Scalia: Voting Rights Act is a ‘perpetuation of racial entitlement’
Conservative justices on the United State Supreme Court hinted on Wednesday that the 1965 Voting Rights Act (VRA) would soon be ruled unconstitutional.
The landmark achievement of the civil rights movement sought to stop discrimination against black voters by barring poll taxes and literacy tests in southern states, but the conservative justices suggested on Wednesday that it was now those Southern states that were the victims of discrimination.
“Is it the government’s submission that the citizens in the South are more racist than the citizens in the North?” Chief Justice John Roberts asked Solicitor General Donald Verrilli, according to USA Today.
Justice Anthony Kennedy, who VRA supporters had hoped would be a swing vote, indicated that he too was ready gut the law, accusing Congress of “reverse engineering” with its 2006 reauthorization of the Section 5 restrictions on southern states.
“Times change,” Kennedy said.
Justice Antonin Scalia pointed out that an overwhelming number of lawmakers in both parties had voted to reauthorize the law in 1970, 1975, 1982 and 2006. Scalia argued that the nearly-unanimous reauthorizations proved that lawmakers were scared to be seen voting against discrimination, calling it “a phenomenon that is called perpetuation of racial entitlement.”
“I think it’s a safe prediction to say that the Voting Rights Act, as it now stands, is not going to survive,” NBC’s Pete Williams reported on Wednesday after the oral arguments. “The question is how far will the Supreme Court go in striking parts of it down?”
The court is expected to rule on Shelby County v. Holder, the case challenging Section 5, in the coming months. The Voting Rights Act has previously been upheld by the Supreme Court on four different occasions.
Watch this video from MSNBC, broadcast Feb. 27, 2013.
This is the downside of having a black president. Everyone thinks racism is done and over with.
Elections have consequences.
Electing Bush for eight years put Roberts and Alito on the court.
It looks like that folly will mean the end of VRA and probably Roe v. Wade.
Scalia was put on the bench by Reagan.
Scalia is a lowlife punk, corrupt and stupid.
Scalia is a Republican.
Scalia is a waste of oxygen and space.
Of course voting rights legislation is extremely necessary and important.
Of course it has nothing to do with racial entitlement and Scalia is disgusting for suggesting that.
However, it isn't just for the South anymore. We need a new voting rights policy that protects everyone's right to vote everywhere.
I just hope that that fact doesn't paradoxically destroy voting rights in the South, leaving the entire country unprotected. But it does go to the constitutional issue at stake in the case. Does it make sense any longer to confine these policies to the South? No, it doesn't. Because states all over the country are trying to prevent people, and especially minorities, from voting.
[quote] “Is it the government’s submission that the citizens in the South are more racist than the citizens in the North?” Chief Justice John Roberts asked Solicitor General Donald Verrilli, according to USA Today.
Yes, it is. I've never paid a poll tax or been given a literacy test.
Send that trash back to Sicily!
Rachel Maddow likened him to an internet troll tonight on "The Daily Show."
Scalia uses his position on the SCOTUS to advance his own neo-fascist ideology which he justifies with the insane notion that the Constitution is a "dead" document and 21st Century cases should be judged with an 18th Century perspective.
Gutting the Voting Rights Act will be the single-most offensive and transparent act of right-wing legislation-by-judiciary since the court elected Bush president in 2000. The vile untruths and willful distortions coming out of these men's mouths show their indecency and lack of grounding in reality.
Scalia gets a rise out of getting a reaction and getting his name out there in the blogosphere. An activist judge, if I've ever seen one.
Thankfully at almost 77-years-old, he won't be on the court for much longer. He'll be too stubborn to retire during Obama's second term, though.
I dunno, sometimes those racist old wops can live forever.
Federal Elections need to be nationalized and standardized. Ideally the voting rights act would cover more than just 9 states. As we saw with the past election, northern and Midwestern states are trying to get rid of likely progressive and black voters too.
I'll be glad when white people are extinct.
White people built this institution r17. You're a douchebag. If you hate white people so much, move to a country in Africa or Asia. Free yourself from the burden of being white.
Scalia -- who is a first generation Italian -- ought to know what it feels like to be discriminated against.
Did anyone watch the Daily Show tonight? Rachel Maddow was the guest. She was in attendance at the Court when Scalia made the statement. She told Jon Stewart that Scalia is a "troll" who likes the reaction he gets when he says things he knows is just polemic. Sonia Sotomayor challenged him many times on his views. Apparently, the other Justices are so used to his antics that they didn't have much of a reaction. Only Sonia gave him the "what for?" look.
[quote]If you hate white people so much, move to a country in Africa or Asia. Free yourself from the burden of being white.
Are you saying I'll become of color? Moving can do that?
Or are you suggesting that if I were surrounded by people of color they would kill me? Either way you sound like a dickkk.
you sound like a bigger dick r20. You made a stupid comment. To let a bigoted asshole like Scalia represent all white people makes you sound quite stupid. Let's not forget that Clarence Thomas holds the same views as Scalia on the VRA and Affirmative Action (even though he benefited from it).
"This is the downside of having a black president. Everyone thinks racism is done and over with."
Say wha..? No downsides having a black president AND if anything, it has brought racism front and center. Especially the racism of the Republican party.
"Oh my God. I'm back. I'm home. All the time, it was... We finally really did it ... You Maniacs! You blew it up! Ah, damn you! God damn you all to hell!"
We are switching to the new platform for The DataLounge this weekend. All of our mobile users have been using it for over a week and all first time users have been using it for about a month - which adds up to well over one million users. So we're ready to end this phase of the testing and move everybody to the new site. (more)
And yes, we've changed the look and some of how it operates.
Yes, we know you just *hate* it in well in advance.
Yes, we know we suck.
Yes, we are the biggest suckers that ever sucked.
But it was time for a change and with the huge shift to mobile it was long overdue. We've taken this opportunity not only to update the look but also make major changes under the hood (or "bonnet" if you're either British or pretentious or both). And we have to prepare for 2016 - a presidential election year where we can normally expect to see a 60% jump in traffic (yes, we've seen 5 presidential elections so far…Christ we're old).
The site has a bunch - nay, plethora - of new features which will make the site more usable: better search, the ability to ignore posters and threads, see link previews, to pick up a thread where you left off, spam and malware filtering and more.
If you want you can go explore and see for yourself, Click here.
And while running the tests we've noticed two interesting reactions to the new system - people are spending more time on the site and more people that come stay around longer and look at more stuff. Both good things. Yay!
Possibly we've not slain all the dragons and there will be issues that come up during the switchover. There's a help button in the lower right hand corner of the page which you can use to send us bug reports.
Please include as much information about the hardware (PC, Mac, Tablet, Phone etc), operating system (Windows, Mac OS, Android, iOS etc) and browser (Chrome, Safari, Opera, Internet Explorer etc) that you are using as possible to help us replicate and fix the problem.
Please note that complaints about colors, fonts, icons and the like are not "bugs" - they are design choices that we've made and we expect one or two cases of world-class bitching. But they won't actually cause headaches, scurvy, heart attacks, Restless Leg Syndrome, Morgellon's Disease or the vapors (but have your smelling salts at hand just in case).
Talking to DataLounge servers. Please wait a moment...