I had to stop myself!! I could have kept going. Tried to eliminate ones I'd seen listed already. Love this thread.
James Franco - Pineapple Express
Ricardo Meneses - O Fantasma
James Dean - East of Eden
John Friedrich - The Final Terror
Eric Roberts - Star 80
Max Parrish - Hole Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me
Rory Calhoun - The Red House
Antonio Banderas - Tie Me Up! Tie Me Down!
Hart Bochner - Apartment Zero
Bard Pitt - Fight Club (no contest)
Frederic Malgras - Marie Baie des Anges
Paul McGann - Withnail and I
Jack Noseworthy - Cecil B Demented
Doe Dallesandro - Heat/Flesh
Thom Hoffman - The Fourth Man
Leigh McCloskey - Inferno
Paul Belmondo - Pierrot le Fou
Alain Delon - Le Samourai
Casper Van Dien - Starship Troopers
Adam Driver - Girls (tv)
Christian Bale - The Mechanic
Paul Walker - Joy Ride
Tom Hardy - I find he looks hotter in various non-film photos online than in his films
Josh Hartnet - The Faculty
Paul Dinello - Strangers With Candy (tv)
Warren Beatty - Dobbie Gillis (tv - 2 episodes)
Robert De Niro - Taxi Driver
James LeGros - Near Dark (actually, many others)
Thomas Haustein - Christiane F.
John Karlen - Dark Shadows (tv show)
Dick Rude - Repo Man
Dermot Mulroney - Bright Angel/Where the Day Takes You
Harrison Ford - The Conversation