Charlize Theron at 2-3 years ago, but even today would be just fine.
Off the top of my head - Angelina Jolie, Jennifer Connelly
I already got my wish - Paul Newman. He stayed handsome until his seventies.
Brooke Shields, Grace Kelly, Elizabeth Taylor, Mia Farrow, Helena Bonham Carter, Catherine Denueve...all stunningly luscious in their youth, then went dowdy.
SJP was gorgeous, still is, but in a older way.
Leo and Pitt were never beautiful, just stupid!
Linda EVILangelista is a bitch but a gorgeous one. Paulina was too.
Isabella Rosselini when she was a little younger.
Oh and Cheryl Ladd.
The entire cast (including George) of the "Freedom" music video.
Rosalind Russell, when she was about 30
[R6][R10] Pitt and Skarsgard were also the first two to come to mind for me.
Alex is pushing 40 and it looks like he'll age great.
90s Brad was just wow (look up his Golden Globes speech in '96 - that is what I call a beautiful man in his prime). He looked pretty great even in 00s movies like "Mr and Mrs Smith", but I still look at Brad as a 90s beauty mostly.