Eldergays (and younger gays who like vintage stuff) - Which Vintage Playgirl Models Were Your Favorites?

I used to house sit for the family next door when I was a young pup. The mom and dad of the family were a very "70s" couple - into hot tubs, fondue, and probably swinger parties. The wife had stacks of Playgirls in the basement, and I would spend hours combing through them when I would housesit for them (my mom always wondered why it was taking me so long to bring in their mail and water their plants).

Anyway, this guy in particular gave me instant wood. I loved his beefy body and his thick, long cock.

Brian Buzzini

Brian Bianchini - can't find the penis pics. Suicide - gay.

Something about this 70s stud with the tight body and long dick:

Didn't like all the pubes. Like it in the 2000s when the pubes went away.

Here you go ....... R3

Lou.

These guys have the roid queens beat.

Yes. Muscular from working out, no chemical help.

Steve!

Steve is very hot.

Did he ever do porn?

I don’t think so R11

R4, would there be a name to that magnificent spicyman specimen?

R13, I believe he's somewhere here, among the 1970s guys.

Jim Waldrop, aka J.W. King, in porn.

R13 Greg Andersen is his name.

After Brian Buzzini and some guy named Jim, who was painting a room, my favorite was Howie Gordon.

R17 AKA porn star Richard Pacheco, who is actually a very funny and talented writer. He has a great autobiography out called "Hindsight," and he talks about his time as a Playgirl centerfold.

I remember this hottie from the 1980 "College Men" issue:

I loved Bill McAnally's hairy chest and beautiful eyes. His penis was quite nice, too.

oh, boy do I recall jacking off to him big time

R17 Howie Gordon looks like Glenn Frey.

Vanna White's now deceased fiancée John Gibson was hot.

Which "him," R21?

I wonder if r19 lived in Seattle then. I had what we now call a FWB named Jim who looked just like him.

Daniel Egger was pretty much exactly my type. More cute than handsome, really.

R25 Dayum! Lucky you!

The dick, too, r27.

Antonio Contrelle: Playgirl centerfold July 1981; Playgirl Man of the Year 1982. Always my favorite, so handsome and sexy.

Not bad!

So natural looking. Great thread.

Sam Jones and his meaty cock. Yummy yum yum.

I like the more natural non steroid musculature and the full untrimmed bush. I would love to get lost in those big bushes.

R13, there was a Playgirl thread a while back and someone posted that he found out his dad posed for Playgirl. It turned out to be Greg Anderson.

Joe Davis did gay porn under a different name. He was in one of Jeff Stryker’s films.

Okay, Joe Davis went by the name Doug Cory.

R34 I'd love to find that. And I'd love to see what Mr. Andersen looks like today.

Thanks for ID, R16!

R36 And here's Joe Davis, aka Doug Cory today:

Jim Davis was the centerfold of the first Playgirl magazine I stole at 13 years-old. So he was my first PG fantasy/jo crush.

Frank Savino was another favorite.

I'll always have a thing for muscle stud Peter Lupus and his nice-sized dick.

This hairy stud with the looks of a matinee idol:

These hot brothers got me waaaaay horny as a young gayling.

Brandon Court from 1983

many nice memories of all of these gents

I 'loved playgirl

Lion-like ginger stud Bill Douglas!

Carlos Soares had the first uncut pinga I ever saw. I was mesmerized.

This thick, cut cock was bate fuel for a couple years after 1977. Tom Gagen.

I went to college with these two and had a few classes with one of them. Surprisingly, a tad asexual in person.

This guy always did it for me.

R52, years ago someone posted about an encounter with him.

R52 yes, I spilled plenty of seed over him too. I believe his name is Jeremy Alves

I'm a butt man, and Geoffrey Kane had one of the most beautiful asses I've ever seen. I read that he was a bartender at Studio 54. Sadly, he was another victim of ARC.

I remember him, r55. Well, not him, his Playboy spread.

If you are "another victim of ARC," doesn't that mean it turned into full-blown AIDS?

All of my faves

Geoffrey Kane en frontal. Not just his ass.

Former United States Senator and presently U.S. Ambassador to New Zealand.

More Steve Rally! He’s the first photo.

Does he have a name, r59? And does his dong make a public appearance anywhere?

R59 Fuck her. Plus, she was in Cosmo, not Playgirl.

Oh yeah r58, I remember him too. Had that issue and wanked to it all the time.

Did Playgirl have a policy of only showing soft dicks?

R64 When the magazine first debuted, it did. But over the years, they loosened their standards a bit and they started showing lots of hard cocks.

This bearded dude with the long dick was mighty fine.

R51, cool to know. if you meet them again, tell them I had a TON of incest fantasies about them back in the day

Horst Wagenbauer and is monster uncut dick.

Carlos Soares / February 1976

Woody Parker.

Pete Meluso

Antonio Contrelle (Playgirl - July 1981 and Man of the Year 1982)

Ah, Playgirl. When I was on my own, at last, 1974 or so, it was such a jolt of pleasure to see that sealed envelope in my mailbox. There was always at least one model, each month, who would get me off. A monthly Jerk Off catalogue. One of life's little joys. xx

SO many memories....these gorgeous men who were hot, not perfect.

The thing about Playgirl was that it was a natural progression to Colt. Masculine men, almost unobtainable, and it drove so many people wild. What is Colt now? Just a bunch of familiar pron stars we’ve seen almost daily. There is nothing spontaneous or natural about the male physique nowadays. It s all processed..

Benny Graham from July 1989.

76 hits and nobody mentions Jim Brown, the number one footballer and the biggest stud in history. It tears me to pieces. Playgirl imploded after Mr. Brown; nothing ever came close.

My favorite topic on DL is the demise of Playgirl. The only other publication to come close was the Brazilian G, which has also regrettably bitten the dust. Why did Playgirl go from Jim Brown to the back alleys of Prague?

Thanks, you guys. Brought back many happy memories. But I have to confess that looking at these hung guys when I was a gayling made me feel kinda, ya know, inadequate "down there."

some of the vintage playgirl guys had boners

Ryan Wirth, 1999. Had a crush on him for 20 years.

I suspect he plays for our team, so if you're lurking Ryan, thank you for all the jack-off material.

I've cyber-stalked him, and he still looks cute now in his mid-40s. Looks like he may have a boyfriend/husband too. Darn.

Not really vintage (1998?), but my Playgirl favorite, Kevin Larson.

Kevin Larson, hard

R56, Yes, I get the feeling that some people thing ARC is less painful to read than AIDS.

~R55

I used to start at the Pat Larkin centerfold, and not even use it as JO material: I just wanted to admire his perfection. Lovely cock.

Dirk Shafer- 1992 Model, Playgirl's Man of the Year, and mockumentary star in Man of the Year movie release, which I saw in the theaters two or three times.

Reminded me of my boyfriend, and sadly like Dirk, both passed in their early 50's. Dirk did a reshoot in the early 00's that I missed at the bookseller but have seen a few shots from online.

Paul Barresi, almost cartoonishly macho and so sexually threatening. There just was nothing cute, collegiate, or Californian about him.

It was a few years ago, but I saw a recent photo of classic centerfold David White, and damn, he still looked good! The pornstache was gone, and his hair was now silver, but still incredibly handsome.

Rock Pamplin

He went from Playgirl to Colt, a variation on r78's theme.

Has an interesting history too.

I believe there are much more recent nudes of him floating around, looking great as an older gent.

Max Werner, 1984.

Rob Sawyer was a beautiful brunette, who did gay porn as 'Tom Farrell'. He was killed after he was struck by a car while standing at the side of a road to pee. His Rhode Island accent was a huge turn-on for a Midwesterner like me.

r68 Hence the expression "Hung like a Horst."

Rock Pamplin turned me gay.

(Seriously, dad caught me jacking off to his pics).

Joe Pallister, in the early 90s was another I just remembered. I had a roommate at the time who kind of looked like him, so...fuel for the fire.

Levi Johnston.

He didn’t even show his fucking cock.

R61: His name is Scott Brown and my bad, that indeed was Cosmo.

No dong shots that I know of, but he's such an asshole that if he had a 12" dick, all he could do with it would be to fuck himself.

Sadly, he still has his looks but as a person he is a serious embarrassment.

Jean Michele Villette

R94, Lucky you! I mainly knew Joe Pallister from his appearances in soft-core movies on late-night TV (Cinemax, I imagine).

But Joe Pallister has also done the legitimate theatre!

Villette is way too steroidal looking.

Did any women read this magazine? And did they know most of the guys they were looking at were gay?

My favorite pic of Jean Michel Villette

Jerry Pedersoli and Peter Speach

Another set of votes for Daniel Egger and Rock Pamplin

Rob Monroe... my first ever Playgirl centerfold (I shop-lifted a Playgirl magazine at the age of 16 on my birthday while my parents left me alone in the bookstore to go buy me my birthday gift).

Rob Monroe naked

And the actual centerfold that I jacked off to for YEARS...

R107 - I remember that issue as well and always wondered how they got his dick to hang that way. Come to think of it, I still do . . .

R104, OMG, I remember Peter Speach. He was one hot, hairy hunk of man. I stole my auntie's Playgirl because of him.

Peter again.

Steve (or was it Stephen) D'Auria

Stephen Taylor

Ben Gallagher had a Sam Elliott sexiness.

Michael was the first Playgirl model I ever saw. WOW!

SAM JONES and WOODY PARKER

So many wonderful memories

These guys were real babes. Thanks, OP and all!

R98 and R103: My first model! 18th birthday, went down to B. Dalton and bought a Playgirl. And they didn't card me! I could have bought one before. Anyway, Jean Michelle was the first and I remember that ballot picture exactly. Such an awesome memory, thanks!

R113, your link is a 403 FORBIDDEN link. Can you try posting a link that actually works?

But thank God for blackdogue. I wouldn't have Jim Brown without it.

I didn't want to continue to populate a thread on 1978 with Playdongs from the 1980s, so I thought I'd bring Brandon Court here to present pole.

Brandon Court is from March, 1983. Someone in the 1978 thread posited that 1978 was the last year Playgirl was worth looking at.

I think not.

r118, does this work?

It WORKS

And it was so frustrating when they wouldn't spread their legs....

r121, I did. And I stick by it.

R125. That's okay, baby. Chacun, and so forth.

Happy vintage Friday

Sounds like many of us stole our first Playgirls, lol. Frank Scolari. Wowsa.

I like the bush!

When I was a freshman in college, my next-door neighbor filled out a subscription form for Playgirl for me as a way to tease me. I got it for about 8 months without having to pay for it. Years later, I would shoplift them from the local bookstore, like so many other guys have done. I wonder what percent of people actually bought them versus stole them?

those blackdogue links don't seem to work for me? Whats happening? Pilot error?

I can only access them on my tablet

playgirl bump

The men who are not cut/mutilated.

the men who show us everything

Rhett Routley did gay porn as 'Jeff Quinn' (and boy, was he good at it.

Very eighties

OMG. Socks and sandals.

R136, RR should have been the porn name.

forbidden

Porn, porn, porn. Playgirl's efforts equal Hillary Clinton's.

R134, get help, you fucking loser. EVERY post. EVERY thread, for so long. You are far more "mutilated" than any cut guy.

R142, is it really always the same person? Sad.

John Gibson was Vanna White's fiance, but he lost his life in an airplane crash.

I know that the Blackdogue site is old, and it's not always that easy to navigate from individual links, so I'll just include the main site, which has a whole listing of models you can look at.

As far as the conversation about circumcision goes, the advice that was given when I was growing up was that boys should 'match' their fathers, so they wouldn't feel different. So I'm circumcised, as was my Dad. I don't know what it would be like if I weren't, and I certainly wouldn't blame my parents for what was standard here in the US when I was born. The whole conversation seems rather childish. My ex-partner chose to become circumcised as an adult: it was his decision, not mine, and I never questioned his reasoning. Demeaning those of us who have been circumcised is rather cruel, when most of us who have been didn't have a say in the matter.

Thanks, R145. If I may, did your partner say,whether there was much difference in sensation, between the two states?

This guy, who vaguely looks like Zac Efron, was one of my very first jackoff fantasies.

I've always wondered what happened to him. He must be around 50 by now.

Joey Newton (May 1994) drove me crazy.

When did Playgirl start showing models with hardons?

Newton became a pastor.

Hot daddy, I’d get on my knees with him

LOL, nice try R150

The Joe Newton in R148's post has brown eyes and your guy's eyes are blue.

Details.

I remember when Sam Jones and his pedulous dong.

R150 Definitely not the same Joey Newton. The front of the pastor's nose is bulbous. The Playgirl Joey Newton's isn't.

R146, My ex had his circumcision in his early 20s. He had phimosis (foreskin wouldn't retract). He was the first uncut guy I ever experienced (and I think, still the only one). He was very shy about sex, and I think he was ashamed to be uncircumcised, since he was born to poor black sharecroppers in Florida, with his mother only being 14 at the time. He never discussed the circumcision, other than to say it was something he had always wanted. And he never talked about it afterwards. It didn't make a difference to me: I loved every single inch of him, and would have regardless (well, if I'm in love, that's the way it works for me). I still love him, very much. I do think being circumcised allowed him to become more confident in his sex life. After we separated, he didn't have any trouble moving on to other partners, although he was very hesitant when we first started seeing each other. There was no reason: he's gorgeous, with a great body, but I fell in love with him because he makes me laugh. I don't know how other people keep from falling in love with him (I suspect they do).

R145

R149, That's been the subject of debate. It's not always clear what constitutes an erection The earliest one that I believe qualifies is Howie Gordon (straight porn star Richard Pacheco) back in 1978 (not a big one, though).

Why are some links forbidden?

Jeremy Johnson

when sam jones and his pendulous dong what, r153?

Sam Jones

they were hotter back in the day

R102: Yes and Yes!

Daddy Christopher George. Wanked myself raw over him.

he needs to shoot it

Yippee

r161 just made the understatement of the century.

sexy men

Not vintage.. but this dude.

george maharis

The only Playgirl i had laid my eyes on as a kid was the issue with Lou Zivkovich, I got it for a quarter at a yard sale, rode my bike home and Lou became my boyfriend for the next few wanktastic years. He had to stay under the bed though.

I still think about that stud, thanks for posting [R7} you blew my mind today!