystery intrigues me. The issue with shows like this is that they are better suited for cable where you have shorter seasons and can keep the story tight. The 22 episode network seasons, mean you're going to have filler episodes that don't really advance the plot.
I hope they have a plan and know what all the answers are. I'm sticking with it for now. Like I said, the only real issues I have are the "Canada feel" and I think some of the actors are miscast. Josh Dallas should have a hotter wife and be shirtless more.
|by Anonymous||reply 109||10/12/2018|
[quote] Josh Dallas should have a hotter wife and be shirtless more.
It would not shock me if he ended up with the doctor.
I have heard Daniel Sunjata has been cast as the wife's boyfriend, so kind of a win-win situation for her.
|by Anonymous||reply 110||10/12/2018|
How is that wife pulling such hot guys?
|by Anonymous||reply 111||10/12/2018|
Because it is a TV show R111. BTW, Daniel Sunjata believes 9/11 was planned by our government.
|by Anonymous||reply 112||10/12/2018|
I think a 22-episode count for Manifest would be deadly too, R109. I think the reason NBC hasn’t picked up further episodes is because they are negotiating with the creators on what to do. This is Us and Empire both do 18-episode orders in an attempt to trim some of that padding and I think Manifest will aim for something similar.
Lower counts are worse for syndication deals, but better for quality. Outside procedurals and half hour comedies, the networks are slowly adapting to shorter, more cable-like seasons. It just means they have to create more shows to fill in the scheduling hours, like Good Girls, which ran for 10 episodes on NBC last season and was picked up for another 10 episode second season to air this spring.
|by Anonymous||reply 113||10/12/2018|
Another Kings lover!
I love good scify but in the long term as a series it tends to jump the shark when they start showing the aliens, or get to involved in the science at the risk of the characters. Or else it starts to get too complicated. The first seasons of Revolution, Zoo, and Under the Dome were great. Then they just got stupid and you couldn't suspend belief. One series i like a lot that seems to balance this out and just be silly fun is The 100. I am liking Manifest but expect it will spiral into stupidity too. Sometimes in these series tgey need to just keep it simple. I also like Colony, but if they ever show the aliens they risk jumping the shark, too.
|by Anonymous||reply 114||10/12/2018|
[quote] BTW, Daniel Sunjata believes 9/11 was planned by our government.
And? Given how much was discovered about the attack since then this is almost commonly accepted knowledge. Most of us have moved on and are now more concerned about Hillary's Emails than what Donald Trump comes up with while sitting on the toilet twittering his ass off.
|by Anonymous||reply 115||10/12/2018|
No it is not commonly accepted R115.
|by Anonymous||reply 116||10/12/2018|
I agree with R115. It is commonly accepted.
|by Anonymous||reply 117||10/12/2018|
r116, shouldn't you keep looking for GWB's Weapons of Mass Destruction instead of wasting your time on DL?
|by Anonymous||reply 118||10/12/2018|
Oh look, another conspiracy nut at R118.
|by Anonymous||reply 119||10/12/2018|
R115 now we know Ms Alex Jones posts here. Please go to Stormfront where you belong and post elsewhere.
|by Anonymous||reply 120||10/12/2018|
r120, Is Breitbart down or something? Is that why you are here and disappointed that there are no new contributions in the presenting hole threads you have tagged in your thread watcher and this thread was the next best thing?
|by Anonymous||reply 121||10/12/2018|
[quote]I agree with [R115]. It is commonly accepted.
The DL does not dispute your claim to be "common".
|by Anonymous||reply 122||10/12/2018|
[quote]I have heard Daniel Sunjata has been cast as the wife's boyfriend, so kind of a win-win situation for her.
I'd rather he'd have been cast as Josh Dallas's lover, which would be a win-win for me.
|by Anonymous||reply 123||10/12/2018|
I enjoy the concept and the show so far, but I wish that they wouldn't even green light one of these shows without the writers having to have the last two episodes of the show written up front. It's the Twin Peaks and Lost syndrome of just wandering around and having no finish line planned out.
Oh, and the lantern-jawed chick playing the sister/cop is horrible.
|by Anonymous||reply 124||10/12/2018|
I haven't had a chance to catch up with the show since the first episode. So far is it only about the brother and sister and their family? What about all of the other people that were on the plane? Have none of them come into the story at all?
|by Anonymous||reply 125||10/12/2018|
R125, if you watch you will see that the main family will be the central focus of the series, but another passenger will step forward each week (or so it appears) to be the case of the week. The passenger from ep 2 was not in ep 3, and third passenger will not feature in the fourth episode.
|by Anonymous||reply 126||10/12/2018|
Ah, okay. Interesting. Thank you, R126.
|by Anonymous||reply 127||10/12/2018|
R125, we’ve been discussing precisely what r126 said throughout the thread. You didn’t read it, did you?
|by Anonymous||reply 128||10/12/2018|
The main reason Lost worked was because the cast for that was distinctive looking and most were such good actors. Everyone in Manifest, like in so many other high concept shows, look totally generic and are mediocre actors. Tick the box casting. Awful. The show doesn’t deserve a full season order.
|by Anonymous||reply 129||10/13/2018|
Lost’s backstories were well-written.
|by Anonymous||reply 130||10/13/2018|
[quote] I enjoy the concept and the show so far, but I wish that they wouldn't even green light one of these shows without the writers having to have the last two episodes of the show written up front. It's the Twin Peaks and Lost syndrome of just wandering around and having no finish line planned out.
Agreed. "Lost" ruined it for these kinds of shows. That finale was so tremendously dreadful that I no longer believe anyone can sustain this concept over a full season, not to mention a full series. Knowing that it can all go so wrong makes me unable to watch or invest in it.
|by Anonymous||reply 131||10/13/2018|
How many passengers were there. If we're going to get one a week that show will be on forever.
|by Anonymous||reply 132||10/13/2018|
I can’t believe it hasn’t been mentioned yet that even though the plane was coming from Jamaica none of the passengers were tanned. The pilot was shot in March. It’s fun to watch the two subsequent episodes, which were shot in July. In scenes like the one in Times Square the extras right next to the main actors are wearing outerwear but if you look closer the “real people” are in summer clothing. In the storyline it’s November.
|by Anonymous||reply 133||10/13/2018|
FBI has also gotten a back 9. Still no word on Manifest. Hmmmm.
|by Anonymous||reply 134||10/13/2018|
They have been missing for 5 years R133? Where do you think they have been, sunning on a Jamaican beach?
|by Anonymous||reply 135||10/13/2018|
[quote]]FBI has also gotten a back 9. Still no word on Manifest. Hmmmm.
The live ratings have been strong,and it is also picking up a lot of additional numbers with the seven day ratings. I think unless it suddenly falls off a cliff, it will get the back 9. Although it would probably be better for the concept of the show, if they renewed it but kept a shorter season.
|by Anonymous||reply 136||10/14/2018|
How big an idiot ARE you, R135? They weren’t tanned at Montego Bay Airport in the opening scenes, either. Jesus.
|by Anonymous||reply 137||10/14/2018|
Your ignorance is noted R137.
|by Anonymous||reply 138||10/14/2018|
R135/138, YOUR ignorance is monumental.
Most of the airplane passengers were coming back from a vacation in JAMAICA. You know, where it’s sunny and hot even in April (when the scene was set). But not one of them, in the airport lounge or airplane) looked sunburnt or tanned.
If you can’t process logic I can’t help you, dipshit.
|by Anonymous||reply 139||10/14/2018|
R139, I'm not R135 or R138, but have you not heard of sunscreen? And is your biggest beef with the show that they don't have tans yet you are willing to suspend your disbelief that they were on an airplane that disappeared for five and a half years and they were unaware as well?
|by Anonymous||reply 140||10/14/2018|
Yeah, I wondered about why none of them looked like they've been on an actual vacation. At first I thought that there would be a twist, but then remembered LOST and that I am way overthinking this and it's just writers being stupid.
|by Anonymous||reply 141||10/14/2018|
Well R139 they weren't on the vacation for 5 1/2 years. Despite what you think tans fade.
|by Anonymous||reply 142||10/14/2018|
Maybe you don’t understand the premise, R142, but all of their bodies are exactly the same. If they had had tans in Jamaica, they would still have the tans now. By your logic their hair would have grown for 5.5 years, as well as their fingernails and toenails. Nothing about them has changed. They were frozen in time.
Jamaica was a poor destination to choose. Even if the core family didn’t have a tan, it would be crazy to think that a certain percentage of the passengers wouldn’t be tan. Also, while I’m sure most of the passengers could be written off as tourists, there should have been a certain percentage of Jamaican/Caribbean residents on the plane who were visiting New York.
Having the plane originate somewhere like Denver would have solved all these problems.
|by Anonymous||reply 143||10/14/2018|
With all the mystery surrounding the passengers somehow I doubt that they came back with no tan will be a big plot line. Maybe they all used the world's best sun block.
|by Anonymous||reply 144||10/14/2018|
True, R144, this is totally nit picky, and really something more worthy of the hate on A Million Little Things Thread, but the fact remains that the writers chose for the flight to depart from Jamaica and no one on the flight looks likel they are traveling home from a Jamaican vacation. Why introduce a detail if you aren’t going to follow through on it?
Regardless of where they departed and even accounting for the 2013 start date, none of the passengers were in sweatpants or hoodies. Have none of these writers/costume department people been on a plane in the past decade- especially one returning from a Caribbean vacation? People are slobs and even New Yorkers would not be dressed up like these passengers. They should have been PINK sweatsuits instead of jeans and leather jackets- at least a good half of the passengers at least.
|by Anonymous||reply 145||10/14/2018|
The fact that really remains, r145, is that no one gives a shit about their tans except you.
|by Anonymous||reply 146||10/14/2018|
Their tans? Priceless.
I love high-concept shows. I’m still in mouring for Resurrection, Awake, Now and Again, Eli Stone and Flashfoward, just to name a few!
But this show? I’m not a big fan of the actress playing Michaela. But I guess I will keep watching. Sigh.
|by Anonymous||reply 147||10/14/2018|
Quite possibly one of the stupidest premises ever for a show. I will NEVAH watch!!!
|by Anonymous||reply 148||10/14/2018|
THANK YOU, R143.
R135/R138/R142, you are beyond obtuse. NONE of the white passengers looked like they’d spent a minute under any sun, much less a day or more in fucking Jamaica. That’s my last word on this, I just needed to berate you one more time for your ignorance and sheer stupidity.
|by Anonymous||reply 149||10/14/2018|
More stupid "Event" shows..all the same. Under the Done, The Event, Flashforward...no wonder Netflix is doing so well.
|by Anonymous||reply 150||10/14/2018|
LMAO who fucking cares about the tan?
|by Anonymous||reply 151||10/14/2018|
R147. I loved Resurrection. It was one of my all time favorite shows. I'm still heartbroken that they took it off, just like that! Bastards. I fear Manifest, which I am enjoying will meet the same fate.
|by Anonymous||reply 152||10/14/2018|
Not to pile on (which I guess is what I'm doing) I love people who watch these supernatural type shows and can suspend disbelief about a plane missing for five years, but the deal breaker is the lack of tans.
|by Anonymous||reply 153||10/14/2018|
And yet R149 a lot of people are point out you and your stupid tan obsession.
|by Anonymous||reply 154||10/14/2018|
Episode 4 was easily the best yet, and we got not one, but two LGBTQ characters this week. Glad they brought up the homophobia in Jamaica. Olive’s gay bff was fun too. I hope we see him again.
I think the lead actress is getting better too.
|by Anonymous||reply 155||10/16/2018|
Regarding the tan issue (passengers leaving Jamaica on a plane). First impression is everything. When such an issue (like the tan situation) is occupying viewers' minds in the pilot you are off to a rocky start. With all this entertainment around people rather look for excuses NOT to watch a show than get emotionally invested in another one.
|by Anonymous||reply 156||10/16/2018|
Plus we got a Tony Kushner shout out! There have to be some gay guys in the writers room.
|by Anonymous||reply 157||10/16/2018|
This show is bad. I couldn't even finish the last episode. Not even Josh Dallas' hotness can save the show.
|by Anonymous||reply 158||10/16/2018|
I know this show is not going to be racking up a lot of acting awards, but I thought Dallas did a nice job with his reaction shot seeing his daughter with the boyfriend. It was a nice touch that instead of showing the jealous husband you saw the heartbroken Dad who realized he had been replaced as a father figure. He briefly looked like he had been kicked in the gut, but they did not go all melodrama with the scene while he regained his composure.. You saw everything you needed to by the look on his face without any dialogue.
|by Anonymous||reply 159||10/16/2018|
The 10/15/18 episode was very good. I think the lead actress is doing a fine job. I just love everything about this show and can't wait for each new episode.
|by Anonymous||reply 160||10/16/2018|
I like it, too. Kqwitcher bitchin, cuntsquad.
|by Anonymous||reply 161||10/16/2018|
Tan-related but I'm not sure why it was so important that they had been in Jamaica of all places. It didn't really matter where the flight took off, unless it did? Maybe the mystery is Bermuda Triangle related.
|by Anonymous||reply 162||10/16/2018|
“Thomas may not know New York? But he sure as hell knows Tony Kushner.”
God, the writing on this show is almost as horrible as most of the actors. But the leading lady, the flight attendant and the NSA chief are all awful.
|by Anonymous||reply 163||10/17/2018|
R157, the episode was written by two women.
|by Anonymous||reply 164||10/17/2018|
You cunts still haven't gotten me to hate it. A Tony Kushner/Bethesda Fountain reference on network TV is okay by me. And Josh Dallas is divine. "Bliss," as the blisscunts might say.
|by Anonymous||reply 165||10/17/2018|
I’ve noticed that the leading girl frequently employs the Gina Rodriguez (Jane the Virgin) acting technique of nervously exhaling through her mouth to denote angst, tension, or pathos.
The whole deep breath reality check. Really amateurish. It gets old.
|by Anonymous||reply 166||10/18/2018|
Three more episodes...
|by Anonymous||reply 167||10/18/2018|
R164, it may have been credited to two women, but these shows are written by committee. I’m sure some gay guy in the writers room threw out that line.
|by Anonymous||reply 168||10/18/2018|
No, R168, that’s not how it works. Only storylines are pitched in the writers room.
|by Anonymous||reply 169||10/18/2018|
3 more episodes than what? Was last week supposed to be the last episode? I wish it was like the old days when shows ran 39 weeks out of the year, at least for the shows I love and Manifest is one of them.
|by Anonymous||reply 170||10/18/2018|
It is one of the highest rated new shows, so I am thinking that the creators think a shorter season would be better for the premise. Then NBC can also have a show like Black List fill the second half of the season.
|by Anonymous||reply 171||10/18/2018|
The third episode just aired, R170. There will be a total of sixteen episodes.
|by Anonymous||reply 172||10/18/2018|
Actually, r172, it is the fourth episode that aired on 10/15/18.
|by Anonymous||reply 173||10/18/2018|
Except R171 that is rarely how it goes. I remember when you had, at most, a three month gap during the summer until new episodes. For some shows you have a fall schedule and then with the holidays you don't see any new episodes until the spring. Network ratings are down because the networks have shortened the number of episodes.
|by Anonymous||reply 174||10/18/2018|
[quote]Network ratings are down because the networks have shortened the number of episodes.
|by Anonymous||reply 175||10/18/2018|
[quote]Network ratings are down because the networks have shortened the number of episodes.
HTGAWM lost me forever the first time they went away between what was it, mid-November and the February sweeps. I realized how stupid the storytelling was, and I could never watch it again. Lost's scheduling had a similar effect on my watching. I was willing to play along for a while, but once they put months between episodes, creating these seasonettes, I was gone.
|by Anonymous||reply 176||10/18/2018|
So, where were they?
|by Anonymous||reply 177||10/20/2018|
Abducted by Secret Lesbians
|by Anonymous||reply 178||10/20/2018|
r108, Lost would have been great. But the producers got greedy and forced out 2 more seasons, that contradicted previous storylines and facts introduce in the series. The ending was crap. Commercialism truly hurts good tv.
|by Anonymous||reply 179||10/20/2018|
It’s their job but it must be difficult to write series like that not knowing how many seasons or episodes to write and have everything wrapped up at the end.
|by Anonymous||reply 180||10/20/2018|
Speaking of tans, Josh Dallas could really use one. He should really be a lot hotter.
|by Anonymous||reply 181||10/20/2018|
Yeah, I don’t get the appeal of Josh Dallas at all. He’s a decent actor but OK looking at best. He’s far from a hunk or a beauty.
|by Anonymous||reply 182||10/20/2018|
He's very bland. An Everyman.
|by Anonymous||reply 183||10/20/2018|
[quote]So, where were they?
IN CONNECTICUT, ROSE!
|by Anonymous||reply 184||10/20/2018|
Dallas is a poor man’s Justin Hartley. And nowhere near as beautiful as Matt Lanter. He’s very meh.
|by Anonymous||reply 185||10/21/2018|
I like him more than either, r185.
|by Anonymous||reply 186||10/21/2018|
Latest ep was a tad “This is Us” with all the time jumping.
|by Anonymous||reply 187||10/22/2018|
The latest ep was more Lost than This Is Us with the series of flashbacks. In fact, this was the Lost-iest of the episodes yet and the imitation worked well. Best episode since the pilot.
|by Anonymous||reply 188||10/23/2018|
I'm enjoying the series except I cannot stand Melissa Roxburgh. Can't act for shit..
|by Anonymous||reply 189||10/23/2018|
And I DESPISE those eyebrows.
|by Anonymous||reply 190||10/23/2018|
And that lantern jaw. Utterly prehensile.
|by Anonymous||reply 191||10/23/2018|
Her underbite and lack of expression kill me every week. How did she even get this role?
|by Anonymous||reply 192||10/23/2018|
Lead actress sucks and that Dallas guy is generic looking but his acting is fine. I am enjoying it but wince every time a character (usually the deceased mom) starts in on the faith stuff. I hope this isn't about God and his angels and a faith based program hiding behind scyfi. I already had to endure the crappy finale to Lost.
|by Anonymous||reply 193||10/24/2018|
I did not like this episode as much as the last but I think they wanted to get the rest of the back story of the relationships established. I was relieved the scene of the boyfriend hugging the wife and daughter was a flashback and they were not stupid enough to be doing that in the present when Dallas could do a cliched walk in on them. I appreciate how they are painting all sides sympathetic and that the boyfriend was part of the family for the last three years, but also think the boyfriend was a little self involved for whining about how he could not be with the family he had been with the last two to three years and not really considering that Dallas had lost five years, but this was his wife and kids for over ten years prior. You should really let them along and see if they can reconcile and let her call you if it does not work out. I do think they have done a decent job of showing that the sons illness had put strains on the family prior to the disappearance without overplaying it.
The Mom was a little too good to be true. Most people I know who have been terminally ill have not been the smiling peacefully accepting their fate while drinking tea in a rocking chair that you tend to see on TV.
I like the clean-cut pretty boy look, so have no problems with Josh's generic factor, plus I do think he is a decent actor. He might not be Justin Hartley buff (I don't watch This is Us - I am assuming he is still ripped), but he has some nice arms chest, and legs (as seen in the Olive flash-back with him in the T and green jeans). I don't know if there have been any shots of it on this show, but he also has a nice ass. I think his dynamic with his daughter is probably the most interesting right now. It is kind of humorous how they have him wear "smart guy" glasses when he is doing math.
|by Anonymous||reply 194||10/24/2018|
Manifest (NBC), 12.3 million viewers and 2.7 rating. Boosted by its lead-in from The Voice, the mystery drama is the fall’s biggest new show. NBC has ordered a total of 16 episodes which will represent a full season.
From Entertainment Weekly
|by Anonymous||reply 195||10/26/2018|
The boy seeing the bright light at the end of this episode reminds me of The Final Countdown time warp. Anyone else remember this movie?
|by Anonymous||reply 196||10/26/2018|
So 16 episodes is what they're calling a full season now. A full season used to be 39 episodes and those episodes had half the commercials. The people involved in shows really had to work way back when.
|by Anonymous||reply 197||10/26/2018|
R197 I’m totally fine with 16 episodes. The show runners aren’t going to give us a bunch of episodes with filler. We should have a fairly tight season where every episode and every scene has a purpose. Too often networks get greedy with hit series and try to stretch them out to 22 episodes and run them into the ground. I’m happy that NBC is letting Manifest breath and can hopefully continue the series 3-4 seasons.
|by Anonymous||reply 198||10/27/2018|
I think it's tremendous!
|by Anonymous||reply 199||10/27/2018|
The last episode was SO BORING. Nothing much happened except near the end. I hope it's not aliens.
|by Anonymous||reply 200||10/27/2018|
New ep starting now...
|by Anonymous||reply 201||11/05/2018|
About time! Why did they skip a week?
|by Anonymous||reply 202||11/05/2018|
The Wicked 15th anniversary special played last week. Maybe they wanted to play that Halloween week.
|by Anonymous||reply 203||11/05/2018|
[quote]Why did they skip a week?
Because they're assholes.
|by Anonymous||reply 204||11/05/2018|
There isn't any chemistry between them but I suspect McKayla and ex-fiance Jared will wind up back together.
|by Anonymous||reply 205||11/05/2018|
Yes - I could see Ben and his wife go either way, but do think McKayla will end up with Jared.
|by Anonymous||reply 206||11/05/2018|
Ben's wife wanted to call her old boyfriend just now when Cal woke up and she was alone. She should have. I don't like her and Ben together. They need to split up so Ben can get with the pretty cancer doctor.
|by Anonymous||reply 207||11/05/2018|
Ugh - of course a breakdown in the privacy of the bathroom would include collapsing on the floor against a wall - cliche number 43 - missing only the shower and running water.
Even though the direction, acting and writing are mediocre, I’m still drawn to the show - not unlike one of those “callings”- because of it’s fascinating premise. Still on board.
|by Anonymous||reply 208||11/05/2018|
So what do we think happened to the plane? At this time I think that the government has discovered/been given alien technology and they made the plane disappear. Those passengers in captivity are being used for experiments, those in the wild are being observed like a control group.
|by Anonymous||reply 209||11/05/2018|
I think they were kidnapped by Secret Lesbians and forced to work in their pubic mines.
|by Anonymous||reply 210||11/05/2018|
I understand why the wife is upset, but I am not sure she has ever really giving thought to what her husband is going through. It is always how her life with was disrupted and what she went through - never that he actually lost five years of his life and missed his daughter growing up. She seems like someone who is always going to find the blame on the other party and minimize her blame.
As heavy handed as the show can be, I think they have done a decent job of showing how a child's illness can cause strain on a marriage and how these issue go back preflight.
|by Anonymous||reply 211||11/05/2018|
The wife is becoming insufferable.
|by Anonymous||reply 212||11/07/2018|
R209, the villain is the corporation, not the government, though I suppose with a big military contractor the difference can be overstated.
|by Anonymous||reply 213||11/07/2018|
What is wrong with Melissa Roxburgh’s face? Why do the want to make us look at it?
|by Anonymous||reply 214||11/07/2018|
Next week looks good. I think this plane was sent into a wormhole (or some other time-traveling alien technology) so they could be analyzed by whatever Big, Bad Government Agency is behind this. It was all planned.
|by Anonymous||reply 215||11/07/2018|
R214, They are not making you do anything. If you don't like looking at her, close your eyes or don't watch the show.
|by Anonymous||reply 216||11/07/2018|
The wife annoyed me last night. I know she's worried about her child, but this is the same universe where a plane went missing for 5 years and people came back not having aged a day. But she has trouble believing that her husband and child are getting some kind of telepathic callings is a stretch too far? Come on lady.
|by Anonymous||reply 217||11/07/2018|
The wife is a little whore and annoying as fuck!
|by Anonymous||reply 218||11/07/2018|
And she’s a Greek-Canadian which makes her just as bad as Nia Vardalos.
|by Anonymous||reply 219||11/07/2018|
The show is losing me a little. The characters just aren’t compelling enough. I liked the mystery in LOST (at first anyway), but I truly enjoyed the characters and learning their backstories. They were interesting and surprising people.
The premise and mystery here is good, but I don’t care what happens to this family.
|by Anonymous||reply 220||11/07/2018|
I've already watched more episodes of Manifest than I could of Lost, and I still like it.
|by Anonymous||reply 221||11/07/2018|
Such wit, r216. I doubt I could keep up with you. For the sake of argument though, let’s just accept, for a moment, that one might choose to watch a show and still find one or more of its actors unattractive. Is not Datalounge just the place to express irritation at the casting of a misshapen monster in a lead role? If not, I will, as you suggest, stop watching, and I’m very sorry to have taken up your time.
|by Anonymous||reply 222||11/07/2018|
Josh does turn me on. Been tivoing the show but only watched first two. Any lingering shirtless Josh scenes I can fast forward to? Once Upon A Time never provided that for me and I tivod every week in the hopes I'd see his nips.
|by Anonymous||reply 223||11/08/2018|
I don't think he has a good body, at least not one producers want to show off. He seems sort of soft to me. There has to be a reason he's clothed most of the time in his shows. Could he have a third nipple or some sort of hideous absorbed twin head?!
|by Anonymous||reply 224||11/08/2018|
There you go. Not crazy about the shaved/greased look, but there’s no question he’s fit enough.
Unless he’s doughed up since this pic was taken...
|by Anonymous||reply 225||11/08/2018|
What did he box in?
|by Anonymous||reply 226||11/08/2018|
I don't remember Once ever showing anyone shirtless.
I don't think he is like instangram model ripped but he is in good shape and has some nice arms, legs, and ass that has been shown off in short sleeve shirts and tight jeans.
|by Anonymous||reply 227||11/08/2018|
Ew, that is still a pretty blah body. It might be ok for a househusband in the suburbs but not for TV.
|by Anonymous||reply 228||11/08/2018|
He's so pretty, JNGASP about his lovely-if-not-flawless body.
|by Anonymous||reply 229||11/08/2018|
I prefer NBC's "MANIMAL" with the late, very sexy and handsome Simon McCorkindale.
|by Anonymous||reply 230||11/08/2018|
The gratuitous ass shot
|by Anonymous||reply 231||11/08/2018|
He has a pretty face but it's still bland. He always reminds me of some other actor whose name I can't remember. Who never existed, because it's sort of a blank canvas.
If he were ripped with abs, they'd be showing off his body, but I can't imagine him that way.
|by Anonymous||reply 232||11/08/2018|
I don't think his abs are ripped - but he is in good enough shape where he looks pretty good in some snug fitting clothes. Unless the guy is in his twenties, I think most of the time people look better with a touch of body fat and not being ultra defined.
|by Anonymous||reply 233||11/08/2018|
I'm still in with the show, but it really does have a high percentage of awful actors.
|by Anonymous||reply 234||11/08/2018|
Josh Dallas is 39.
|by Anonymous||reply 235||11/08/2018|
Agree with 220. After Lost jumped the shark I stayed with it until the end because if the characters. That, and looking at Josh Holloway. I don't feel that way about any of these characters.
|by Anonymous||reply 236||11/08/2018|
Ugh. The mother is so annoying. Josh needs to slap her repeatedly in an episode while she's standing near an open window ten stories up.
"But MY SON!!! Don't leave me alone when I need YOU!"
"He's MY son TOO, you WHORE!@!" *SLAP SLAP SLAP*
*She screams in rage, stumbles and falls out the window to her doom*
"Hooray! Now I can go gay!" *Quickly installs Grindr on his phone*
|by Anonymous||reply 237||11/08/2018|
This last episode was awful. Josh Dallas is a bargain basement Justin Hartley, the wife is incredible annoying and bland at the same time, the NSA guy is an awful actor, the leading lady’s overbite is far from camera ready, the daughter is a cookie cutter young Winona Ryder and I want the little kid to die, already. The only one I can stand is the doctor/scientist/whatever. She’s good.
|by Anonymous||reply 238||11/08/2018|
The wife character is really starting to piss me off.
|by Anonymous||reply 239||11/08/2018|
[quote]Josh Dallas is a bargain basement Justin Hartley
I like Josh a million times more than Justin.
|by Anonymous||reply 240||11/08/2018|
I’m out after this last episode. The sister annoys me trying to one up a woman who’s husband asked her for a divorce after she got off the plane and is living in a motel. Meanwhile she’s surrounded by her family, received a promotion at work, appears to have some new highlights and is in the process of breaking up her former fiancés marriage to her former best friend. Can’t stand her. The wife is annoying as well. Agreed she lives in a world where a plane disappears for 5 years but can’t buy into her husband and son hearing voices. I’ll read the recaps here but no longer a viewer.
|by Anonymous||reply 241||11/08/2018|
What was with that translator woman being bumped into by some random stranger when she was having a conversation with the sister? I thought for sure she’d drop dead by the end of the episode but nope.
|by Anonymous||reply 242||11/08/2018|
Here’s the thing: if you’re not going to make the characters be interesting, then you need to keep the plot compelling and very fast paced. It needs a lot more action.
When Michela and he cop-ex found that off the books lab, they should have snuck back and infiltrated the building, discovering another piece of the puzzle. The plot should be bonkers, but instead it’s slow and boring.
|by Anonymous||reply 243||11/08/2018|
[quote]Ugh. The mother is so annoying. Josh needs to slap her repeatedly in an episode while she's standing near an open window ten stories up.
Yes, dear. I agree with you but your desire to get rid of Eyebrow Teefs just so you can have Josh Dallas all to yourself is very obvious and I applaud you for it. Other than that, your post was hilarious.
|by Anonymous||reply 244||11/08/2018|
So did I, r242
|by Anonymous||reply 245||11/09/2018|
It’s a top 5 show.
|by Anonymous||reply 246||11/12/2018|
This last ep wasn’t great. They just can’t make the mystery interesting enough.
The case of the week with the heart transplant recipient was fine, but nothing special.
|by Anonymous||reply 247||11/13/2018|
The Hispanic kid in the last episode seems to be going for the Oscar. "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! WHYYY!!!!!"
I don't feel sympathy for him and I just want to slap him repeatedly.
This show is boring and the writing is shitty. I'm starting to lose interest in it and mainly watching it now to see what the big mystery is.
|by Anonymous||reply 248||11/13/2018|
That’s why everyone is watching and why it’s such a big hit, silly goose at r248 - the premise. And, just like that critic says, if they manage to keep audiences interested throughout the weak writing and mediocre acting (by revealing bits and pieces about “the big mystery” episode by episode), they might just have a winner with “This Is Us - Lost in the Law and Order of the X-Files.”
|by Anonymous||reply 249||11/13/2018|
I, got one, liked the last episode, because they revealed enough information, tug at our hearts with a donated heart, and now we see that Vance is “not a bad guy anymore.” Apparently they’re delegating major reveal responsibilities to the little sick kid.
|by Anonymous||reply 250||11/13/2018|
I continue to watch and enjoy.
Ben Stone, take off your shirt.
|by Anonymous||reply 251||11/13/2018|
R246 It is not. Manifest has already lost half of the audience compared to the first episode and it will continue to drop because the show sucks. There will be a second season but it will probably be moved to Friday.
|by Anonymous||reply 252||11/13/2018|
R250 how many drinks did you quaff before sitting down to watch?
|by Anonymous||reply 253||11/14/2018|
R231 Do you think his ass crack have hair?
|by Anonymous||reply 254||11/14/2018|
That little boy is unbearable.
|by Anonymous||reply 255||11/14/2018|
I hate it when characters just give up after doing CPR for 15 seconds. I get that it's done because of time limits and drama, but it still annoys the hell out of me.
|by Anonymous||reply 256||11/14/2018|
Where are you getting your information from R252?
[quote]The mystery of “Manifest” is proving too much for viewers to resist.
[quote]According to Live+7 data through week 5 of the current broadcast season, the freshman NBC drama is averaging a 1.8 rating lift in adults 18-49 thus far, an improvement of 106% over its Live+Same Day haul in that measure. In total viewers, the show is averaging more viewer growth than any other broadcast show this season. It is, on average, adding 7.2 million viewers per episode in delayed viewing for 15.4 million viewers total.
[quote]For the week of Oct. 22, “Manifest” grew 114% in the demo to a 3.0 and 87% in total viewers to 13.6 million.
|by Anonymous||reply 257||11/14/2018|
The NSA character has been completely overhauled from the first eps where all he did was yell. New writers?
|by Anonymous||reply 258||11/14/2018|
The "connected" bit is channeling Sense 8. But the episode to episode storylines and tension are so SLOW and plodding and snoozeworthy.
|by Anonymous||reply 259||11/14/2018|
R257 Scroll slightly down to see the table. I'm not saying DVR ratings are not important but looking at the live ratings gives you a better picture of whether the show is doing well or not. I can tell you the show is collapsing fast, especially when you consider it has The Voice as a lead in.
|by Anonymous||reply 260||11/14/2018|
Oh please, face it. Whether you think it’s a good show or not, it’s a hit. Whether or not it is following the footsteps of “A Different World,” “Night Court,” “Family Ties,” “Newhart,” and many other mediocre shows who were blessed to be sandwiched between great shows, is yet to be determined, but it doesn’t make any of those shows, or Manifest for that matter, less of a hit.
I just hope they don’t milk ll “it’s all connected” to a frothy pulp, because the show may all then be “disconnected” too soon.
|by Anonymous||reply 261||11/14/2018|
[quote]That little boy is unbearable.
He reminds me of Brick Heck. I keep expecting him to whisper to his feet every time he opens his mouth.
|by Anonymous||reply 262||11/14/2018|
r261 sure, that's what the Secret Lesbians WANT you to say.
|by Anonymous||reply 263||11/14/2018|
OK you lost me with “the Secret Lesbians.” Not even interested in finding out WTF that means.
|by Anonymous||reply 264||11/14/2018|
I’d bet the farm the little boy will be kidnapped soon.
|by Anonymous||reply 265||11/15/2018|
Yeah that seems likely r265. They have to create false urgency.
|by Anonymous||reply 266||11/15/2018|
The show is dragging. I’m still not not invested in any of the character except for Daniel Sunjata’s David. They’re trying hard to tug at the heart strings but failing miserably imo. Couldn’t they have picked better actors? Talk about a badly cast show.
|by Anonymous||reply 267||11/15/2018|
It's also getting to where you have to follow it very closely to know WTF is going on. I like the show but really don't like to have to pay such attention. I like to be on the computer while I watch TV. I don't want a show to become like studying for the SATs.
|by Anonymous||reply 268||11/15/2018|
I'm only watching for that Josh guy. HAWT to death!
|by Anonymous||reply 269||11/15/2018|
I suspect I am only watching for Josh Dallas, too. If he weren't there, would I be there? I can't say for sure.
|by Anonymous||reply 270||11/15/2018|
I probably wouldn't, but then I mostly watched 'Once Upon A Time' to see him in those tight Prince Charming costumes.
|by Anonymous||reply 271||11/16/2018|
Why is the boring girl who can't act given top billing? At least boring Josh Dallas can act.
|by Anonymous||reply 272||11/20/2018|
Josh's PR or agent must be posting in this thread. He's nothing special.
|by Anonymous||reply 273||11/20/2018|
The wince of pain on the kid’s face as the guy was being jolted by an electric shock was unintentionally hilarious. God, this show is bad.
|by Anonymous||reply 274||11/20/2018|
I wouldn’t call it hilarious but the kid did smirk like Seinfeld and Ben Seaver used to do when delivering punch lines.
I did think it was very sweet of all of the kid’s school friends to ask him to join them at the lunch table. Them they all regressed and shared as if they were back in fifth grade.
|by Anonymous||reply 275||11/20/2018|
He still looks like fifth grade, r275. When you take him and his twin sister together, he is the living emblem of what happened on that plane.
|by Anonymous||reply 276||11/21/2018|
[quote]I did think it was very sweet of all of the kid’s school friends to ask him to join them at the lunch table. Them they all regressed and shared as if they were back in fifth grade
The scene on paper probably was a little contrived, but it was pretty effective in both showing the passage of time, what he had lost, and how he had been part of that group. The dialogue discussing little every day things like lunch swapping traditions helped make it seem real and the day player kids did a good job making it believable.
Promos can be misleading, but it looks like some things will come to a head next week for the holiday break.
I do like the partnership between the irritable Vance and the earnest Ben. Vance is most likely suppressing an urge to smack him on the side of his head (or you never know - throw him over his knee). Ben's boss clearly would like to see him thrown over his lap.
|by Anonymous||reply 277||11/21/2018|
Vance is so much better as a friendly adversary rather than a characterless government goon.
|by Anonymous||reply 278||11/22/2018|
The boy was happy, so something horrible has to happen to him in order to show him that you must never, ever be too happy.
|by Anonymous||reply 279||11/22/2018|
That goes without saying, r279, especially since the boy himself has foreshadowed it to his dad.
|by Anonymous||reply 280||11/22/2018|
On the telecast of the parade today various NBC “stars” spoke of what Thanksgiving meant to them. Of course Dallas and Lantern Jaw represented Manifest. It was a tad unfortunate, though, that Justin Hartley immediately went after Dallas because it exposed Dallas as the Poor Man’s Justin Hartley that he is.
|by Anonymous||reply 281||11/22/2018|
He isn't the "poor man's" anyone, nor anyone's "Justin Hartley."
|by Anonymous||reply 282||11/22/2018|
Who is Justin Hartley? Never heard of him. And no, I don't have Google where I live.
|by Anonymous||reply 283||11/22/2018|
Hartley is the hunky one on This is Us.
Pay attention, R282. Dallas IS the poor man’s Justin Hartley. He’s being pushed as the hunk of Manifest and he is nowhere in Hartley’s league. Or even Ryan Eggold from New Amsterdam.
|by Anonymous||reply 284||11/22/2018|
I like Josh Dallas SO much more than Justin Hartley, if they were to recast Hartley, I would not offer a word of objection. I'd probably enjoy it more. The only Kevin I've liked is the one with the cast on his leg.
I like Ryan Eggold more than Hartley, too, but not as much as Dallas. Sorry, "pay attention" queen.
|by Anonymous||reply 285||11/22/2018|
|by Anonymous||reply 286||11/24/2018|
|by Anonymous||reply 287||11/24/2018|
I’m sorry all you Negative Nancies can criticize the show all you want - and you are mostly right (the acting and the dialogue are pretty bad)- but the plot is getting better and better. It thickens and twists.
And really? This is 2018, and the Black Guy had to be the first character with over 20 lines to get killed?!
|by Anonymous||reply 288||11/27/2018|
Well, it's got to be the black guy, or the white guy background character who suddenly gets a sympathetic spotlight out of nowhere. Or the lesbian.
|by Anonymous||reply 289||11/27/2018|
Or the gay man commits suicide. Recently I’ve been watching a lot of gay short films whose previews look sweet, and to this day they are still producing a lot of garbage with tragic endings caused by the fact that they are gay.
|by Anonymous||reply 290||11/27/2018|
I’m sad they killed Vance, but this fall finale was pretty exciting. The rescuing of the patients was thrilling; the one thing that bogs down the show is Grace (Dallas’ wife). I hope there is a twist where Vance is still alive. We never saw a body.
|by Anonymous||reply 291||11/27/2018|
[quote] I hope there is a twist where Vance is still alive. We never saw a body.
This would not shock me. I hope this is the case, I liked his prickly partnership with Dallas -- his skeptical sometimes eye-rolling reactions were a good counter to Ben's impulsiveness.
I thought it was a decent episode and agree Grace could go on the back burner and I would not be sad.
It would not surprise me if Fiona (professor/research lady) ended up bad - or at least shady. I also can see the mole end up having an attack of conscience and switch sides.
|by Anonymous||reply 292||11/27/2018|
Good episode, but I'm really starting to hate the whiny wife - he should have smacked her and taken both kids.
|by Anonymous||reply 293||11/27/2018|
|by Anonymous||reply 294||11/27/2018|
They need to visit Pamplona for some reason during the running of the bulls. The shrew wife will be whining and complaining about "her needs" and how Josh Dallas's character isn't there for her and she will gesture dramatically, signalling the bulls to stampede. She'll be horribly maimed and disfigured and they can replace her with a less obnoxious actress after "extensive plastic surgery". Or, just let her die so Josh can date men and get some of that BBC he so obviously desires.
|by Anonymous||reply 295||11/27/2018|
The actor who played Vance was awful. I hope he stays dead.
|by Anonymous||reply 296||11/27/2018|
[quote] We never saw a body.
Lantern Jaw said she saw Vance being carted into an ambulance, implying he was still alive - hmmmmmm. And the last thing Vance was told was “you don’t know who you’re desling with” - hmmmmmmm.
You may be on to something.
|by Anonymous||reply 297||11/27/2018|
Well, Ben told Grace about the callings and, so far, everyone who’s been told about the callings has died (except for Jared and only because LJ talked back to the “callers”).
So there may still be hope she will be out of our lives soon, or at least be taught a lesson with a close call so nasty, that she can shut her yap (“don’t you act like you know what losing a son is!!!”), believe Ben and Cal, and follow their lead.
I mean, that little kid has saved the day at least twice with his drawings. Isn’t it time people paid attention?
|by Anonymous||reply 298||11/27/2018|
This will end up like Lost.
|by Anonymous||reply 299||11/27/2018|
Bless you, r295
|by Anonymous||reply 300||11/27/2018|
I thought the episode was ridiculous.
|by Anonymous||reply 301||11/27/2018|
Why was this ep any more ridiculous than any other?
|by Anonymous||reply 302||11/28/2018|
To the Justin Hartley queen: I saw him in a Cold Case rerun yesterday, in which he played yet another prettyboy, and it occurred to me why I don't like him as much as Josh Dallas. "Prettyboy" is all Justin has, whereas Josh is playing a character who's equally brainy and beautiful. Can't call Kevin Pearson brainy by any stretch.
|by Anonymous||reply 303||11/28/2018|
Is Josh Dallas considered a "Pretty boy"? He's certainly attractive, but I wouldn't refer to him as a pretty boy. Hartley is the epitome of a pretty boy--even though I think he looks like an extraterrestrial, personally.
|by Anonymous||reply 304||11/28/2018|
I didn't refer to Josh Dallas as a "prettyboy." I said he was equal parts brains and beauty. And I mean that about his performance in Manifest, which is all I've ever seen him in.
Justin Hartley, OTOH, I've seen in lots of shows, and "prettyboy" is about it, in terms of characters he plays.
|by Anonymous||reply 305||11/28/2018|
They've made the wife unbearable on this show. She's as hateble as Connor was on Angel. Her lack of empathy for what's her husband and child are going through is ridiculous at this point.
|by Anonymous||reply 306||11/28/2018|
[quote] She's as hateble as Connor was on Angel.
I don't know if that's even possible. She's going to have to sped a couple more seasons being completely insufferable first.
|by Anonymous||reply 307||11/28/2018|
I think Dallas is a bit of a pretty boy, but can pull off the vulnerable everyman and can really pull off the concerned father which is probably why he was cast. I have not seen This is Us or really seen Hartley since Smallville, so am not sure he could bring that to the role.
Connor --- I had blocked him out. Strangely, he was likable in the one episode they brought him back for at the end. He was like the ultimate annoying kid out of nowhere that was brought on to shows near the end of their runs in the 70's and 80's. He even had a bit of a bowl cut.
I think the wife really started to annoy me when she yelled at Ben for not telling her about the shoplifting, not bothering to ask the circumstances and completely ignoring the fact that her husband just found his daughter with a father-figure that had replaced him or how painful that might have been for him. It did not help that Dallas did a good job of subtly showing how he had been kicked in the gut when he saw his daughter with Danny.
|by Anonymous||reply 308||11/28/2018|
[quote]Why was this ep any more ridiculous than any other?
Deadly gun battle. Exploding oxygen. Kill the incredibly valuable test subjects after recklessly torturing them. I get that there is a sci-fi premise, but this went off the rails in terms of logic and internal consistency. I’m out.
|by Anonymous||reply 309||11/28/2018|
|by Anonymous||reply 310||11/28/2018|
I haven't watched Monday's episode, but the wife is clearly being written in a way where she is slowly coming to the realization that her life was better when the husband and the sick son were thought to be dead. She had a loving and attentive man, her daughter liked him and was close to him, and she was doing okay in life.
The premise is a plane disappeared for 5 years and returned and none of the passengers haven't aged a day and the "deadly gun battle. Exploding oxygen. Kill the incredibly valuable test subjects after recklessly torturing them" is the part where you think it goes off the rails? I'm not sure why some people even get started with these shows, if they are not going to be able to just go with it. If you can't take the leap, then stay away from high concept supernatural/sci-fi shows.
|by Anonymous||reply 311||11/28/2018|
Grace just wants mah dik. Not that nasty Josh Dallas' dong.
|by Anonymous||reply 312||11/28/2018|
R311–obviously I can take the sci-fi leap. None of what I describe is sci-fi or remotely logical behavior for the ordinary humans involved.
|by Anonymous||reply 313||11/28/2018|
They have to make the wife hated so they can have Josh and the lady doc get together. Get it?
|by Anonymous||reply 314||11/28/2018|
That whole Connor season does not hold up well. I mean...it was REALLY dumb. And they didn't explain why he was so angry. It's odd that he's married to the forehead from Gilmore Girls.
|by Anonymous||reply 315||11/28/2018|
Vincent Kartheiser went on to play Pete Campbell in Mad Men which just floored me. He must have played Connor to be as unsympathetic as humanly possible, because I hated every second he was on screen, but Pete Campbell was great. Good actor.
|by Anonymous||reply 316||11/28/2018|
Ok enough about Connor and back to Man-o- fest (and it IS a man fest, lest you forget hunk-cum-daddy bear Daniel Sunjata, and of course Jared and Dallas).
I thought all the patients/subjects had made it out and gone with British Lady. Some people here are saying “kill the incredibly valuable test subjects” and I’m getting confused.
And yeah, complaining about the bullet shower and fire is like buying into Star Wars but then saying the gun battles are fake.
|by Anonymous||reply 317||11/28/2018|
I don't think killing the test subjects, whom you're guilty of kidnapping and torturing, is so strange, nor are exploding oxygen tanks when there's a fire.
|by Anonymous||reply 318||11/28/2018|
It looked to me like the test subjects got out, but the "scientists", the head creep, a couple of soldiers and Vance didn't.
|by Anonymous||reply 319||11/28/2018|
Oxygen feeds a fire, but doesn’t explode like hydrogen.
|by Anonymous||reply 320||11/28/2018|
Just to wrap up the Connor thing. Connor was stolen and lived in a hell dimension with someone who hated Angel. That person raised Connor to hate Angel.
Now back to Josh Dallas and Daniel Sunjata and that wife who isn’t hot enough for either one. And why does this show have that shot in Canada look when it is filmed in New York?
|by Anonymous||reply 321||11/28/2018|
R321, because most of it is shot on Long Island and in Westchester which looks like Canada.
|by Anonymous||reply 322||11/28/2018|
[quote]Just to wrap up the Connor thing.
Really, enough already.
|by Anonymous||reply 323||11/28/2018|