St. Elmo's Fire is referenced all the time, and is considered to be in the same league as John Hughes comedies. But it really is a shitty movie.
If it weren't for the title song and the very good musical score, there are not many redeeming qualities about it.
Demi Moore gives the most realistic performance. Ally Sheedy is high-school play level bad in every scene, and seems coked up with her nervous delivery.
Rob Lowe jumping onto stage yelling, "Let's rock!" is cringeworthy. Judd Nelson has none of his appeal from "The Breakfast Club." Demi Moore's gay friend is a stereotypical, flouncing flamer, and she refers to Kevin being gay as a problem. Mare Winningham is the most bizarre casting, and doesn't fit with any of them.
Robert Downey Jr. was originally considered for Rob Lowe's role. Other actors considered or turned down roles: Brooke Shields, Tatum O'Neal, Jodie Foster, Joan Cusack, C. Thomas Howell, Jamie lee Curtis, Melanie Griffith, Sarah Jessica Parker, Jennifer Jason Leigh, Elisabeth Shue, Bridget Fonda, Anthony Edwards, Lea Thompson
Did you see this movie when it came out and what do you think of it now?