Because they didn't want the show to close after one night.
[quote]Why not Liza Minnelli, or Leslie Uggams, or Sandy Duncan, or Michele Lee, or Bernadette Peters, or Ann Reinking, or Madeline Kahn?
Because none of them would have been even remotely convincing speaking lines such as these?
"I'm a bagel on a plate full of onion rolls"
"If ya wanna sit around and schmooze..."
"I'm private Schvartz from Rockavay and I guess you've hoid reports"
"Oy, what a day I had today!"
Carol Burnett, when she turned down the role on Broadway, told Ray Stark and Jule Styne that they needed a Jewish actress or at least someone with a prominent nose to play the part.
Because Bette Midler was too young.
I was in 9th grade you bitch!
Because I was in grade school,dears...
So She Later Could Be Cast In Funny Lady !!
Funny Girl would have been better as a cartoon.
I wasn't born for another 20 years!
OP, you're an idiot.
I share your sentiments, OP.
Because has more talent in her pinky than any you mention, and in manner and looks was very close to Fanny Brice.
Jule Stein brought Ray Stark to see her in a NY club and neither ever seriously considered anyone else.
Now, OP, I think you are a troll.
I thought Eydie Gorme was under consideration at one point. She would've been pretty good!
Shirley Maclaine would have been better as Fanny Brice than Babs
Sure, would love to hear Shirley trill "I'd Rather be Blue, or deliver "Don't Rain on My Parade, or People or Greatest Star or My Man.
Idiots and trolls on this thread.
Maclaine barely made it through the cut-down score of the filmed "Sweet Charity." Get a grip.
R27 R28 you do know that every major studio turned down Funny Girl, unless Maclaine was in the lead.
R29 That explains why a film version was never made.
So what, r29? I fail to see how that means she was up to singing the score, even in a studio. That people were willing to make a bad decision based upon presumed box-office familiarity says nothing about whether she was up to the task.
Talk about missing the point.
R31 so did Julie Andrews get the shaft over My Fair Lady?
Maybe because she was the best fit for the role, and ended up giving a iconic, star-making performance?
And maybe Leslie Uggams wasn't cast because casting an African-American as a famous Jewish performer would have been bizarre?
Also, none of the other performers you mentioned were Jewish, and Fanny Brice was. Streisand was clearly a far better choice than any of the other performers you mentioned. Why are you trolling us about this?
Maclaine scored in Two for a Seasaw and would have brought that kookiness to Fanny Brice.
A much better fit, from Gittel to Fanny.
Funny Girl was not called "Beautiful Girl." People related to the story of someone with less than perfect WASP looks using her other gifts of smarts, persistence, sense of humor, etc to make it in showbiz (or elsewhere.) Now shall we list the male actors who had more talent than looks who also got somewhere?
I have a feeling you guys are young. This is all ancient history to you and you do not know much about the 60s.
Streisand created a sensation with Funny Girl on B'way- and also on TV, concerts, and records. She was a bit of a phenomenon. A mistake was made not casting Julie Andrews in Fair Lady earlier, but she was not the sensation Streisand was.
No one seriously considered for long anyone but her in the movie version.
McClaine knew this well. She is on record as saying when she first saw Streisand perform in LA long before Funny Girl that she was seeing one of the biggest stars ever in show business. She said that Streisand was destined to become one of the "greats".
Fine, r32, you win. Whatever point it is that you're now arguing--you win, you relentless bore.
[quote] someone with less than perfect WASP looks using her other gifts of smarts, persistence, sense of humor, etc to make it in showbiz
Sounds like Shirley Maclaine's life story.
[quote] not casting Julie Andrews in Fair Lady earlier, but she was not the sensation Streisand was.
I'm sure Julie would be thrilled to hear this statement.
[quote] No one seriously considered for long anyone but her in the movie version.
All the studio heads disagreed at the time, insisting Shirley Maclaine be cast.
[quote] Whatever point it is that you're now arguing--you win
So you seriously prefer Audrey Hepburn in My Fair Lady OVER Julie Andrews?
Why are people still arguing about Shirley MacLaine? She would have sounded like crap on the score. THREAD CLOSED!
[quote] She would have sounded like crap on the score.
So that didn't stop Audrey Hepburn from accepting the role in My Fair Lady.
Marni Nixon was available to dub on Funny Girl.
R39, (the McClaine statement) is simply not true- where do you get that information?
[quote]So you seriously prefer Audrey Hepburn in My Fair Lady OVER Julie Andrews?
You are seriously either AlanScott or the Hall Monitor from the Game of Thrones thread. Or both.
[quote]Marni Nixon was available to dub on Funny Girl.
Okay, enough now. It was a valiant try, but some people just have a chemical imbalance and NEED the pills. It's nothing to be ashamed of.
R43 if you preferred Audrey over Julie as Eliza there is nothing wrong with that.
Now you guys are attacking Marni Nixon?
All she did was accept a job.
[quote]Marni Nixon? All she did was accept a job.
Sang Copland's Dickenson songs nicely, too.
I thought I read somewhere that it was part of her contract, in order to get her to do the stage show, she would also get to do the movie.
[quote] Sang Copland's Dickenson songs nicely, too.
Imagine what she could have done with Jules Styne score.
R48 no it wasn't. The contract only said she would be 'considered'.
That way Ray Stark could keep Babs in line by threatening not to give her the part.
Babs had a contract with Stark to do four movies for him. Nowhere in the contract did it say 'Funny Girl' would be one of them.
[quote]Imagine what she could have done with Jules Styne score.
I had to wrestle that bitch to the floor over Gypsy.
OP must be a troll, because otherwise this is a colossally stupid post. Ann Bancroft was originally cast, after Carol Burnett had turned it down because Carol wisely realized you needed to be Jewish to play the part effectively. In the meantime, Jule Styne saw Barbra in 'Wholesale' and heard her sing in the Bon Soir and started dragging the people involved in the production to her shows. He also started writing the score with her voice in his head. After he wrote "People", Bancroft walked. She had been promised a show that was heavy on drama and light on music, and music that was easy to sing as she is no singer. After hearing the songs, she said 'I can't sing this" and hightailed it out of there before making a monumental fool of herself screeching songs that were written for someone else. Barbra was duly brought in, and the rest is history. She created a sensation, re-created the role on film and became a superstar.
As for your original post, OP, you simply must be a troll or one of the most ignorant people alive. Leslie Uggams playing Fanny Brice? Yes, that would have been great. About like Bette Midler playing the governess in 'The King and I" or Bernadette Peters playing Effie in 'Dreamgirls".
[quote]like Bette Midler playing the governess in 'The King and I"
[quote] Leslie Uggams playing Fanny Brice? Yes, that would have been great.
Everyone knows that you put the actor of color in a SUPPORTING role that was conceived for a white actor. That way the company and the audience can congratulate themselves for being "color blind" without having to imagine a leading man and woman of different races ending up as lovers.
God you are all IDIOTS - It was because she had an amazing voice, was great on stage ( had proven herself in " I Can Get It For You Wholesale"), was already selling lots of albums, on her own - as someone else mentioned here, she could SELL the cast album, and was a big, up, and coming star. It's not rocket science.
Because she gave the best head.
r12? r11 listed some of Barbra's men, for those here who think she was/is unattractive.
Who should have been cast as Nicky Arnstein?
She had an amazing singing voice and was hugely popular in the 1960s. The film of Funny Girl wasn't very good outside of her performance. I don't think the film has aged well, but at the time it was WOW!
"Jule Stein brought Ray Stark to see her in a NY club and neither ever seriously considered anyone else."
Not true. Ray Stark and his wife, Fannie Brice's daughter, HATED Streisand because she was such a dog. Really, before she was cleaned up, Babs was a pimple-face meeskite. A real FUG.
"Oh my God. I'm back. I'm home. All the time, it was... We finally really did it ... You Maniacs! You blew it up! Ah, damn you! God damn you all to hell!"
We are switching to the new platform for The DataLounge this weekend. All of our mobile users have been using it for over a week and all first time users have been using it for about a month - which adds up to well over one million users. So we're ready to end this phase of the testing and move everybody to the new site. (more)
And yes, we've changed the look and some of how it operates.
Yes, we know you just *hate* it in well in advance.
Yes, we know we suck.
Yes, we are the biggest suckers that ever sucked.
But it was time for a change and with the huge shift to mobile it was long overdue. We've taken this opportunity not only to update the look but also make major changes under the hood (or "bonnet" if you're either British or pretentious or both). And we have to prepare for 2016 - a presidential election year where we can normally expect to see a 60% jump in traffic (yes, we've seen 5 presidential elections so far…Christ we're old).
The site has a bunch - nay, plethora - of new features which will make the site more usable: better search, the ability to ignore posters and threads, see link previews, to pick up a thread where you left off, spam and malware filtering and more.
If you want you can go explore and see for yourself, Click here.
And while running the tests we've noticed two interesting reactions to the new system - people are spending more time on the site and more people that come stay around longer and look at more stuff. Both good things. Yay!
Possibly we've not slain all the dragons and there will be issues that come up during the switchover. There's a help button in the lower right hand corner of the page which you can use to send us bug reports.
Please include as much information about the hardware (PC, Mac, Tablet, Phone etc), operating system (Windows, Mac OS, Android, iOS etc) and browser (Chrome, Safari, Opera, Internet Explorer etc) that you are using as possible to help us replicate and fix the problem.
Please note that complaints about colors, fonts, icons and the like are not "bugs" - they are design choices that we've made and we expect one or two cases of world-class bitching. But they won't actually cause headaches, scurvy, heart attacks, Restless Leg Syndrome, Morgellon's Disease or the vapors (but have your smelling salts at hand just in case).
Talking to DataLounge servers. Please wait a moment...