Unlike, say, homosexuality, Asperger's is a developmental disorder. These patients require a lot of intervention, which is expensive, and having this disorder is another life struggle.
Soon science will be able to identify the genes that contribute to the development of spectrum disorders. But some Aspies fear fetuses with Asperger's will be aborted simply for that reason. They also argue their lives are just fine, thank you. They say they're different; not disordered. But Aspies don't understand how frustrating they are to the rest of us because they have the disorder. I say parents should be able to selectively abort.
If they cure it, we won't have any more "Big Bang Theory."
I don't think "curing" and killing are the same thing. Cure, to me, implies a treatment not an extinction.
No it's not, r1.
True Asperger's is real, but all the UMC white people have glommed onto it in order to excuse their sons' weirdness and lack of social skills.
But what would we do without our Sherlock Holmes?
No psycholigical condition has ever been linked to a pathogen. Homosexuliaty is one of many nonexitent "disorders," such as sociopathy or narcissism, which biol down to someone behaving in a manner we simply don't like.
I believe that Asperger's is the natural state of trust and ignorance in which we are born, and that those who are diagnosed with it never "evolve" into cynicism like the rest of us. For jobs which require trust, like handling money or security acess, it is actually considered a big plus, and there are employment agencies who place these people.
I wouldn't call it a true disorder as much as an inability to function in society. One could argue that the rest of us have the porblem, since Aspies are loyal, trusting, honest, and treat others with the respect that they assume others will treat them.
We already have a "cure" for it, but most do not realize it: COGNITIVE THERAPY. Talk to someone with Asperger's where others took the time to school them on how the world really operates. They learn intellectually what most of us learn naturally, but once the lightbulb goes off, they can function just fine.
Our desire to label them as mentally ill is just another example of politically-motivated retaliation against those we deem a threat. Criminals don't like honest people who refuse to shut up, that's for sure.
Former Aspie, now smart and cynical
Tesla was an Aspie.
You can't diagnose Asperger's thru a brainscan etc. You can only assess for it. My therapist referred me, and I score 5 points over the baseline.
Now I am pissed at how my mother "punished" me for not living up to her standard of social skills. And at my sister for "setting me up" for embarrassments.
But I don't define myself my that way and never will. And I don't advertise it.
It does however give me some comfort that it explains some things.
For one thing, the term "Asperger's Syndrome" is itself considered out of date at this point, as it isn't distinguishable from high-functioning autism. And autism spectrum disorder may not be a binary yes-you-have-it or no-you-don't genetic condition so much as an epigenetic one.
[quote]Epigenetic processes [are] chemical reactions tied to neither nature nor nurture but representing what researchers have called a "third component." These reactions influence how our genetic code is expressed: how each gene is strengthened or weakened, even turned on or off, to build our bones, brains, and all the other parts of our bodies.
[quote]If you think of our DNA as an immense piano keyboard and our genes as keys—each key symbolizing a segment of DNA responsible for a particular note, or trait, and all the keys combining to make us who we are—then epigenetic processes determine when and how each key can be struck, changing the tune being played.
[quote]One way the study of epigenetics is revolutionizing our understanding of biology is by revealing a mechanism by which the environment directly impacts genes. Studies of animals, for example, have shown that when a rat experiences stress during pregnancy, it can cause epigenetic changes in a fetus that lead to behavioral problems as the rodent grows up. Other epigenetic changes appear to occur randomly—throwing a monkey wrench into the engine of nature versus nurture. Still other epigenetic processes are normal, such as those that guide embryonic cells as they become heart, brain, or liver cells, for example.
[quote]"During pregnancy, many changes must occur as cells commit to and become progressively specialized tissues, and we know that process involves a cascade of epigenetic programs," says Andrew Feinberg, director of the Center for Epigenetics at Johns Hopkins School of Medicine.
[quote]Feinberg's study focuses on a particular epigenetic process called DNA methylation, which is known to make the expression of genes weaker or stronger. To better understand how it relates to autism, Feinberg and his team are using scanners and computers to search samples of DNA from autistic twins for epigenetic "tags," places along the genome where methylation changes the pattern of gene expression.
[quote]The goal of the study, still in progress, is to determine whether individuals with severe autism have different methylation profiles than other people. Despite sharing the same keyboard, their bodies [may be] playing different tunes.
[quote]Scientists are only beginning to understand how epigenetic processes relate to complex disorders like autism. The good news is that some of these processes, unlike our DNA sequences, can be altered. Genes muted by methylation, for example, sometimes can be switched back on again relatively easily. And though it may not happen soon, the hope is that someday epigenetic mistakes will be as simple to repair as a piano that's out of tune.
I was diagnosed with it at 40 and since I have none of those Aspie related super skills some with the condition seem to possess I'd want to be cured.
It's hard to cure something that is basically an excuse for bad behaviour.
I dated an aspie & he was a genius level scientist. He was also almost incapable of using the phone, sustaining communication , and relating to any emotional issues. If you get rid of Aspergers you would get rid of some of the greatest geniuses the world has produced. I really liked the guy I dated, but it was impossible to have a relationship of any depth with him.
People who say Aspergers is fake are incredibly ignorant.
R13, if a person is "incredibly ignorant," does that mean they're not really ignorant?
Or are you just illustrating what such ignorance looks like by embodying it?
Incredibly is a synonym for astonishing dickweed
No, absolutely not, and no fucking way to the OP's repugnant proposal. Eugenics are not a solution.
A friend and I had sons of the same age who were in the same preschool program for language delays. When the boys were in elementary school being horribly bullied, behaving differently from other kids, being loving,having great senses of humor, obviously very intelligent children, she said to me, "If there were a way to make this go away, I wouldn't change him. I love him the way that he is." We later found out that both boys have Aspergers. It is a difference in brain organization that takes place early in fetal development. Our sons had it rough in school, but college is different. My son has friends and has had girlfriends, makes many social mistakes, is doing very well in school, plays Dungeon and Dragons, and is very happy. I think my friend was right: even though he has not had an easy time of it, I wouldn't change him.
Inconvenient to the rest of you? We are not obliged to "convenience" anyone. Life is made in the divine image. You people have no right to decide who lives or who dies. Abortion, when it is not needed to save the woman's life, is murder period. I don't give a flying crap about your convenience, you coward who had to post anonymously and hide behind a keyboard.
Asbergers allows a "A" for "C" work.
Asperger's sydrome is this century's ADHD. It may apply to a small number of kids, but more and more they're applying it to normal kids to excuse their bad behavior. I'm waiting for them to come up with a magic pill like they did Ritalin and Adderall to soothe the savage beats into obedient little brats.
If you completely eliminated all Asperger's, who the fuck would be left to program our computers?
aspies are mean and insufferable
My friend has ASD and while I am glad he is in my life and while he makes his contribution - he can't work but raises money for charities obsessively through various sponsored activities - he is not the 'aspie Saint' the aspie industry likes to push as the norm.
Yes, he is naive and scrupulously honest. But those traits can result in really appalling behavior and attitudes. He has made a widow cry at her husband's funeral, gets very loud and agitated if you disagree with him on anything, e.g. No, thanks I won't take another piece of bread; WHAT? Come on. It's good. Have it; No, I really don't want more; Why? etc until you give in or he nearly explodes with his inability to understand the preference of another person if it differs from his own.
So, aspies have good points but can be exhausting and upsetting if you don't understand, and accept, how narrow and rigid their perceptions are.
I might have someone with Asperger's in one of the college courses I'm teaching (film studies). As a professor, it's a huge courtesy if the student can come and talk to me and let me know so I can do a better job of accommodating them and understanding behavior in the classroom without attempting to diagnose them myself, which is a farce because I'm not remotely.
Instead, he is constantly muttering critical comments while sitting about two feet away from the front of the classroom. We're 3/4 through winter quarter and today was the day I asked him to please stop doing that because it's disrespectful to classmates talking and people trying to listen when I teach (plus it distracts the hell out of me).
A simple accommodation form in the first week would make things run better, especially for him, and things could be handled earlier than this. Having to guess and armchair analyze feels really unfair to him. He does great work and is incredibly smart, but the bitching about classmates under his breath and audibly is just a no-go.
That should read "not remotely qualified" at the end of the first paragraph.
I too taught film studies and the difficulty my ASD students had was in interpreting character motivations and relationships between characters onscreen, other than at the most very basic level. They were very interested in editing and shot scales and use of color.
They recently used a compound from brocolli that when given in pill form, reduced the symptoms of Aspergers, thereby proving that it's some kind of chemical, or structural brain abnormality, and therefore absolutely a real disorder.
Hey, R26. R24/25 here. That's actually really helpful to know. His essays on "A Trip to the Moon" and "Meshes of the Afternoon" were really impressive and I get the sense that he might be struggling with the structural and psychological criticism that we hit this week. Those could be especially challenging for him. Thanks for giving me something to think about.
I wonder if we knew/know each other via the film studies connection. I used to do the conference circuit but phased that out in the last few years.
many aspies lie a lot and are hypocrites with no empathy!!!
Tim Burton has to be aspie, I can't stand his films, there are not relatable and have a weird sense of dissociation from humanity.
R19 I would actually give you a C in my class for misspelling, either intentionally or unintentionally, "Asperger's."
I have a number of students with Asperger's Syndrome in my college-level classes. Like any population, they are all very individual, from those who cannot bear to have you within five feet of them to those who, even though they present with some of the traditional speech and gestural symptoms, can, when encouraged, do remarkably thoughtful, insightful, and, yes, emotionally deep work.
As a teacher, my classes would be much less rich and interesting if some of these students were all of a sudden "homogenized."
Any screaming bipolars, Professor, or do you discriminate against them?
Bipolars are usually very gifted.
r32, aspies have high depression and suicide rates as well as violence
They monopolize the conversation, are physically clumsy and VERY SELFISH
[quote]But some Aspies fear fetuses with Asperger's will be aborted simply for that reason.
As well they should be [aborted, that is]!
Imo, it's no different from how some deaf parents get mad when a cochlear implant is suggested for their deaf child. "Well, I've been deaf my whole life and I'm fine, why should my child be forced to hear?" Um, because it's better? Hello, duhhh!
"True Asperger's is real, but all the UMC white people have glommed onto it in order to excuse their sons' weirdness and lack of social skills."
You sound dumb. There is way more to autism than "weirdness" and "lack of social skills" - it's more complicated than that.
"It's hard to cure something that is basically an excuse for bad behaviour."
Except most people with autism aren't bad, and most bad people never claimed to have autism
r37, Jeffrey dahmer, adam Lanza, Colorado batman shooter etc had aspergers
R38, citation please. Else, drivel.
What is "UMC white people"?
upper middle class maybe?
If they cure it, will my little New Mexico still be special?
Oh, sure she would. She'd still have that allergy to 52 watt light bulbs.
She looks just like her Daddy! She's 12 and just had her first taste of carob!
No. I'm Autistic and would not change myself. I am who I am. I'm not deficient. I wouldn't change that just because of how other people view it or other's view of people/things outside of their personal norm, anymore than I'd change being African-American, queer, or a woman.
I think a lot of people could use a dose of self-love and acceptance but instead we have people taking a bunch of drugs, getting nose jobs, pretending, and bleaching their skin.
p.s. threads like this remind me of the those who judge people who commit suicide so harshly. Instead of being grateful they don't have to deal with being *insert experience* they just sit around and laugh and joke that something (even despair) doesn't really exist. What a luxury.
Homosexuality is NOT a disorder that needs to be cured.
"I say parents should be able to selectively abort."
I say you're an idiot. If your parents had known you'd turn out to be such an ass they probably would have "selectively" aborted YOU.
What's so wrong about being an Aspie? We're just different. Watch this clip to understand instead of being so weird about everything.
That's the thing about freedom of choice, and why "freedom of choice" has become such a watchword - people are FREE to choose what to do about any pregnancy. They can choose to abort for any damn reason they please, without asking the busybodies and control freaks for permission.
So what if aborting a fetus because they don't like something about it isn't fair, well life isn't fucking fair is it and personal freedom isn't simple.
R51 I think that any woman who want to terminate her pregnancy should have the legal right (though I get queasy when it happens in the last trimester, unless mother's life is in danger or something that will make life unremittingly painful for the to-be-born child is detected--like Tay-Sachs). to do it for any reason.
Morally, I find it questionable as a motivation, though, if the parent(s) truly believe it is beyond them to raise such a child, I would say, given the lack of genuine support systems we have for such families, it might be a moral choice. To do so simply because the child is likely to be "defective" (a term I loathe) is problematic for me. There has been a 90% rise in the termination of fetuses that test positive for Down Syndrome since pre-natal genetic tests have been able to pick up that. Since many many people with Down Syndrome live long, fulfilling, and happy--and, yes, often reasonably independent--lives, that as a reason for termination is not as clear to me.
Haven't read through all the comments, but an Asperger's diagnosis is a description of behavior and not based on any concrete genetic markers, is it not? So the diagnosis seems very subjective, and the behavioral aspects could be due to any number of factors.
My little cousin is autistic. We couldn't get him to stop staring at things that went around in a circle like ceiling fans, he also still has a compulsion to turn lights on and off. He didn't talk for a long time and wouldn't make eye contact. Since my cousin's wife is a doctor and he's a teacher, they both make good money and were able to get him the best of care. He's a million times better today, but he seems about 3 years behind where he should be mentally. Had they not had the money, I really do fear what would have happened to him. They were determined for him to go to a regular school, which he did. It took his mother a long time to accept that her kid, her first born, had an obvious mental disorder. The family had to convince her to take him to see someone for over a year once the signs were there. They have a second child now who shows no signs of having the disorder.
I think you meant astonishingly.
[quote]There has been a 90% rise in the termination of fetuses that test positive for Down Syndrome since pre-natal genetic tests have been able to pick up that. Since many many people with Down Syndrome live long, fulfilling, and happy--and, yes, often reasonably independent--lives, that as a reason for termination is not as clear to me.
The problem is that there are degrees of impairment in Down Syndrome. Some are merely "slow" and can live happily and semi-independently. Others remain at the level of an infant and require 24/7 care for their entire lives, which also puts them at serious risk for abuse from the people who are supposed to be caring for them.
Not only that, but Down Syndrome isn't just about the mental retardation, there have many other physical problems and deformities, as well, including serious heart defects.
When Down Syndrome is detected in a fetus, there's no way to know how damaged the child will ultimately be, and most responsible parents will choose to abort. Imo, that's a good thing.
With Lanza, I believe that his disordered behaviors were evident at a very young age. He was taken for diagnosis. But clinicians will not diagnise anti-social personality disorder in kids, even if they see signs of it. It may be that the autism diagnosis was made to explain his lack of empathy at a young age, whereas perhaps in fact he was developing psychopathy. Or, he was both autistic and psychopathic = zero ability to form any meaningful connection with others.
The lack of empathy is ASD is not linked to maliciousness or desire to hurt another or inability to feel affection or compassion, it's a cognition problem of being unable to conceptualise another's feelings. But those harmful traits are associated with the psychopathic lack of empathy, which is linked to a highly exploitative and aggressive attitude to others.