I have known two people who teach at such schools with no credentials whatsoever(one barely graduated high school). I have heard they're about encouraging kids to learn at their own pace and bringing the real world into lessons. Are these valid places of learning or kind of home school-y?
Please explain "Montessori" schools to me.
|by Anonymous||reply 42||12/30/2012|
Are they institutions of learning, or teenage brothels?
|by Anonymous||reply 1||12/27/2012|
They used to pick out the brighter students, but these days, they are more a fashion statements for rich people with kids.
|by Anonymous||reply 2||12/27/2012|
We're not going to explain them to you. We're going to teach you to find out about them yourself.
|by Anonymous||reply 3||12/27/2012|
Montesorri was Thomas Jefferson's home. He used to teach his slave children there. The school developed from that.
It teaches kids to think for themselves rather than be regimented to societal norms.
|by Anonymous||reply 4||12/27/2012|
r4 not Montesorri. It was Monticello.
|by Anonymous||reply 5||12/27/2012|
No, Monticello was the last name of Larry on Leave it To Beaver.
|by Anonymous||reply 6||12/27/2012|
|by Anonymous||reply 7||12/27/2012|
I went to a Montessori school for 2nd, 3rd, and 4th grade. Basically, there were flashcards, games, books in the classroom and you play/work with whatever you want. I'd memorize the US capitals, study math in a math book or with flashcards, games etc. We'd have one awful boring science lecture a week from the principal. We had a music class and for a period of each year, we'd have dancing teachers teach us square dancing and even a may pole dance. We also had a French teacher work with us from time to time. I loved it except for the principal who was mean to me. In retrospect, I think he was a drunk.
I turned out pretty well. When I went back to public school for the 5th grade, I was wayyyy ahead of everybody and I ultimately skipped the 7th grade and graduated from high school as Valedictorian.
On a side note, while at Montessori, one of my good friends there Dustin Stills told me his dad was a singer. Stephen Stills. I was like "never heard of him.". Years later, I was like whoa. Dustin was a good artist. He could draw E.T. I was impressed. I wrote a book while I was there and he did the illustrations.
|by Anonymous||reply 8||12/28/2012|
What a liar. You probably skipped to 7th grade from the 11th grade.
A teacher from Park Forest was put on suspension when he was investigated for improper relationships with the student. This is the second student at Rich East High School that has been investigated for improper conduct, in the last two months.
|by Anonymous||reply 9||12/28/2012|
Montessori techniques were originally developed to be used with special needs students. Basically it's like enrolling your kid in special ed.
|by Anonymous||reply 10||12/28/2012|
oh please. you are 8. learn the shit or shut up. if you dont finish school welcome to a life of poverty.
Can parents take any responsibility about their kids education?
|by Anonymous||reply 11||12/28/2012|
The kids I have known in Montessori schools have all been, well shall we be charitable and say, Michael Phelps clones. Not swimming wise but mentally.
|by Anonymous||reply 12||12/28/2012|
My law partner's two kids went to Montesorri til they started a public high school. Both graduated valedictorian, one attends UVa and the other graduated last year from UVa and works at a liberal think tank/foundation in DC and has been accepted to Georgetown, UVa, Duke, and a few other law schools.
I fully expect one or both to be White House Chief of Staff at some point in the future. Each wants the job, not glory.
So we made fun of the daily moring ritual of walking the birthday child "around the sun", but yeah, it worked for them.
|by Anonymous||reply 13||12/28/2012|
[quote]I fully expect one or both to be White House Chief of Staff at some point in the future. Each wants the job, not glory.
Riiiight. They learn that bullshit sells at Montesorri, I guess.
I want the job not the glory.
There are plenty of jobs with no glory like giving free legal advice to the poor but they don't seem too interested in that, do they?
|by Anonymous||reply 14||12/28/2012|
Right on, R14!
|by Anonymous||reply 15||12/28/2012|
My three cousins attended montessori in the 80's and while they're all successful in the IT field now that they are in their 30s, they all started but didn't finish college even though their parents both have advanced degrees. The mom's theory was that montessori left them too independent to buckle down and get through the 4 years of university when they were younger.
|by Anonymous||reply 16||12/28/2012|
Montessori focuses on individual training rather than teaching to a class all at once. The teacher and assistants move around the classroom spending time with each student. There is no homework. By 1st grade they are learning multiplication, by 2nd algebra. Montessori students always test at several grade levels above their public school peers. They are taught to think outside the box. They promote diversity. There is no homework. There are no desks, they either sit at tables or on the floor.
Having a child go from a Montessori school to a public school is always a shock to their system. They aren't used to large class sizes, group learning/group think, homework and conformity.
I'd love for our child to continue in the system but each year costs about 10k. We had our child in the system for preschool and 1st grade and due to the approach to critical thinking achieved then, our child is now the smartest kid in the public elementary school (5th grade testing at 8th grade level) and often gets teased for it.
|by Anonymous||reply 17||12/28/2012|
R16, if they are successful, it sounds like a degree wouldn't have given them anything but a ton of debt.
Perhaps they are smarter than their parents.
|by Anonymous||reply 18||12/28/2012|
It is for dyslexic Asians looking for Monstacock.
|by Anonymous||reply 19||12/28/2012|
[quote]Montesorri was Thomas Jefferson's home. He used to teach his slave children there. The school developed from that.
Where the fuck did you learn that?
|by Anonymous||reply 20||12/28/2012|
My public school did some experimenting with the self-directed learning in the 70s. I was in several classes like that and left to my own devices I'd rather not work, so I didn't. I needed direction.
|by Anonymous||reply 21||12/28/2012|
You have any idea how much White House staff make? It's effectively pro bono, believe me.
|by Anonymous||reply 22||12/28/2012|
My nephew went for about 2 years early on. He is also near the top of his class now in 8th grade.
|by Anonymous||reply 23||12/28/2012|
It's certainly better than the Prussian system that our public schools use.
|by Anonymous||reply 24||12/28/2012|
My nephew goes to one in NYC. My brother said it's almost weird when you go into the classroom because it's so quiet: everyone is doing projects and doing "work." They are taught to put their projects away, responsibility, etc. I do have to say that my nephew seems to understand "process" - how to get something done. When he was three, he wanted us to write to a book together. And even though the story was about a monster, Charlie Brown and jail, I was impressed he could even figure out that you can make a book.
|by Anonymous||reply 25||12/28/2012|
Um, r4 was making a joke, people.
|by Anonymous||reply 26||12/28/2012|
I went to one as a kid was great- I was reading at the HS level in the 3rd grade. Was a shock when we moved. I was way ahead of the other kids in my "assigned" grade. Was a miserable few months until I was finally moved up a few grades. Was a very traditional school. The books for reading were dumbed down 3rd grade book. I started goig back in with the 5th graders after recess, brought my own reading books to school-basically the teacher finally gave in.
|by Anonymous||reply 27||12/28/2012|
Correlation doesn't necessarily mean causation. Parents who can afford $10k/yr for Montessori school can likely provide their kids with many more opportunities for mental enrichment and exploration than the working stiffs sending their kids to public schools.
|by Anonymous||reply 28||12/28/2012|
[quote]They promote diversity.
Reason enough to avoid it.
|by Anonymous||reply 29||12/28/2012|
Some states offer public ones.
|by Anonymous||reply 30||12/28/2012|
I went from about age 3 to age 8, and I think I got a good foundation for the rest of my education, which was more traditional in Catholic and public schools. I was mostly bored in traditional classrooms, and ended up skipping two grades, graduating at 15, and finishing college at 19, which I don't actually recommend.
That said, the self-starter, work-at-your-own-pace way of completing tasks and solving problems has always worked well for me. I've worked for non-profits where you have to be a multi-tasker, and in the theater, where it's also good to be a generalist when you're producing a show.
I read "In the Plex," which is the story of Google and one of the main observations is that if you want to understand the company, you need to know that both Larry Page and Sergey Brin were Montessori kids. I recently got a job at Google, and when I walked in, I immediately "got" it.
So I guess the Montessori education is still useful after all these years.
|by Anonymous||reply 31||12/28/2012|
[quote]Correlation doesn't necessarily mean causation. Parents who can afford $10k/yr for Montessori school can likely provide their kids with many more opportunities for mental enrichment and exploration than the working stiffs sending their kids to public schools.
This is true, however it doesn't mean the system is a scam and it's only the other opportunities that enrich these kids lives. There is clearly something beneficial to the Montessori technique.
|by Anonymous||reply 32||12/28/2012|
My sister is a teacher and says most kids who come out of Montessori schools and into public school are often behind. She's taught 8yr olds who can barely spell and has had to use the reading program of 5 year olds to help them catch up. To be fair though she doesn't live in the USA and her experience may be very different from the US one.
|by Anonymous||reply 33||12/28/2012|
Ima no have no slaves, no way, capisci?
|by Anonymous||reply 34||12/28/2012|
Montessori was always for "troubled" children, who can't cope with everyday life.
And if a child can't cope with everyday life at age five, you know he's gonna turn out to be some kind of a retarded sociopath as an adult.
|by Anonymous||reply 35||12/28/2012|
Growing up in NYC, it was where all the rich arty hippies sent their kids. And the kids I knew there wound up going to Brown, Bennington, or art school.
|by Anonymous||reply 36||12/28/2012|
Thank you, R36, from the rest of the nation because we know what you are talking about.
We are all so NYC focused of course.
|by Anonymous||reply 37||12/28/2012|
[quote]WTF is Brown or Bennington?
Brown is a famous Ivy League University. Bennington is well known too.
|by Anonymous||reply 38||12/30/2012|
R6, Larry was my favorite of the younger boys on "Leave it to Beaver" -- Eddie was my favorite of the older boys, of course.
|by Anonymous||reply 39||12/30/2012|
The end of Jane Eyre turns me into a sobbing mess.
|by Anonymous||reply 40||12/30/2012|
|by Anonymous||reply 41||12/30/2012|
They are acting academies for aspiring exotic thespians, both male and female.
|by Anonymous||reply 42||12/30/2012|