I just watched Autumn Sonata for the first time. She was great...I don't get how Ingrid got all the awards.
Shouldn't Liv Ullman have won an Oscar?
|by Anonymous||reply 23||04/10/2013|
She is not American.
|by Anonymous||reply 1||04/08/2013|
She should have won an Oscar for Face to Face.
|by Anonymous||reply 2||04/08/2013|
[all posts by ham-fisted troll a removed.]
|by Anonymous||reply 3||04/08/2013|
Yes, only Americans win Oscars.
|by Anonymous||reply 4||04/08/2013|
Ingrid Bergman was born in Cedar Rapids, I-O-W-A, U-S-A! This whole "Swedish" thing was FAKE, FAKE, FAKE. She was as Swedish as my aunt Tina.
|by Anonymous||reply 5||04/08/2013|
r4, those wins are only in the last 10 years where the film industry has become more internationalized. How many foreign actors/actress won in the 60s/70s compared to now?
|by Anonymous||reply 6||04/08/2013|
I have a feeling she doesn't give a shit.
|by Anonymous||reply 7||04/08/2013|
r6 I think lots of Brits won in the 60's/70's...."they give Glenda Jackson a bloody Oscar every year and she never shows up!"
|by Anonymous||reply 8||04/08/2013|
Her only American tribute was when Bebe Buell named her spawn by Steven Tyler after her.
|by Anonymous||reply 9||04/08/2013|
As for the Oscar, Liv and Let Liv.
|by Anonymous||reply 10||04/08/2013|
You lot must be too young to remember Simone Signoret and Sophia Loren won the best actress Oscars back in 1959 and 1961.
Liv certainly wouldnt win for any of her American movies ..... but yes she and Ingrid should have tied for Autumn Sonata in 1978.
|by Anonymous||reply 11||04/08/2013|
Jane Fonda won in 1978...I never get that one. I guess it was connected to her Vietnam activism but Coming Home is a boring performance. I was shocked to read Jill Clayburgh lost that year too. I always thought she won.
|by Anonymous||reply 12||04/08/2013|
r5, IB was born in Stockholm.
As for 'Autumn Sonata': Ullmann is great, as usual, but her performance isn't wildly different from 'Face to Face' or 'Scenes from a Marriage', for which she should have won. (Yes, I realize the latter is a tv mini-series which was cut to a theatrical release in the US).
Ingrid Bergman has arguably the more challenging part in 'Autumn Sonata'; she has to convey maternal love, indifference, derision, regret, embarrassment... sometimes all in one take. And she pulls it off.
It's a more quiet yet nuanced performance than Ullmann's, and therefore Bergman deserved her nomination.
|by Anonymous||reply 13||04/10/2013|
Wow, r13, that r5 post just flew right over your little head, didn't it?
I never miss a Liv Ullmann musical.
|by Anonymous||reply 14||04/10/2013|
She's also a terrific director as anyone who saw the production of STREETCAR with Cate Blanchett will attest.
And before anyone gets too rhapsodic about Blanchett, I think Ullman deserves credit for guiding Blanchett's superb performance as the latter's previous NYC stage appearance in NYC in HEDDA GABLER was underwhelming, to put it nicely. But that whole production was horrid.
|by Anonymous||reply 15||04/10/2013|
"Autmn Sonata" is one of Bergman's greatest performances. Liv is fine but Ingrid is incredible.
|by Anonymous||reply 16||04/10/2013|
What about a Tony- or not?!
|by Anonymous||reply 17||04/10/2013|
I agree, R15. I credit Liv Ullman with getting out of Blanchett a performance that was more from the gut than anything Blanchett had done before.
I saw Blanchett in UNCLE VANYA last year and I didn't understand the hype about her performance. She was not nearly as luminous and captivating as she was in STREETCAR.
|by Anonymous||reply 18||04/10/2013|
I eat shit.
|by Anonymous||reply 19||04/10/2013|
Yes OP. At the very least she should have more nominations. OK so Scenes from a Marriage was hampered by the TV rule, but she was drop dead amazing in Sonata, every bit the equal of Ingrid, really better.
Speaking of Ingrid I need to get that TV movie she did where she played the Israeli prime minister. That along with Sonata, her final performances, have been said to be the best.
|by Anonymous||reply 20||04/10/2013|
The role of Mama in I Remember Mama seems tailor made for her.
Yet she flopped on Broadway.
What went wrong?
|by Anonymous||reply 21||04/10/2013|
If you heard her sing, R21, you'd know why it flopped (she was thankfully dubbed in LOST HORIZON). Plus Richard Rogers was way, way past his prime at that point. The show itself was terrible.
|by Anonymous||reply 22||04/10/2013|
There are worst singers that have appeared on Broadway.
|by Anonymous||reply 23||04/10/2013|