It sounds like r26's conservatism, judgmentalism, perfectionism and absolutism are holding him back. And the neediness is driving your despair.
Stop being so needy. Find work, hobbies, friends or family in life who are worth living for if you want to be attractive. Curling up and dying because you don't have a boyfriend is weak. If I were dating you and found out your life is all about me and you can't stand on your own or have anything else going on, I would be scared. I'd know you're helplessly co-dependent and I'll be carrying you all the time like a baby.
And are you looking for a boyfriend in your league? Are you seeking partners who are hotter or richer than you? Who knows what type of person you pursue if you ever had the courage to leave your social/moral/mental shells.
I can respect that you want monogamy. But you have to understand, not only do half of gay men want open relationships — the "monogamous" half just ends up cheating outside the marriage, anyway. Because promiscuity and the desire for sexual variety is strong in men — a biologically wired tendency. I can honestly say that anyone who expects a gay man to remain monogamous is naiive and you're putting your expectations too high. But it is possible and the illusion of monogamy carries some marriages through.
I don't want you to compromise your monogamy if you feel that strongly about it. But be sober: you're automatically limiting yourself to an even smaller pool of gay men. And even if you find someone who promises monogamy, you still need to bond over stronger stuff to stay together and NOT BE SURPRISED when you find out he cheated.
Staying in a small town further limits your opportunities. Bigger cities will have more guys AND jobs to choose from and you might find a good social group again. Your lesbian doc was probably right about that.
But women might not be the best therapists for men, anyways -- they're always going to have a tougher time understanding and relating to men, especially gay men. Lesbian dynamics and biology are WAY different than gay men's. She wouldn't know how to navigate it, honestly.
There's no way I would take ever take dating or relationship advice from a straight person -- doctorate or not. Not a lesbian, either. They might have good insights on other subjects, however.
[quote]Everyone want's someone who's 20, both the young guys and the older guys. There I was at 32 and invisible to both groups.
Bullshit, you haven't interviewed everyone in both groups. You're making defeatist generalizations. And you're in a small town with little to choose from.
It's telling that the social circle you liked -- and lost -- mostly didn't have jobs. One was based on a daughter's locale? That means there was no substance to the arrangement and nothing in it for you. It was never going to last.
Move to a bigger city and/or pursue a better career. You just need a bigger pool of opportunities and people. That's what your friends of quality did.