I see it on here all the time, but I have no idea what it means or where it came from.
Some comedian once said gay men always look in photographs like they are smelling cookies. I don't think that's accurate (nor do many other people here), but one or two posters think it's hilarious and cannot let it go.
lesbians have a code about their labya majora looking like sugar cookies and tasting sweet, so when a woman is a lesbian, her cookies smell or something like that... i never quite understood it.
Can someone post a photo example of a gay guy looking like they're smelling cookies? I don't get it.
R2 Lesbians who've never met Cheryl, that is.
AC: What's that smell? I think I smell cookies. Do you smell cookies?
BM: *sniff* *sniff* Yeah, I think I smell it, too. It smells like peanut butter cookies.
AC: *sniff* Naw, it's more of a brown sugar smell. Maybe it's molasses cookies.
BM: *sniff* *sniff* Maybe it's both. Let's go to lunch.
OP, I think it has to do with the squinty eye/overly tanned look that many gay men had a few years back.
I don't see it as often now, but if you're with the crowd that still obsessively tans and tweezes, there's still squinty gay face. These are the cookie smellers.