Hundreds of Transgender California Inmates Request Transfers to Women’s Prisons

I predict every straight man in the Ca prison system is going to claim they identify as whatever-it-takes to get into women's prisons (and to the promised land of wet poo-say.)

Seriously, those legislators didn't think that would happen? Dumbasses!

This will not end well.

You reap what you sow.

LITTORAL VIOLINS

You can't 'claim' to be Intersex - it's a physically verifiable condition (or rather conditions).

Excellent, R3!

Well, hopefully this will force some standards over what can be defined as transgender. Throwing on a dress and a slap of lipstick shouldn't be a qualifier.

Or they can create their own cell block - that's probably the best solution. I believe they've had that at Riker's Island for years.

And we all know how this will end....

LOL mass incarcerated trolling.

What about the human rights of incarcerated women?

This was the issue that made me jump on the TERF Bandwagon.

When absolute self ID was being taken through the British Parliament by stealth feminists started asking what would happen with prisons and the trans campaigners responded with WHY ARE YOU ACCUSING ALL TRANS WOMEN OF BEING SEXUAL PREDATORS and shouting TRANS WOMEN ARE WOMEN rather than addressing the issue and the potential issues.

Then the "Karen White" case happened and it proved the point. The details are still not clear - there are some claims that one of the women raped by serial rapist White suffered internal injuries that needed hospital treatment - but White or whatever he calls himself will now be kept in a men's prison.

There was also a case recently about a trans man (born female) who had sexually attacked someone (possibly a child) and was being kept in a women's prison - again, the right decision.

Like shooting fish in a barrel

Literal violence. Oh I can't wait!!!

This volume means it's easy to solve the situation. But the 1,129 trans inmates in their own quarters with each other.

I agree with R6 - it should be something like only fully transitioned people i.e. no longer have their dick. That'd soon separate the wheat from the chaff. And if that's 'unfair', well, they want to be women and that's how women are separated.

While there are plenty of sincerely trans women in prison, any man can put on a frock and lipstick and proclaim “I’m a woman”. I hope the prison system is implementing some sort of screening before transferring these people.

Stunning and brave!

TRANS 👏🏾 WOMEN 👏🏾 RAPISTS 👏🏾 ARE 👏🏾 WOMEN 👏🏾 RAPISTS

What I don't get is, when transgender prisoners with a history of sexual assaults or personal crimes against women are transferred to women's prison... why aren't they segregated from the general population?

I’m sorry so you’re blaming potential straight men lying and gaming a system on transgender people? Even tho the ones causing the (potentially nonexistent) problem you’re complaining about aren’t really transgender?

[quote]CCWF, VSPW and CIW have a combined capacity of 5010. There are currently 8268 prisoners being held in these three facilities, putting their combined occupation at 161% of design capacity. (California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation data).

So women's prisons in California are already way over capacity, and now they're going to put a load of ejaculators in there.

Clearly Trans women don’t belong in mens prisons with the long history of rape behind bars.

[quote]I’m sorry so you’re blaming potential straight men lying and gaming a system on transgender people? Even tho the ones causing the (potentially nonexistent) problem you’re complaining about aren’t really transgender?

YES YES YES YES YES

Men who take pleasure in abusing women (like "Karen White") will manipulate rules on self ID and attempt to move from a men's prison to a women's prison, a place where vulnerable women are in great supply. That's the problem with self ID with NO restrictions.

Because TRANS WOMEN ARE WOMEN PERIOD it's transphobic to differentiate between 1. trans women who have a diagnosis of gender dysphoria, have started medical treatment and had surgeries and 2. trans women with beards, hairy chests, permanent erections and who maybe have an ear pierced.

This is gonna turn out well. s/

R22 so you agree, the problem is with lying straight men, rather than trans people. Because the way this thread is framed one would almost think that everyone is blaming trans people for the behaviour of non trans people! Which would be crazy.

[quote][R22] so you agree, the problem is with lying straight men, rather than trans people. Because the way this thread is framed one would almost think that everyone is blaming trans people for the behaviour of non trans people! Which would be crazy.

Fuck off with your fake concern.

As the article says, non binary people can now apply to be transferred to a women's prison.

So it's not a question of men's prisons and women's prisons, it's a question of prisons for men and prisons for anyone who isn't a man.

But while you're here, read this article about Karen White and share your thoughts on whether he should be put into a men's prison or a prison with vulnerable women, the majority of which have not committed a violent offence.

[quote] the majority of which

First of all women aren’t objects you don’t use ‘which’ to describe them, great starting point if you’re pretending that your interest in this story is about protecting women.

I believe one of the political aims of the transgender movement is to abolish women’s prisons, so I’m not going to enter a discussion on whether or not that person should be placed into a women’s prison and whether or not that is ‘correct’ because I agree with that political aim and don’t believe in prison for women.

Your problem is with men that are lying about being trans when they’re not trans, not trans people, don’t confuse yourself.

[quote]Even tho the ones causing the (potentially nonexistent) problem you’re complaining about aren’t really transgender?

Oh? Do tell us who determines, and based on what criteria, whether someone is "really" transgender. Trans and their supporters demand self-ID while duplicitously refusing to acknowledge the very real and dangerous loopholes self-ID creates. You can't have it both ways, moron.

Hundreds?

R27 we can go round and round on this but your problem is with cis / straight men exploiting trans people not trans people sorry.

[quote]I believe [bold]one of the political aims of the transgender movement is to abolish women’s prisons[/bold], so I’m not going to enter a discussion on whether or not that person should be placed into a women’s prison and whether or not that is ‘correct’ because [bold]I agree with that political aim and don’t believe in prison for women.[/bold]

Why abolish women’s prisons? Facilities are separate for a reason, the idea of co-ed prisons is a disaster waiting to happen and would probably end up costing tax payers even more. I imagine prisons would need their own obstetrics departments.

Nobody’s shocked by “hundreds”?

The easiest/best solution is for people like this (who undoubtedly are under terrifying risks, (deaths, rapes, or severe beatings) in the male prisons every day of their lives), should be housed in a separate facility. If there are 1100 total, that would be a sufficient number to justify opening up a block or ward just for them.

Whoops, I misread the article. Only 261 out of the total of 1100 who have self-identified as non-binary have requested this change.

I’ll bet there are ZERO ftm trying to get in the men’s prison.

Oh no R34.

[quote][R27] we can go round and round on this but your problem is with cis / straight men exploiting trans people not trans people sorry.

The circular logic is incredible.

This trans man was SHOCKED AND APPALLED by the transphobic attitude of the women he was locked up with but didn't make the case for his transfer to a men's prison.

And nowhere does it say what his crime was.

R30 you misunderstand me. No women’s prisons - I don’t mean co-ed. I mean not placing women in prisons. It’s a bit radical sure but there’s a lot of material out there about how useless women’s prisons are, for general society and the women held in them.

A woman was raped by a transgender inmate in Illinois...

That transgender inmate was in prison for shooting two people, they strangled one of their previous cellmates to death. How do you rationalize sending someone like that to a women’s prison?

You're contradicting yourself, OP. You claim that this is just trans people.....but then say it includes intersex people, non-binary, etc

How do you rationalize keeping any woman in any prison?

R40, you think bio females have never killed anyone?

“Hundreds” should be questionable. Clearly these are men who are pulling a fast one in order to get women.

First, everyone’s “innocent” in prison; now everyone’s a “woman”.

[quote]you think bio females have never killed anyone?

I have never heard of a female inmate strangling her cellmate to death.

[quote]No women’s prisons - I don’t mean co-ed. I mean not placing women in prisons.

Then every single man in male prisons is going to claim he's a woman -- and under current trans ideology, that claim can't be questioned.

Countdown to Ooze coming into this thread and posting that we’re not allowed to talk about this...

I don't even think California would do that.

Best thing to do is have a transgender unit in one of the prisons.

You should only be allowed to transfer once you’ve completely transitioned, i.e., have had sex reassignment surgery. This is almost the only way to prevent the deranged from pretending to be trans to get at “fresh meat.”

[quote]How do you rationalize keeping any woman in any prison?

We have prisons for several reasons. Depriving someone of their liberty works as a punishment for a crime and as a deterrent for others thinking about committing a crime. Prison SHOULD rehabilitate people and perhaps most importantly prison is essential to protect the public.

A lot of women in prison are vulnerable and victims of abuse and prison doesn't help them or society, but there are women who deserve to be deprived of their liberty as a punishment for their crimes. I'd put women involved the Capitol insurrection attack into that category.

[quote] Best thing to do is have a transgender unit in one of the prisons.

R49 I initially started writing this but didn’t want to be accused of being anti-trans, which I am not, but I agree.

Trans only = anti-trans?

R53 Honey, it gets that insanely minute.

R48 I think you just blue yourself.

[quote] Then every single man in male prisons is going to claim he's a woman

You’re doing that thing again where you blame trans people for the lies of straight men. Focus your anger to the correct group pls.

[quote]You’re doing that thing again where you blame trans people for the lies of straight men. Focus your anger to the correct group pls.

What criteria would you use to differentiate between authentic trans women and manipulative men who are pretending to be trans to get access to women?

Is there an opening for a Prison Warden?

This will end in tears (as will this thread)....

Biden so royally fucked up with this. He really acted like an asshole and Dems needed to call him on it.

Clitoral Violence!

This is why Catlyn should be governor. She'd speed up the approval of these requests and get rid of the backlog.

[quote]Clitoral Violence!

WERK!

[quote]You should only be allowed to transfer once you’ve completely transitioned, i.e., have had sex reassignment surgery.

Imagine none of the 261 inmates who requested transfer have had SRS, or imagine just half haven’t transitioned yet, who do you think is going to pay for it?

[quote]costs between $15,000 and $25,000

R64 it costs $81,000 to keep a prisoner in prison for a year, let’s say they’re in for five years then the $20,000 on top of that only comes out at an extra 5% total cost. You know, maybe if the prison population was lower then the cost would be lower, since you’re so concerned about costs you must be concerned about the overpopulation of the prison system in the US no?

Yes, I am, R65, but overpopulation not the topic of this thread.

The inmate mentioned in the article at R64 is serving a life sentence.

No more gender. All inmates together regardless of their gender or lack there of!

This is Caitly Jenner's base.

R66 so what’s $15k compared to the $2m it will take to keep this person in prison for the rest of their lives? What a misuse of funds wow.

This should be the takeaway from these threads - the over-incarceration of people in this country purely for money making prison contract purposes. And they have you distracted arguing over the couple of hundred trans inmates wanting to be housed properly.

Thanks R63!

[quote] I agree with [R6] - it should be something like only fully transitioned people i.e. no longer have their dick.

These people are still male. Just because they got cosmetic surgery doesn’t change that.

There was a case of a transwoman inmate who had got SRS (after a botched castration), was transferred to a women’s prison, and still sexually and physically assaulted the women inmates, just with his hands and objects.

Men do not belong in female prisons.

R56

We are. Trans demanded this; they're getting it. They are responsible.

Also, "real" trans are as violent as other men. So, straight men "faking" is irrelevant. Trans women are men.

[quote] You’re doing that thing again where you blame trans people for the lies of straight men.

Oh fuck off with the logical fallacies.

Wouldn't they get more dick in the men's prison? I mean, duh.

Hundreds is enough to put them in their own wing of some centralized prison in California.

They can form their own sports leagues too.

This seems to only go in one direction. I wonder why.

[quote] This seems to only go in one direction. I wonder why.

On balance, men commit crimes at a much higher rate than women do. Therefore, you would expect the number of trans "men" currently in women's prisons to be much higher than the number of trans "women" in men's prisons. Yet, strangely, it seems to be the other way round - it's almost exclusively trans "women" who are requesting transfers. How very, very mysterious...

give trannies their own prisons

Nikki Wade wouldn’t stand for this. No woman should.

That's by far the most sensible option, R78 (although I suspect requests for transfers would dwindle significantly if they realised they were only going to be imprisoned with one another, not with actual women)

Trans Prisons.

Trans Restrooms.

Are we really too poor a country to give everyone a private bathroom to go to? Doesn't have to be large. Convert the big ones to singles with locks on doors - add more if needed. At least, wherever possible.

It's really rather disgusting to have to do your business communally.

So they hired a man pretending to be a woman to weed out men pretending to be women?

Truthfully R81, I don’t think that’s smart. Because the reality is there are 10 trans people that exist in this entire world. Not thousands and thousands you read about. These people aren’t trans. These people are attention seeking, gay but don’t want to be, mentally ill, etc. Trans only places is not a good use of money. By 2030, all these “trans” and “queers” will have dwindled dramatically.