Someone on 'average penis size' thread asked, "How big of a slut do you need to be for *average* penis size in the entire population to be a significant factor for you?" Which got me to thinking...
I'm not a size queen because some of the HOTTEST guys I've been with have had small to average dicks. Some of the UGLIEST guys I've been with have had huge, long cocks. Big isn't fun to handle and combined with an ugly face, it's just a no.
I would never judge a man's worthiness as a human being or desirability as a friend by that standard, but other things being equal, a guy with a big dick is much more attractive to me than one without.
I never cared about whether a guy is GQ handsome, either, as long as he's not butt ugly. Otherwise, I like a beefy guy with a calm, masculine air who is kind to others...and has a big dick.