I hate to be a store-bought ice cream snob, but...
Against my better judgment i purchased a lower -priced yet with more in the carton brand.
Ugh, talk about a case of the trots.
Otoh, I never have problems with the expensive premium brands like Starbucks and Ben & Jerry's.
Why is that? What's the difference in production between cheaper brands of store bought ice cream and the expensive ones?
|by Anonymous||reply 125||06/27/2014|
Um... did you read the ingredients?
A good ice cream has four or five ingredients max and you should be able to read all of them.
|by Anonymous||reply 1||09/30/2012|
OP, next time read the package. You purchased Frosty Paws ice cream for dogs.
|by Anonymous||reply 2||09/30/2012|
Some store brands are better than others, but they rarely natch premium quality brands.
|by Anonymous||reply 3||09/30/2012|
I don't know what it is, r1, but I avoid any ice cream below Blue Bell in quality and I never drink fast food milk shakes.
|by Anonymous||reply 4||09/30/2012|
Graeter's. The best.
Kroger just started selling it here.
|by Anonymous||reply 5||09/30/2012|
It's psychosomatic. You need a lobotomy.
|by Anonymous||reply 6||09/30/2012|
I still eat Haagen-Daz.
It's the only brand I can tolerate.
Their cherry with chocolate chunk is amazing-I just had some tonight.
|by Anonymous||reply 7||09/30/2012|
all ice creams make me very gassy
|by Anonymous||reply 8||09/30/2012|
More sugar less milk and cream i imagine. I dont buy anything below blue bell in texas. Its worth a little more.
|by Anonymous||reply 9||09/30/2012|
R1 is correct about a good ice cream only having a few ingredients.
Some cheap ice creams are whipped with so much air to create more product for less money. Edy's is particularly guilty of this.
|by Anonymous||reply 10||09/30/2012|
The best ice cream you will ever find can be had at your state university's dairy bar which is operated by the university's agriculture dept. These institutions stick to the strict tried and true recipes for ice cream, no high fructose corn syrup, no preservatives, no sugar substitutes, no growth hormone fed cows. Of the store bought varieties, Ben & Jerry's remains the gold standard even though they were bought out by Unilever a few years ago. Somehow Ben & Jerry seemed to have maintained the recipes even under new ownership. Always beware of corporate buyouts, because as soon as the big parent company takes over they start altering the recipes to include the garbage because its cheaper and because they have relationships with Monsanto and big agra-businesses that push that crap down our throats.
Brighams ice cream (a New England institution) used to be really good but the company went bankrupt and they were bought out by some venture capital firm which closed all of the Brighams stores in New England and altered the ice cream. It is still available in the stores but it is just not as good any more which is a shame.
|by Anonymous||reply 11||09/30/2012|
Seriously, ice cream snobbery?
|by Anonymous||reply 12||09/30/2012|
R13- I do love Ronnybrook. You can find it at Whole Foods too.
I agree- Buying Ben & Jerry's, which you can find in any bodega for $5, does not qualify you as an ice cream snob.
|by Anonymous||reply 14||09/30/2012|
OP, the bad stuff is basically eating a bucket of antibiotics; your guts are fucked up because you've just stripped them of all their good bacteria. Most US dairy cows are pumped full of antibiotics all day long every day, fed them, washed in them until they die of some antibiotic resistant bacterial disease. Same with poultry.
|by Anonymous||reply 15||09/30/2012|
OP, Are you sensitive to HFCS? Some ice creams (Blue Bunny) contain too many artificial ingredients that may cause stomach distress. Or it could be too cold, so you have to consume less at a time.
|by Anonymous||reply 16||09/30/2012|
It's ridiculous to read of "snobbery" among fools who don't have the sense to simply take a few minutes to make their own ice cream. What is wrong with these sad creatures who jabber about crapping out bad stuff and buying commercial products that are not only overprices but that never capture the taste of what ice cream can be.
The only poster who comes close is the one suggesting people run to their state agriculture schools' dairy bars. But not everyone wants to take a 150 mile drive for a pint, and it's still a poor second to just making your own.
Ben and Jerry. Starbucks.
|by Anonymous||reply 17||09/30/2012|
[quote]Seriously, ice cream snobbery?
It isn't snobbery; it's indigestion. Even something like Borden's will do a number on my gut.
|by Anonymous||reply 19||09/30/2012|
B&J's is filled with guar gum, wheat flour and soybean oil. It is also very, very sweet. Having said that, I love the Karamel Sutra.
|by Anonymous||reply 20||09/30/2012|
Holy shit, this thread has the makings of a DL classic. We're only 20 responses in and we've already got at least four or five different kinds of DL assholes all in one thread.
|by Anonymous||reply 21||10/01/2012|
Was it a sugar-free ice cream, OP? Artificial sweeteners have a laxative effect.
|by Anonymous||reply 23||10/01/2012|
Blue Bell Ice Cream is the secret weapon of Republicans in southern red states. That is how they get the votes.
|by Anonymous||reply 24||10/01/2012|
I buy Blue Bell because it's affordable yet good (tried Blue Bunny and it was crappy). Since, as a broke student, I cant afford the higher brands, is Blue Bell ok? This is a serious question, cause I find that it tastes pretty good but if the others taste better, I guess I can buy a higher quality brand once every two months
|by Anonymous||reply 25||10/01/2012|
Ben & Jerry's cookie dough is my fav, as I eat 2 pints a night
|by Anonymous||reply 26||10/01/2012|
Don't forget the trolls, r21. The HFCS troll seems to be here upthread.
|by Anonymous||reply 27||10/01/2012|
Brighams had the most incredible hot fudge. I've never found anything like it.
|by Anonymous||reply 29||10/01/2012|
Meijer brand Moose Tracks FTW
|by Anonymous||reply 30||10/01/2012|
[quote]The best ice cream you will ever find can be had at your state university's dairy bar which is operated by the university's agriculture dept.
So true. Babcock Hall dairy store at the Univ. of Wisconsin is the bomb.
That said, Straus Family Creamery is really, really good and also organic. It just doesn't come in vats.
|by Anonymous||reply 31||10/01/2012|
Blue-Bell Peach Cobbler ice-cream is food of the gods. Seriously. I think they put crack in it, it's so addictive.
|by Anonymous||reply 32||10/01/2012|
The petty snobbery of Dataloungers is at times insufferable. This thread is a good example.
|by Anonymous||reply 33||10/01/2012|
I advise you all to buy a pint of Graeter's Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip.
|by Anonymous||reply 34||10/01/2012|
Growing up, my state university was Rutgers. I don't think they have an agriculture department, much less a dairy bar.
So I guess Thomas Sweet's in Princeton remains the best bet in Jersey.
|by Anonymous||reply 35||10/01/2012|
It's not the ice cream it's from eating out guy's asses. You got that Matthew Rush illness.
|by Anonymous||reply 36||10/01/2012|
If you have not tried Graeter's, then you're missing out.
They are currently expanding into new markets.
Enter your zip to find out if Graeter's is sold near you.
|by Anonymous||reply 37||10/01/2012|
I'm sure OP used a coupon to buy his store-bought ice cream. I, on the other hand, only make my own ice cream from scratch using nothing but farm fresh ingredients.
|by Anonymous||reply 38||10/01/2012|
OP, you could have had a bout of lactose intolerance. That can cause the symptoms you describe when eating dairy products. It is also possible that the ice cream was prepared badly and you may have had a bout with bactiria like salmonella.
Ny the way, here in Ohio, Pierre's Ice Cream is fantastic.
|by Anonymous||reply 39||10/01/2012|
r38 is illiterate and a megalomaniac.
|by Anonymous||reply 40||10/01/2012|
I don't eat ice cream anymore but if I did it would be B&J. I have converted to FroYo and tthe best I've had is Stonyfield's Organic. Their mint chocolate chip is seriously good.
|by Anonymous||reply 42||10/01/2012|
[quote]I, on the other hand, only make my own ice cream from scratch using nothing but farm fresh ingredients.
Me too -- & I have my own cow!
In fact, for the salted caramel flavor, I make my own salt from my own sea.
|by Anonymous||reply 44||10/01/2012|
I'm a woman -- I milk myself!!!
|by Anonymous||reply 45||10/01/2012|
R45 wins and shuts the thread the down. Way to go babe!
|by Anonymous||reply 47||10/01/2012|
[quote] I advise you all to buy a pint of Graeter's Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip.
I concur. Ralphs (Kroger) in L.A. just started carrying this and it is my new crack.
|by Anonymous||reply 48||10/01/2012|
The store brand ice cream and frozen yogurt at Publix is far superior to Ben & Jerry's and every other national brand.
|by Anonymous||reply 49||10/01/2012|
It's not very fashionable but Breyer's is still a good choice. All natural with only 5 ingredients. They even sell it at Whole Foods.
|by Anonymous||reply 50||10/01/2012|
Blue Bell's entire marketing strategy seems to be, "I know! We'll just add ⅓ MORE sweetener to all our flavors! We'll be the sweetest ice cream in the marketplace!"
|by Anonymous||reply 51||10/01/2012|
Lifeway frozen kefir for me!
|by Anonymous||reply 52||10/01/2012|
LOL I feel bad for anyone who has to shop at a store called Publix. Sounds very tacky.
|by Anonymous||reply 53||10/01/2012|
I miss Publix!
I moved from ATL to another state and there are no Publix Grocery Stores here! : (
EXCELLENT grocery store.
|by Anonymous||reply 54||10/01/2012|
I love having 'the trots', so cleansing and refreshing, it is, it is!
|by Anonymous||reply 55||10/01/2012|
Publix is fine, the name is frightening.
|by Anonymous||reply 56||10/01/2012|
Publix is just a plain, run-of-the-mill grocery store. It's not Whole Foods or Balducci's.
|by Anonymous||reply 57||10/01/2012|
Thanks, R48 -- but you may mean R46, who certainly deserves it.
|by Anonymous||reply 59||10/01/2012|
How sad for you dirty poorsies who have to go to grocery stores and touch things.
|by Anonymous||reply 60||10/01/2012|
Never buy store ice cream. You learned the hard way OP. In fact nobody needs to eat ice cream anyway. It's not good for you. Leave it.
|by Anonymous||reply 62||10/01/2012|
Well Scotch and cigars aren't good for you either. Not giving them up along with ice cream.
As Dana/George said, "Na. Ga. Da!"
I wonder if they make Scotch flavor sorbet?
|by Anonymous||reply 63||10/01/2012|
You can start here, R64, & tinker with the "recipe" to suit your taste.
|by Anonymous||reply 64||10/06/2012|
Someone I know, who does not have particularly good taste in certain things, mentioned repeatedly that Breyers was his favorite ice cream. I scoffed because the one time I'd had it, it'd been disgusting (I also believe the fewer ingredients, the better).
I agreed to humor him, and found it even more unappetizing than when I had first tried it. And the texture wasn't creamy, but felt like it had been chemically engineered to be creamy (an almost gelatinous feel). I later checked the carton and noticed that it's now called "Bryers Frozen Dairy Dessert". They can't legally call it ice cream, I guess.
Why would a company willingly alter a product to the point that it barely resembles what it's meant to be? And is the average American that hapless and undiscerning to buy enough of this "frozen dairy dessert" to help Breyers remain a successful company?
|by Anonymous||reply 65||10/06/2012|
[quote]That said, Straus Family Creamery is really, really good and also organic. It just doesn't come in vats.
Where can you buy this?
|by Anonymous||reply 66||10/06/2012|
[quote]If you're gonna be a snob, you might as well go all the way and just buy Ronnybrook or Ciao Bella. I buy Ronnybrook exclusively at the Chelsea Market or the Union Square Farmer's Market. But even you people should be able to get Ciao Bella at your local Pic 'n Pay or whatever middling grocery stores you frequent on Main St.
Ciao Bella doesn't sell ice cream, you dumb fuck.
|by Anonymous||reply 67||10/06/2012|
I always like Braum's back when I lived in Dallas.
|by Anonymous||reply 68||10/06/2012|
I never buy anything larger than a pint because it's all shit and filled with air. I don't know why people would buy gallons of ice cream in those giant tubs like Dreyer's or Edi's. They take up so much room in your freezer and they taste so fluffy and horrible.
|by Anonymous||reply 69||10/06/2012|
News flash mabey people don't know it but Chipoltle does have harmones.
|by Anonymous||reply 71||07/07/2013|
Thrifty Ice Cream is still the best store-bought ice cream around, but it's only available in Southern California (and maybe Arizona?) at Rite-Aid drug stores. Rite-Aid bought out Thrifty Drug Stores about 20 years ago but very wisely kept the Thrifty Ice Cream and the name.
It's still better than even the premium (Graeters, Starbucks, Haagen-Daz, etc.) ice creams available on store shelves.
|by Anonymous||reply 72||07/07/2013|
[quote]And is the average American that hapless and undiscerning to buy enough of this "frozen dairy dessert" to help Breyers remain a successful company?
|by Anonymous||reply 73||07/07/2013|
I like friendly's chocoalate almond chip as regular ice cream. My fave right now: haagen daaz gelato sea salt caramel. Ciao Bella Blood orange, Mango, and key lime gelatos are also fab.
|by Anonymous||reply 74||07/07/2013|
Having sugar withdrawal, R71?
R39 is right. There are ice cream makers that are small, fit in the freezer and make it very easy to create the real thing. You'll never taste anything better than fresh peach ice cream.
|by Anonymous||reply 75||07/07/2013|
Probably milk?cream? but you know what's weird, OP, I would normally agree with you 100%, but I have 2 or 3 times recently had excellent ice cream that was from a big tub bough at a Sam's Club! so go, figure...
|by Anonymous||reply 77||07/07/2013|
My friend had a late-term miscarriage, but still ended up with the boobies and lactation. She used one of those breast pumps and made a batch of strawberry ice cream. It *tasted* of miscarriage.
|by Anonymous||reply 78||07/07/2013|
r78, If you'er trying to say cheaper brands use milk and pricier brands use cream you're wrong. If it's made from milk it's called ice milk.
Apparently, "frozen dessert" is made from something called "butter-sugar" plus chemicals.
|by Anonymous||reply 79||07/07/2013|
My current favorite: Talenti caramel cookie crunch gelato
|by Anonymous||reply 80||07/07/2013|
Graeter's is being carried by Fairway, although not on a regular basis. But it's amazing.
|by Anonymous||reply 81||07/07/2013|
I liked John Weir better before this last one.
|by Anonymous||reply 84||07/07/2013|
R67, (I know you're probably not going to see this) I've linked to their website where you can enter your zipcode and see if it's carried in your area. In L.A. they carry it at Whole Foods, Gelson's, and at some Sprouts locations, for the larger market chains.
|by Anonymous||reply 86||07/07/2013|
The best ice cream is homemade. It's easy.
|by Anonymous||reply 87||07/07/2013|
But your a store-bought ice cream troll!
Who cares what you like!
You just want to show off what "expensive" tastes you have. Maybe your body is just like a "temple" as described by Jennifer Aniston.
|by Anonymous||reply 88||07/07/2013|
Check the container. In some states the Plant number where it was made is listed. Then see if a brand you like makes ice cream for the cheaper brand.
|by Anonymous||reply 89||07/07/2013|
I can find "No Sugar Added," but not sugar-free. Who makes it?
|by Anonymous||reply 90||07/07/2013|
Ben and Jerry are phonies. Claimed they'd never make a certain percentage in salary higher than their employees, then sold to Pillsbury for multi-millions.
|by Anonymous||reply 91||07/14/2013|
Most ice cream is so grossly sweet it is inedible to me. I cannot tolerate any Ben and Jerry's.
|by Anonymous||reply 92||07/14/2013|
Most premium ice cream uses more fat for a dense texture -
Best in the world is Jenni's
|by Anonymous||reply 93||07/14/2013|
You probably won't find sugar free, R90, because milk contains it's own sugar (lactose). I guess they could make ice cream from lactose-free milk but I can't imagine what that would be like.
|by Anonymous||reply 94||07/14/2013|
"Roasted" fucking strawberries. Goddamn!
What insane Yankee fuckery is this?!
They warm the strawberries in an industrial heating chamber to cause the juice to exude and soften the flesh. That's it.
"Roasted" -- puh-lease, Louise!
Some idiotic copywriter went over the top and the Jenis fools let him or her.
I would by the product just for this reason.
|by Anonymous||reply 95||07/14/2013|
I quit eating Blue Bell because it's now made with HFCS instead of sugar and it's close to where I grew up so I wanted to help the economy. Oh well.
OP, are you sure you aren't developing lactose intolerance? It hit me in my mid forties. I love dairy products but cannot eat too much of it especially a glass of milk. Talk about diarrhea and excessive cramping. I can't still eat cheese thank god.
|by Anonymous||reply 96||07/14/2013|
Instead, R93, Jeni -- one "n" -- uses cornstarch. Talk about disgusting.
|by Anonymous||reply 97||07/14/2013|
No they use tapioca starch.
Bananas & Honey Ice Cream Ingredients: Snowville Creamery Milk, Snowville Creamery Cream, Cane Sugar, Bananas, Honey, Tapioca Starch. Contains: Milk. **Gluten Free**
Roasted Strawberry Buttermilk Ice Cream Ingredients: Snowville Creamery Milk, Snowville Cream, Sugar, Strawberries, Tapioca Syrup, Dried Buttermilk Powder (Sweet Cream Buttermilk Solids), Tapioca Starch, Citric Acid
only one I can find uses corn starch -
|by Anonymous||reply 98||07/14/2013|
Miss R83 - pay $18 and start threads for that shit, instead of bombing other threads.
AIN'T NOBODY GOT TIME FOR THAT!
|by Anonymous||reply 99||07/14/2013|
Everyone gets so excited about Jeni's. It's not that fucking special and for ten bucks a pint that ice cream needs to be delicious AND suck my cock, too.
|by Anonymous||reply 100||07/14/2013|
Talenti gelato is incredible, R80 - especially the caramel sea salt flavor! Their containers make terrific cannisters afterwards as well. However, they're so expensive that it's only worth buying on a good sale.
For those of you near a Safeway, try their frozen Greek yogurt, which is To Die For. Safeway's house brand ice cream (including "premium") is pretty bad; everything tastes the same to me.
|by Anonymous||reply 102||07/14/2013|
Another mention of Talenti Gelato. My favorites are Caramel Cookie Crunch and Southern Butter Pecan. But I'll bet I'd like the caramel sea salt, too.
It's on sale this week in DC and Pittsburgh.
|by Anonymous||reply 103||07/14/2013|
yes talent sea salt carmel is like crack....it is on sale in a big ass container at BJ wholesale club too..
|by Anonymous||reply 104||07/14/2013|
As a child visiting Baskin-Robbins, I fell in love with coffee ice cream.
Sue me, but for store-bought mass produced coffee ice cream, Starbuck's makes the best; and I write this as someone who never sets foot in their stores because I don't like their coffee.
As is their coffee, it's way overpriced: $5.39 a pint at my local supermarket.
I'm not a Ben & Jerry's customer- as others have pointed out, it's too damn sweet.
|by Anonymous||reply 105||07/14/2013|
This thread is filled with retail ice queens.
|by Anonymous||reply 106||07/14/2013|
I hated the thought of being an ice cream brand snob too.
Then I tasted Talenti. Now I embrace my ice cream snobbery with a passion.
|by Anonymous||reply 107||07/14/2013|
OK, home-made ice cream queens, since you say it's so easy, how about posting a recipe and instructions?
|by Anonymous||reply 108||07/14/2013|
to be fair Talenti's is gellato not ice cream.
|by Anonymous||reply 109||07/14/2013|
Thanks for clearing that up, r109, seriously.
No wonder when I tried it I didn't care for its texture.
|by Anonymous||reply 110||07/14/2013|
DF Mavens is a store brand that is actually vegan, and amazingly good. Especially the Del Lago Chocolate and the Shot of Java.
|by Anonymous||reply 111||07/14/2013|
The best strawberry ice cream is always made with gin.
|by Anonymous||reply 112||07/14/2013|
Fun fact -- did you know that "coffee" is one of the two official WASP ice cream flavors? (No, the other is NOT vanilla!)
|by Anonymous||reply 113||07/14/2013|
We buy the Neapolitan Imitation Ice Milk from the Piggly Wiggly. It's so cheap!
|by Anonymous||reply 114||07/14/2013|
Here I go.
I grew up on vanilla ice milk. To this day, it's my secret pleasure and takes me back home where it was warm and safe.
You may proceed to castigate me..........
|by Anonymous||reply 116||07/14/2013|
Ice cream should be a rare treat and it should come from an ice cream shop
|by Anonymous||reply 117||07/14/2013|
what about the 365 everyday brand at whole foods? i see people buying all the time but i always wondered what they taste like...
|by Anonymous||reply 119||07/14/2013|
Try making your own ice cream. I had never really liked ice cream because it didn't really agree with me,sometimes the results were just feeling mildly bloated but other times it was way worse. My boyfriend who is in the habit of buying me things that he wants but can't justify spending the money on himself bought me an ice cream maker for my birthday a couple of months ago and I started making ice cream for him. I tasted it a few times and no reaction at all and now I can eat it when ever I want with out any problems.
My brother is a chemist at the FDA and he told me that if a company puts under x micrograms of a chemical in a food they aren't required to list it in their ingredients list and there is no limit to how many chemicals they can put in the food, they are only limited by how much of the chemicals. So they can have a lot more chemicals than anyone would know of from reading the list of ingredients
|by Anonymous||reply 120||07/14/2013|
R108, here's a good & easy recipe.
|by Anonymous||reply 121||07/16/2013|
[quote]My boyfriend who is in the habit of buying me things that he wants but can't justify spending the money on himself bought me an ice cream maker for my birthday a couple of months ago and I started making ice cream for him.
Edit: My boyfriend bought himself an ice cream maker for my birthday.
|by Anonymous||reply 122||07/16/2013|
In my opinion, Blue Bell ice cream is not as rich and creamy as it used to be. Like most food manufacturers, they have replaced healthy, natural fat with more sugar.
Don't trust any food that has less fat in it. It doesn't taste as good, nor is it as healthy.
|by Anonymous||reply 123||06/27/2014|
[quote] I buy Ronnybrook exclusively at the Chelsea Market or the Union Square Farmer's Market.
|by Anonymous||reply 124||06/27/2014|