He is really pretty. I would not like to hear him talk, but it would be great to fuck him.
Too much of a cookie-sniffing face for me.
Oddly enough, his most masculine photo is the one where Terry Richardson dressed him up like a 70s gay porn star.
Huge hands too.
Hope he will go back to Girls since TNN is almost definitely going to be canceled.
He should be handsome. But he's just not to me. I don't think it's gay face, because on Girls he doesn't have it as bad as he does on TNN. He's tall, has nice features, is talented. But he does nothing for me.
I think he is adorable.
His nose is weird in a Mare Winningham type way. Also, that twink look is so weak, just yuck.
But he's got a nice body.
He is in a movie called Bachelorette starring Kirsten Dunst, James Marsden, and Rebel Wilson.
In TNN, is he top or bottom, he is so much taller than the other guy.
I finally got around to watching The New Normal on HuLu. I like it. He and Bartha make a much more attractive and believable couple than the two twits on Modern Family. The surrogate Mommy is sweet. Nene is actually entertaining. Not crazy about the Ellen Barkin character, though I loved her when she was young. The little girl is weird and is a cross between the young girl who played Jill as a child in the original Mighty Joe Young and the fat kid on Modern Family. I hope this show gets another season. Rannell's character on Girls is the only one I can stand.
He looks like an inbred rat-faced hick.
Would be hot if it wasn't for the face.
[quote]since TNN is almost definitely going to be canceled.
I think you are wrong there. It'll be back for a second season.
R15 Ratings are really bad, so probably not.
You have to adjust for the fact that it's NBC.
It's a goner, as well as SMASH. Especially now that Comcast has bought NBC.
R17 They are bad even for NBC show.
He did it to himself. That feminizing nosejob really damaged his looks.
You said it best, R7.
I want to see Andrew Rannells entering Justin Bartha's furry hole.
Loved him in The Book of Mormon.
He's more sweetly good looking than hot and has that cute midwestern cornfed looks. That's how he got cast as a Mormon. He's got a decent body --see naked scene in Girls and he's over 6 feet 2 inches.
He just needs to get a couple of DUI's, accidentally post some naked cock pictures on Twitter, show pics of him doing coke (which he said he did before because hey he's a New Yorker) and he'll have all those fickle superficial gay boys calling him hot and chasing after him.
Exactly what R20 said. That nosejob is a nightmare, and poor Andrew would actually be quite handsome without it.
Can he actually have his nose enlarged somehow?
He's not remotely good looking. He has a face made for comedy.
However, he seems like a sweet, personable guy.
Not everyone has to be gorgeous or hot.
Are we sure the nose is fake? Anyone have a before pic?
I can't imagine why he would have his nose redone to look like that.
I am so ridiculously in love with him (from afar)! Seems like he has a great personality, really good sense of humor, and he's very attractive to boot. I am obsessed!!
I'm not a plastic surgery guru, but to my untrained eye, his face does look very plasticky. Seems like a nice guy though.
I don't think the nose is fake. But I wonder if he's part black. It looks like an African-American nose.