From worst to best. Not so much by their subsequent commercial success, just how good they are.
11. Lee DeWyze. He's cute and can more or less carry a tune, but doesn't seem particularly inspired. Should not have won. Has faded faster than a Bravo reality tv star.
10. Scotty Mcreery. He's ok. Barely distinguishable from the two or three who won before him.
9. Kris Allen. Really not that bad, although I'm not sure I see an appeal outside suburban coffeehouses. One half-decent Kanye West cover will not carry a career.
8. Ruben Studdard. So unbelievably dull, if he'd been around in the 80s he'd have fallen far behind a much better group of soul crooners (Luther, Peabo, James Ingram, etc.). I do have soft spot for him, though, for having sung Superstar.
7. Fantasia. Can't say I ever "got" her. I thought Jennifer Hudson and Diana DeGarmo were both much better. And what a nails-on-the-chalkboard voice! Ugh. But I'll give her points for being unique.
6. Jordin Sparks. Can't say I remember too much about her, but she strikes me as someone who should be cranking out anonymous gay disco anthems (a la Cascada or Deborah Cox) and not trying to rule Billboard.
5. Taylor Hicks. Often and mercilessly mocked, but I think it's more like he's in the wrong genre. He's a genuine blues guy in a way that few white guys can pull off, but he will never be a pop star.
4. Carrie Underwood. Strong pipes, no doubt, although I wish she didn't look exactly like 50 other country blondes. Great singer, I guess. Zero personality.
3. David Cook. Wildly underrated. Love the smoky voice. Definitely one who I hope can at some point achieve the commercial recognition he deserves.
2. Phillip Phillips. Dumb name, hugely talented. That Home song is good but starting to get irritating.
1. Kelly Clarkson. The first Idol and still far and away the best. A truly stunning talent. I would put her up against anyone (Celine, Mariah, Babs, Whitney, etc.) as the greatest pop singer ever.
Frankentasia is the worst, not to mention a drugged up whore!
Clay should have won, love Ruben but Clay had more range in his voice.
Don't diss 'Tasia !
Don't care about the winners. The real winners didn't win.
R3 that's painfully unfunny and sophomoric.
[quote]1. Kelly Clarkson. The first Idol and still far and away the best. A truly stunning talent. I would put her up against anyone (Celine, Mariah, Babs, Whitney, etc.) as the greatest pop singer ever.
You actually typed this with a straight face???
Did the last year's winner even have a record contract? I saw him being interviewed he acted like you could buy his cd on his website?
I see it's White-Trash-American-Idol-Fan season on DL.
In most cases the more talented also-rans had more of an impact during the competitions. People like Adam, Clay, Jennifer, Melinda Doolittle, Daughtry and Elliott Yamin were singers whe you really looked forward to seeing week after week. The downside of Idol is that it's teen girls who vote in droves and they don't necessarily vote for talent but for the chemical reaction the singers ingnite in their wee teen bodies. Also the teenies seem to be on a C&W kick the past few years which can be as dull as listening to paint dry.
R6, those Kelly Nuts are almost as obnoxious as the Glamberts.
Clarkson's problem is that the material she uses sucks.
You need to be a cute white boy to win AI nowadays.
R9, the more talented also-rans had even more impact after the competition. This is why they are the REAL WINNERS of the show. Look at Clay Aiken. His talent is undeniable and he is still has a viable career after 10 years and has sold more than double of what Ruben could all along the way. Ruben who?
[quote]10. Scotty Mcreery. He's ok. Barely distinguishable from the two or three who won before him.
What? He's NOTHING like the "two or three" who won before him.
[quote]5. Taylor Hicks. Often and mercilessly mocked, but I think it's more like he's in the wrong genre. He's a genuine blues guy in a way that few white guys can pull off, but he will never be a pop star.
Five? Bitch please. Taylor Hicks is THE WORST Idol winner to date.
[quote]3. David Cook. Wildly underrated. Love the smoky voice. Definitely one who I hope can at some point achieve the commercial recognition he deserves.
"wildly underrated" = "I want to have sex with him"
[quote]Did the last year's winner even have a record contract? I saw him being interviewed he acted like you could buy his cd on his website?
What a stupid question. His debut album went gold and the single "Home" went double platinum.
R15, P2's single Home is at 3.5 million and shows no signs of slowing down. His album is gold and rapidly approaching platinum. Idol hasn't had anyone, winner or not, selling this well in many years.
American Idol & American Voters are VERY homophobic. This is why Clay & Adam came in second only to outsell the winners.
This show should die already.
Outselling Kris Allen is hardly an accomplishment.
There was a great article a few years back, when Scotty was competing. I forget the girl who came in second, Alaina or something like that, but the article was talking about how religious Scotty was and how the girl had a hard time singing the word "evil" because she was such a goody goody and thought it was bad.
The article went on to talk about how southern values voters always vote for the contestant who is most like them, not who is the most talented. That is why Daughtry, Lambert, Hudson, etc. never win. It wasn't always this way, which is why we have Fantasia, Ruben, Jordan, etc. but it's morphed into a church revival competition. And the reason why you seldom ever hear of the winners again is because it's all young kids who have morals and can't compete with the outrageous antics of Rihanna, Katy, Keisha, Gaga, etc. These kids are more geared to sing at a church picnic.
I'm paraphrasing of course, but you get the gist. I actually quit watching the show at that point because it was dead on. It's not a talent competition, it's a 'moral value' and 'who's most like me' competition.
Honey, from last season Jessica Sanchez and the guy who came in 3rd Joshua Ledet are two of the best singers ever on the show, they are both amazing.
Here they are dueting on "I Knew You Were Waiting For Me" watch the ending.
R19, so you are saying that Ruben & Clay, who are both from the deep south, both raised singing in church, were so equal in their southerness that Ruben won because there were more black voters or was it that Clay was gay and there were more homophobic voters?
I'll go with door #2.
R19, I think it's less about morals and values, and more about teenage/tween white girls voting for the dreamy white boy who can strum a guitar. Basically, girls voting for the cute heartthrob - nothing new about that.
Ruben was no white boy guitar strumming teen heart throb.
I'd agree with you, R21, but as I said in R19, it wasn't always that way, according to the article.
The show morphed over the years into a vote for who is 'most like me'. So it probably wasn't that way at the beginning, but I would bet homophobia cost both Clay and Adam the title.
Don't forget the sexy bald guy and the Gay Aiken.
Are any of them selling their CDs at the car wash while they're on break?
Isn't Ruben gay? I know a white guy who looks/talks a lot like him who is a closeted married guy so I think Ruben might be also.
Ruben is not gay.
OP didn't want to be called a fraucunt. That's why Hicks is at 5 and not 1. That would have been obvious.
I don' understand how they could ever let a common street thug win.
What r6 said. These Kelly Clarkson nuts, seriously.
[quote]4. Carrie Underwood. Strong pipes, no doubt, although I wish she didn't look exactly like 50 other country blondes. Great singer, I guess. Zero personality.
I can categorically tell you that she DOES have a personality, and that it's a great one. She's actually hilarious. Unfortunately, it just doesn't come across all too well in her performances and public manner.
She practiced her voice into to epic proportions after winning AI, and I'd say she's at least just as good as Kelly.
I saw Taylor Hicks perform at a casino (the friend I was with got free tickets as a comp) and he wasn't that bad, actually quite good. Not good enough to do a stadium-filling tour but fine for an evening's entertainment. Saw him on the casino floor after the show, late in the evening.
[quote]Saw him on the casino floor after the show, late in the evening.
On the floor? Passed out?
All pale in comparison to our little Honduran hot hole, David Archuleta.
I honestly never understood all the Kelly Clarkson hype. Her voice is so raspy, she sounds like she's yelling all the time, and her songs all sound the same.
R36, he had to leave "entertainment" to go on a Mormon mission.
"...and her songs all sound the same." How original! Shows some of you are hard of hearing and can't discern talent from talent wannabes.
I've been a faithful viewer since the show premiered in the '60s & the only one I ever voted for was Carmen Rasmussen.
Clay Aiken should have beat Ruben. And he should have beat Arsenio, too. But it doesn't matter. His career will always be better than both of theirs combined. And I like Ruben & Arsenio, but Clay is just that much more talented.
Phillip Phillips is wonderful. He's my all-time favorite American Idol winner.
Adam Lambert should have won, too. His music is not music I care to listen to, but his talent his undeniable.
Has David Archuleta come out of the closet yet? (if he is indeed gay)
"I see it's White-Trash-American-Idol-Fan season on DL."
Does it ever end?
R33, no way in hell Underwood's as strong a singer as Clarkson. Clarkson is stunningly versatile. Did you watch the Duets singing competetion last year?
Kelly's fans want the big belting, anthemic arena songs like "Stronger." She's acknowledged that and jokingly (?) complained about it. That's why all of her songs sound the same.
I'm far from being a country music fan, but I disagree with OP about Carrie Underwood. I prefer her to Clarkson, actually, and strangely it is the material. Clarkson does what I consider insipid, instantly forgettable pop numbers; Underwood has really done some good songs that, even if they weren't in my preferred genre, stuck with me. Plus, I think she's totally gorgeous.
[quote]R33 no way in hell Underwood's as strong a singer as Clarkson. Clarkson is stunningly versatile. Did you watch the Duets singing competetion last year?
No. I'm pretty sure you have it wrong. Carrie got really good.
[quote]Has David Archuleta come out of the closet yet? (if he is indeed gay)
Oh, man. He appears to be on his Latter-Day mission at the moment.
David Archie will come out when he is ready. Let's give him the time to work through it on his own. Like it was for Clay, he could still be in the denial stage waiting for puberty to hit.
I thought Taylor Hicks was the worst winner in American Idol history. He was a talentless clown. To this day I don't know how he won over Chris Daughtry.
Although Chris has become much more successful than Taylor, so it's all good. I mean, where is Taylor these days? Haven't heard a word about him in ages.
[quote]Clarkson does what I consider insipid, instantly forgettable pop numbers
STRONGER (WHAT DOESN'T KILL YOU)
SINCE U BEEN GONE
BEHIND THESE HAZEL EYES
MY LIFE WOULD SUCK WITHOUT YOU
BECAUSE OF YOU
MR. KNOW IT ALL
[quote]Clarkson is stunningly versatile.
I heard she was mostly a top.
Ahem R50. You proved the point. Insipid forgettable man bashing fluff.
Don't think so, R52. These songs were monster hits, and several of them have nothing to do with man-bashing. But thanks anyway.
Kelly Clarkson does a great job with THE TROUBLE WITH LOVE, from the LOVE ACTUALLY soundtrack. However the hands down winner in terms of generating real and authentic electricity in the audience will always be Clay Aiken. The night he sang BRIDGE OVER TROUBLED WATER he blew the roof off the place.
However the hands down winner in terms of generating real and authentic electricity in the audience will always be ADAM LAMBERT
There. Fixed it for you R54.
Making a list of the best AI winners!
I remember how much fun it was back in middle school to categorize trivia. Youth is so sweetly hilarious.
Update: Reuben Studdard is going to compete on the next season of "The Biggest Loser". No, I'm not making a joke-sadly that is true. As much as it will be great to see him get in better shape/health, it's sad that someone of his vocal talent will also be using this exposure as a career move. I just hope maybe he can gain some fans again. If someone wanted to make a separate thread about it, go ahead.
The producers needed a black winner,so they chose Ruben, an affable, teddy bearish type; It had noting to do with homophobia, but the need to keep black viewers and seem non-racist.
I wonder if the Biggest Loser exposure will make people care about Ruben again. He has a nice voice.
I agree 100% Kelly Clarkson is by far the best they ever had, though I would not rate her as the greatest pop star ever--not even close. But she's terrific all the same, and has deserved her fine career.
As for the winners, there are several they had over the years who did not win who are better than any of the others: Jennifer Hudson, Chris Daughtry, Elliot Yamin.
[quote]6. Jordin Sparks. Can't say I remember too much about her, but she strikes me as someone who should be cranking out anonymous gay disco anthems (a la Cascada or Deborah Cox) and not trying to rule Billboard.
She seems like a nice girl and has a good voice, but she isn't really much of a performer and her songs suck really bad. I agree - she should try going down the dance music route.
Anyone who doubts Carrie Underwood's singing ability has not seen her performance of "How Great Thou Art" at the CMAs last year. Amazing. I love Kelly Clarkson, and I think she's definitely the more versatile singer, but Underwood has serious chops.
Kris Allen should hire Adam Lambert to produce some tracks for his next album (if he gets to do another one.) During their season they really seemed to feed off each other's very different music styles and personalities.
Vocally, it's Carrie Underwood who's the best not Kelly! Listen to Kelly's Before Your Love during the season 1 finale (both results and performance show), her lower register really sucked! She had a lot of bum notes there! (Skip to 2:00 in the video) While Carrie was so pitch perfect!
But when it comes to stage presence, Taylor Hicks is by miles the best!
Fantasia's voice unique? I'm really surprised why no one pointed out that Fantasia sounds exactly like Michelle Williams of Destiny's Child! She's not unique!
Carrie is the only winner with a unique voice... You will never confuse her voice with anyone else's when you hear her on radio!
The rest are so generic!
David Cook should bare some skin.. he's hot
OP, to me you lost all credibility when you put Phil Phillips at #2.
R54 and R55 It's Taylor Hicks who never failed to work the audience... Not Clay, not Adam... Didn't notice that most runners-up are gay!
Scotty McGreary has a unique voice. So very very low.
There is only one other singer who sounds somewhat similar and he is also in country music. (he was not on American Idol)
And the OP's assessment of Scotty is ludicrous and could not be more wrong - saying that Scott is indecipherable from a couple of other winners preceding him.
There is not another American Idol winner who is even remotely similar to Scotty McGreery. Scotty is the only male American Idol winner who is a country music singer.
Scotty's voice is extremely different from other winners and no one other winner looks anything like him.
The OP's assessments are 99 percent wrong on every winner he lists. The OP is lacking information and knowledge, and makes laughably wrong statements and assessments of each winner he lists.
The dumb dope ridiculing Taylor Hicks on this thread does not have a shred of information or knowledge of Taylor Hicks' actual career and talks about his career with sheer stupidity - Taylor Hicks career is doing quite well.
None of these Idol winners became as successful as Britney Spears or Rihanna!
Winner Lee DeWyze makes a living in music.
Any person who can make a living in music deserve credit.
R73, you sound young and stupid. Or maybe you're not young, but you're still stupid.
The point is not to be as big as Rihanna or Britney. For you to think so is quite immature and a sheltered uneducated point of view.
The point is to have a career in music and be able to make a living in music.
to those curious about what Taylor Hicks is up to nowadays, see this
R75 Did I mention that they have to?
I was just pointing out that no idol winner went as big as Britney or Rihanna! therefore, the show is not as successful as many people think it is! Sorry! Idol was a flop!
Even Carrie Underwood can't outsell Taylor Swift considering she has a year headstart! LOL
Carrie is vocally much better than Kelly whose voice always sounded so strained...
Phillip Phillps has his second album coming out next week. It'll be interested to see how it does, and if he can manage to be the only Idol winner besides Kelly and Carrie not to slide into obscurity.
Fantasia is really gifted--it's a shame she isn't more together in her personal life.
I'd put her at number two on the list.
R77, no, American Idol is definitely NOT a flop.
The purpose of American Idol is to give young people a career in music and allow them to make a living in music.
American Idol has surpassed that goal because not only are most, if not all, of the winners having a career in music and making their living in music, many of the runners-up, and those who came in 3rd, 4th, 5th, or 6th are also having a career in music and making their living in music.
R81, do you work for AI? The purpose of the show is to make money for the producers.
I hear you, r76, having seen and met Taylor more than once. His stage presence is electrifying and he performs non-stop for at least 90 minute (this was a solo tour, not LV).
HOWEVER, I've also seen Adam a number of times and believe me, he is incredible. The voice alone is other-worldly (or, as Roger Taylor of Queen said, 1 in a 100 million).
Taylor was the first Idol contestant to truly work the Nokia, honor the band, and dress to fit each theme week. Adam was the next and last.
Britney? The used and abused "Slave 4 U" (truth) Britney? Rihanna? The beholden-now-to-Jay-Z RiRi? Neither is what anyone should wish to emulate.
And to put any of the women in the category of Streisand, let alone say any is superior, is beyond ludicrous.
As is true for all of television shows, r82, so I trust you comment on none?
Good lord, it's a Frauvalanche in here.
The 'such a pretty face' fat girl who won last year was a great singer.
This year it's come down to Gina (spelled correctly on purpose) and Caleb, both power belters. Alex Preston, the guy voted out this week, was arguably the most talented contestant of the season and a friend of Alex and Sierra, the X-Factor winners.
What's with all the Jordin Sparks "weight loss" stories lately? They even interviewed her on "Today". Who the fuck cares? This chick hasn't released an album since 2009 and all of her singles in the past 5 years have been total flops.
Is she even with RCA still?
The Taylor Hicks fans are hilarious.
I've met him in professional circumstances several times and he was a grade a asshole. He got worse the less famous he got, too.
[quote]the most talented contestant of the season and a friend of Alex and Sierra, the X-Factor winners.
How does he know them?
I would put David cook second. I didn't watch Phillips' season and I hate that effing "Home" song.
I wonder what Phillip Phillips's piss slit looks like. It must be ravaged from all the kidney stones he's had to pass.
R89, so, judge a singer, songwriter, musician by just one song.
yeah, that's smart
David Archuleta's vocal ability is at par with Josh Groban
Let's also rank the runners-up based on vocals regardless of commercial success:
1. David Archuleta- very unique tone and nice range
2. Katharine McPhee- very pretty
3. Diana DeGarmo- can sustain high notes clearly
4. Adam Lambert- wide range for a male vocalist
5. Blake Lewis- unique beatboxing
6. Bo Bice- good stage presence
7. Clay Aiken- broadway vocals
8. Justin Guarini
9. Kree Harrison
10. Crystal Bowersox
11. Jessica Sanchez- just so-so
12. Lauren Alaina- wth was she doing in the top2?!?
I did not win AI but I made a MAJOR impression. And you know what? I did not even have professional training back then.
Has Clarkson done anything significant after Breakaway? I guess she used up all her talent in that album, all follow ups are just desperate attempts to repeat Breakaway.
R96 From season 12 where mariah carey was a judge
David Archuleta will come out of the closet the day his father dies.
Fantasia is my all time favorite. I wish she could get her personal life in order.
(distant) 3. Allen
They are the only three I've ever listened to after the show. Some of the others have talent (technically) but I'm not interested in listening to them.
Fantasia's voice= 1000000 fingernails on chalkboard!
R99 Maybe David's dad is not as mean as you think
I think Kelly is a little bit overrated... Her vocals are not that great...
[quote]David Archuleta will come out of the closet the day his father dies.
Well that's surprising if that's the only thing standing in his way, but I'm pretty sure he has other things hanging over him, like, oh I dunno--the entire Mormon Church?! His dad has no right to stand in judgment of anyone, anyway. I'm pretty sure he violated Mormon moral code with his massage parlor activities.
Let's make assessments with every season:
Season 1- Kelly was so overrated. Her voice was so unstable at her lower register and a little pitchy at her upper range. Justin was better vocally, but Kelly obviously has the star quality needed.
Season 2- Ruben deserved to win. I don't get Clay. His voice is so broadway. I dunno.
Season 3- Fantasia was so polarizing. She was even answering back to Simon rudely when being criticized. Her voice is so chipmunkish. So like Michelle Williams of Destiny's Child, not really as unique as the judges were pointing out. Diana can sustain high notes clearly while Fantasia can't. Diana, however, was like Kelly because her lower register is not so stable. I also can't forget the fact that she was sabotaged in her "Don't Cry Out Loud" encore performance in the finale so that Fantasia would win.
Season 4- Carrie definitely deserved to win. I just don't get Bo Bice. Carrie's voice was unique, and she was so good despite having no vocal training prior to the competition although she lacked stage presence.
Season 5- Taylor Hicks was really my favorite winner. He deserved to win! He's the most quirky contestant ever. Kat McPhee was also good although she really can't beat Taylor's fanbase (Soul Patrol).
Season 6- Eeeeew I hate Jordin Sparks. Nothing special about her. I rooted for Blake Lewis because he had something new to contribute to the music industry. I hate Jordin.
Season 7- I love David Archuleta, but Cook also deserved his win. Best top 2 ever.
Season 8- I liked Kris Allen too. Adam was so overrated! He's only screaming in his upper range! Eeeeew can't stand him. And it was obvious from the audition that he's gay!
Season 9- I liked Lee DeWyze. He has artistry in him unlike Crystal.
Season 10- I hate this season.
Season 11- I also hated it.
Season 12- Candice didn't even deserve to be in the Top 10. She's a Season 9 reject and like Simon said, she has no star appeal. Kree should've won.
Season 13- Not worth watching. Yuck.
You have terrible taste and know nothing about singing R106.
There is no such term as "pitchy" dawg. Obviously you are a fan, and fan's have favorites, but your descriptions of most all voices that you criticized, and the ones you liked, contain technically incorrect assertions.
Carrie Underwood has the unsupported lower register, she can only sing vowels and high notes. She is flat in her low register, and often sharp in her upper range. Clarkson always had the range and has developed the nuance and control to be the best and most versatile voice in pop music. Kelly Clarkson is still the greatest find of American Idol. Yes she does sing her voice ragged sometimes, but only because she is a spinto soprano with a whole other gear that 99.9% of singers don't have and she overuses it. To some she is over-rated, but to real singers and voice teachers her voice is phenomenal.
Adam Lambert does not always scream, he just has a polarizing voice. Fantastic range and power, but really cool when he slows it down too. Fantasia was indeed unique. She sounds like Diana Ross, Gladys Knight and a bit of Aretha combined, but she has her own style and when she does not push her voice outside her range, it is a beautiful soulful instrument. Crisp and sweet intonation, tasteful runs, great emotion and rhythmically exciting.
Candice Glover AND David Archuleta both had beautiful tone to their voice, Candice smoky, jazzy and rich, David like a raspy castrati.
Kris Allen and Lee Dewyze sound like everyone and anyone. Phillip Phillips may be derivative of Dave Mathews and others, but of the non-vocalists who won, he has the most artistry and style, the personal voice of a good musician/songwriter.
Scotty, Ruben, Taylor and Jordin are the least interesting and memorable winners. I love R&B, but Ruben is nothing special. Taylor Hicks is terrible. Jordin was the last of the girls who thought they could win by singing Whitney Houston and Aretha poorly that managed to win. Scotty, nor Laura Alaina were the best singers of their season.
Elliott Yamin, Daughtry, and Latoya London are the ones who should have made it to the finals in their seasons. Jennifer Hudson was far from ready when she was on AI. There was never a more clear cut winner than Fantasia from the start. That girl had a shimmering star in her voice and a wonderful performance style. It has somewhat devolved.
Of the runner-ups, Archuleta, Clay Aiken and Crystal Bowersox got my vote. Don't love any of them, but thought they deserved to win.
Carrie Underwood does have a unique sound, some great songs and deserves her success as a recording artist and is a huge draw in person. She still has a lot of problems when singing live, though she has improved.
Diana DeGarmo and her husband Ace were lucky to get the exposure for their future in community theatre. There are singers as good as they in any high school.
Simon Cowell said some years back that Kelly Clarkson was the best singer they had ever discovered by a mile, that Carrie would be the most successful and that Fantasia was his personal favorite. Sums up the top three pretty well. Phillip Phillips is the only one likely to join them at the top level of success.
Adam will always work but like Jennifer Hudson his voice bugs alot of people. They don't sell records, but have both had a couple great hits. They are stellar performers with impressive vocal abilities.
Elliot Yamin, Archuleta and especially Candice Glover could break through with an album still, but they are not performers people want to see on the VMA's, or in person.
David Cook is a nice guy, Kelly Pickler is lucky, and Melinda Doolittle is twenty feet from stardom, where she belongs.
Kelly Clarkson is far from "the greatest pop star ever" (!!!), but this clip (her best performance from AI) shows why she's the best AI winner ever, and a genuinely fine singing star.
OK I'm not gonna bother going through this thread after seeing how highly rated OP gave fucking Phillip Phillips? He's probably the weakest winner vocally. He can't sing for shit.
Candice Glover has the best voice with Fantasia and Kelly next then Ruben, Carrie and Jordin.
I don't love this arrangement, but I love this song.
"Always on My Mind."
Fantasia can sing, hell yes.
Phillip Phillips is number one commercially. His songs have been used in tons of movies, TV shows, and commercials. His song was used in that NBC dating show, a realty commercial, Clint Eastwood's Trouble With the Curve and now in a bunch of new movies that came out this year. His new song Raging Fire is the theme song for Godzilla and is the song for the Godzilla music video.
I agree that R106 has awful taste. I like R107's assessment. And here is info on which of the past winners has been the most commercially successful.
[quote]I can categorically tell you that she DOES have a personality, and that it's a great one. She's actually hilarious. Unfortunately, it just doesn't come across all too well in her performances and public manner.
I met her at a party a few days after the "Sound of Music" debacle. When someone brought it up she turned stiff as a corpse and almost cried. You could tell she knew she wasn't prepared for that kind of live show. The C-list "famous" bitch that was mocking her performance was SHUT DOWN. After a few minutes she was back to normal- charming, self-effacing, and down to earth.
She's also incredibly gorgeous. I can understand why Dolly has taken her under her lady ham...I mean wing.
Frankentasia should never have won, she is a drugged up whore. I'm surprised she is even still alive.
Fantasia was the best. She knew how to perform and connect with an audience. She was the most artistic and innately, the smartest.
R108 I don't agree! Fantasia is the best singer ever and this Summertime performance proves it!!!
Carrie Underwood was groomed from a very young age, she was a fixture in the beauty pageant circuit and she did receive vocal training and stage singing, dancing...She was not a newbie to competitions like AI
Carrie graduated magna cum laude (Journalism)... She's not just talented but also very bright!
Carrie Underwood was a farm girl in rural Oklahoma.
She was quite a bit heavier in weight on AI.
I doubt she was in pageants or groomed or had singing/dancing lessons.
Never saw the show when Fantasia was on, but I've bought each of her CDs. For me, unquestionably the best thing to come out of the show.
Taylor Hicks is the best!
R121 come on! Carrie almost signed with Capitol Record in 1996. She was 14 and already a veteran at talent shows and country fairs.
The show is owned by 19 Entertainment, who in turn owns the singers for a while after the show. Anyone who can get a record deal on their own is generally not going to bother with AI.
Any contestant with any dream of winning should begin writing lyrics as soon as possible. The pattern has been to have the first album be entirely written by pro song writers. The following albums usually have about 1/4 written by the artist. Artists should lobby to put out a second album within a year of the first while the iron is hot and their fan base is in the mode of requesting their music on the radio and buying their music. A lot of Idol contestants fall off the radar between the first and second album because they are spaced so far apart.
Some undeserved Kelly hate here. It's clear she is the best singer to come out of AI and she earned winning the first year of the show.
I love David Cook. My only problem with him is when he makes ugly face when singing glory notes...
kris allen and phillip2x also make ugly face when singing high notes
I wanna have sex with David Archuleta as well
My gaydar goes PING with Taylor Hicks!
The problem is that these singers show amazing promise on the show and then release the dullest first albums possible.
who the fuck are all these nobodies?
R107 really does have it right about Clarkson. She tends to sing her voice ragged, but her instrument is incredible. Any professional vocalist or teacher can attest to this. I'm a singing actor on Broadway, and I know many of today's best, beltiest singers who shy away from performing Clarkson's stuff because her range is so ridiculous.
And this is not even taking into account the style of her voice, which is a completely separate phenomenon. Her voice has a palette of textures, nuances, and colors that few singers use nowadays. The fact that she can take any derivative, generic piece of crap song and turn it into an ultra-listenable anthem is a testament to this.
Top-Earning AI Alum of 2013
1. Carrie Underwood ($31 million)
2. Kelly Clarkson ($7 million)
3. Phillip Phillips ($5 million, tie)
3. Adam Lambert ($5 million, tie)
5. Daughtry ($4 million)
6. Scotty McCreery ($3 million)
7. Taylor Hicks ($2.5 million)
8. Fantasia Barrino ($1.5 million, tie)
8. Kellie Pickler ($1.5 million, tie)
10. Katharine McPhee ($1 million, tie)
10. Jennifer Hudson ($1 million, tie)
some surprising entry like Taylor Hicks, obviously doing very well despite little media coverage.
R137 He is cute, and I think he should have a better career than where he is now, but not sure he was motivated enough to have a bigger impact. He seemed to be content after he won the idol and had a decent following year.
R136, he recently had a long term gig at a Las Vegas hotel for 6 months or a year that was very successful where he performed several times per week.
He also tours. His show is really great - I saw a filming of the whole concert on a cable TV channel.
Fantasia has been my favorite. Too bad she had bad advice and followed her trashy origins, unable to rise above it. With proper handling she could have had a very solid career.
I find Fantasia challenging to look at as far a physical looks and presence.
I think Candace will be number 12.
How will Caleb or JenA/gena/Ginny/ Jenny rank?
Fantasia is unquestionably the most gifted performer to come through A.I. if you see her onstage she has star quality. Saw her in "Color Purple" and "After Midnight" and she was fabulous.
I was looking at iTunes charts 5-6 months ago and saw Fantasia had several #1 and top 10 hits in the Caribbean and Africa. She is doing well with black audiences internationally. I thought her career went belly up. I was proven wrong.
Radio was very favorable to American Idol contestants in the early seasons. Now it is very hard for them to get radio play which is the life blood of successful careers. You can't have a million people buy your song without it being played on the radio and if they aren't buying then you can't have a concert tour. There are currently no American Idol contestants in the top 40. Only Daughtry was in the top 40 in the last several months.
Carrie is definitely better than Kelly! Carrie managed to belt a 12-second note in Angels Brought Me Here despite being sick! also a 14-second note in Out of Nothing At All during the top 3 night! Kelly can't hold a note longer than 3 seconds even when she's not sick! Boo!!!
R132 Please don't confuse Taylor Hicks with LAUTNER! T. Hicks is not gay!
[quote]There are currently no American Idol contestants in the top 40. Only Daughtry was in the top 40 in the last several months.
Not true. Phillip Phillip is on the rodeo all the damn time. He now has a third song in constant rotation called Raging Fire which is on the Godzilla soundtrack.
“The platform of American Idol changed my life,” says Taylor Hicks, who now owns a restaurant in his native Alabama.
Wow, Hicks went from singer to food slinger.
Candice is the worst winner ever! It was so ironic that someone who got rejected twice in the same show actually won!
Justin Bieber is more popular than all of them combined!
Just like Caleb who got rejected twice is now going to win.
2 Flop Seasons in a row! American Idol should reformat!
Carrie should do a country pop crossover so that she can beat Shania Twain's worldwide record!!!
Say what you will about American Idol but has any of The Voice's winners ever gone on to a successful, hit-making career? Other than Cassadee Pope?
I like Kris Allen. He's much more talented, authentic and down to earth than the annoying fame whore Adam Lambert
R148, Taylor has singing gigs all the time all over the U.S.
Plus he recently had a year long residency singing gig at a Las Vegas hotel where he performed several times per week for a year and made $1.5 million dollars.
R147 Phillip Phillips is currently 73 in radio airplay.
Phillip Phillips' songs are played constantly and daily on several SiriusXM radio channels. He is very popular and his songs get very frequent airplay.
He has also gone on tour with Bruce Springsteen and a couple other very famous groups.
I must be getting old because I found nothing appealing about Idol this year. That fact Caleb. Somebody needs to tip that cow over and slaughter it. Poor Jena Irene. She's a poster child for down syndrome. They could've skipped a season. They could have done 100 different things instead of putting this shit fest on the air. Shame on Idol and Fox. They've turned millions of people away from their network. Thank God they still have the NFL.
Phillip Phillps won the lottery with his corination song Home. No other Idol was given a commercial song that made it on radio and promoted on Olympics.
At the time PP made sure to tell everyone the song was not the kind of music that he wanyed reptrsenting him. i bet he got told to shut up and make another.
I do like the song, probably because I like Mumford.
1. Kelly Clarkson: she had an interesting voice, some great hits and honestly she had the benefit of being the first.
2. Carrie Underwood: As someone else put it she has a personality and she's a great singer ... I do hate that she looks like everyone else. I don't even like country music and I am happy to see her still hustling.
3. Fantasia: She is completely in her feelings every time she performs which makes her great. Despite her issues (part inexperience from having to perform nightly and not being able to and health related from NOT taking care of her voice or learning how to properly sing forcing her to have throat surgery so early) most critics agree she nailed her role in The Color Purple. Some people hate how expressive she is, a lot of people do eat it up.
Fanatsia is rough around the edges, but you have to love her insane energy.
true about Phillip Phillips, I stopped watching AI 4 years ago so I had no idea who he was, but that damn song Home was so massive on the radio I found out he was AI winner, lol
Loved Phillip Phillips performance of Raging Fire tonight on American Idol. He's a dynamic exciting performer and singer.
Love his raspy voice and stage presence
Okay now that Caleb wonm he's the worst winner ever! Zero personality, zero charisma, zero star quality, zero marketability, zero appeal... Yuck!!!
Way to go Kris Allen! You're no longer in the bottom 3 winners!
I don't understand Caleb. What true rocker would have the Rachel haircut from Friends?
A rocker with a head like a St. Bernard. He needs a bit of hair camouflage. Not everyone looks like Roger Daltry ya know.
Caleb has a bit too much "hangin in my parents basement singing REAL ROCK!" lame satan finger throwing anachronistic vibe about him, but he has a legitimately good rock voice. Pretty fine singer who can still get better. So far he is a bit of an ass, but he didn't conform much and still won. His voice did the work. You could tell form the start he would win. I rate him above Lee, D.Cook, Ruben, Kris, and Ms. Sparks.
R163. Vocally Kelly can set Carrie on fire. They are very different, always compared, but there is no comparison about who is the better vocalist. Carrie has a nice tone, long strong power notes and is blonde. Kelly is one of the great voices and vocalists of our time. She has too many gifts to count.
Carrie Underwood singing one of her power ballads, with power. As I stated upthread she can only sing vowels comfortably, or rather concentrates on them. (Patti LuPone does this too.) She sacrifices a lot of lyrical content and feeling in building the song's vocal momentum. Her non belting voice IS pretty, but unsteady, so she likes to get to the power singing and then repeats it until this sad song has not much feeling. Her voice is wound up but her sound is tight. She impresses. She has some great recordings. There are many worse voices. But she is not a great singer.
Next I will post Kelly Clarkson covering the same song. Y'all can decide for yourselves.
"I Know You Won't."
Kelly Clarkson. She sings without gowns or shoes half the time. She jokes. Her voice gets ragged. She uses melisma, runs, crescendos, whispers, gutsy rasp and slicing through spinto soprano techniques. Sometimes too many. But she sings the lyric with nuance and feeling, and uses her powerful voice with meaning. She is not as polished as Carrie, but Kelly is the girl with more candles on her cake.
The tone of a singers voice is what we love or not. For most that is all that matters. Kelly has a beautiful instrument, the greater range and gift, but some prefer Underwood's tone and dresses.
I would rather listen to Justin Bieber than that ugly Caleb with no X Factor
Even Mikalah Gordon can beat that Caleb whatever.. eeew
David Cook, Kris Allen and Taylor Hicks are the only ones I wanna have sex with...
Carrie Underwood's voice hurts by ears.
I find it very grating, screeching, screaming, and difficult to listen to.
R177 Carrie's voice hurts your ears? Then what do you call Fantasia's voice? Nails on chalkboard!!!
David Archuleta is the only one who doesn't scream in his upper register
Kelly is a little overrated
I want to have sex with David Archuleta
I wanna have sex with David Cook also
I also wanna have sex with Taylor Hicks!
David Cook performed at Epcot for a food and wine festival last week. We remembered him from Idol and attended two of his short performances. Way back when, I thought he was going to be a huge pop/rock solo star, like a new Bryan Adams or Richard Marx. Didn't happen.
He's a truly excellent singer. He covered Journey's Separate Ways and Led Zep's Rock and Roll and even though he joked about how difficult those songs are, he sang them effortlessly. He has no stage presence, which is odd. He's very charming and funny between songs, but keeps his eyes shut tight while singing and doesn't engage the audience. I remember him being one of the more animated Idols, so something has changed.
Apparently he has a new single being released next week, but didn't sing it at his sets at Epcot, which doesn't make any sense. If you're self-releasing music - no deal with a label - shouldn't you be all over the promotion for it?
Clarkson has the best voice. Underwood is right up there as well. The two of them have a good number of hits between them. But Kelly can sing country - look what she did for the song with Jason Aldean. Either way they are both winners.
Taylor Hicks is the worst one
Yeah Clarkson's material sucks. She doesn't have a single thing I like but I can admit she's got a great voice. Though I understand she didn't have the most classic voice and wasn't the most talented but my favorite was Brooke White. I really like her voice and she chose a lot of material I liked.
He didn't win, but Adam Lambert has been playing the Freddie Mercury role with the remaining members of Queen on tour for a while, a couple of summers at least.
Another runner-up is starring on the CBS procedural Scorpion: Katharine McPhee.
K McFee's talent is clearly oral per the rumors of how she gets jobs.
[quote]Carrie Underwood's voice hurts by ears.
Are you serious? She's great!
Clarkson and Underwood are the best singers. They can really sing anything. Underwood is underrated. She's a country singer, but can also sing rock, pop, and standards.
Fantasia is very,very talented, but more in a Patti Labelle-ish crazed live-performance way than a make-radio- hits way. She also has a reputation for a crazy personal life and a family which relies on her financially, which makes people who want to work with her often end up shying away from her.
There is only one American Idol and her name is Kelly Clarkson.
I thought Ruben was better than Clay, at the time, during season 2. But since then Clay improved and Ruben, well, where is he?
In Season 4, I thought Bo Bice was outstanding, one of the best they ever had on that show, while Carrie was dull, wooden and robotic. Since then of course she has gone on to a huge career while Bo has struggled.
Chris Daughtry finished 4th and yet arguably has had a more successful career than either Taylor Hicks or Katharine McPhee.
In season 1 I thought Tamyra Gray was excellent, and I can't remember what season she was on, but Vonzell Solomon was really good. Yet what happened to them?
I can only conclude that being on or even winning American Idol doesn't guarantee future success. Plenty of stars made it big on their own, without that show.
Kelly Clarkson has more talent in her baby finger than Taylor Swift has.
Tamyra Gray married one of the guys from Color Me Badd, a boy band from the 90s. The guy who looked like Kenny G.
Ruben's career was ruined by Clive Davis trying to make him into a hip-hop guy instead of a new Luther Vandross. Nobody was buying that. He released a good CD a few years ago (with excellent covers of "More Than Words" by Extreme and The Beatles' "Long and Winding Road"), but his career was long gone by then.
Clive Davis was NOT good for the Idols. The only reason Carrie Underwood did so well is that he turned her over immediately to the country division of the label and he didn't interfere. If Clive had his way, Kelly Clarkson was supposed to be Christina Aguilera, with sexy clothes and backup dancers. Her first single was exactly that, then she told him that was BS and she wasn't doing it anymore.
Candice Glover, Kelly Clarkson Ruben and Fantasia are the most talented 3 winners vocally. Jordin Sparks and Carrie Underwood come in after them. The other winners sucked and got lucky.
It's a shame that only Kelly and Carrie had any long lasting chart success. Candice, Fantasia, Ruben and Jordin should have bigger careers too but most of the public these days strangely prefer autotune shit or "white soul singers".
OP = Kelly Clarkson.
I loved Fantasia on the show but after she won she kind of went ghetto.
She "went ghetto" because Clive Davis insisted on it. That's the material he solicited for her releases. "Baby Mama" and "Hood Boy".
Clive Davis could never figure out what to do with Jennifer Hudson's recording career either. She's incredibly lucky that Dreamgirls came along to sustain her career for the past few years.Luckily, he's out of power and her album release this year is a good start towards establishing a style.