Who the hell put Anne Baxter in Lead Actress for Sunset Blvd?
Would she have won in Supporting? Would Davis have won in lead without her? Who should have been the 5th lead actress nominee?
Eleanor Parker, Caged
oops!!!for All About EVE I mean!!!!
Drat! The Cat
Supposedly Anne insisted, but really, Eve is just as much a lead as Margo is. \
I''m surprised she and Bette stayed such good friends, when Bette firmly believed she would have won if she and Anne hadn''t "split the votes."
Oh please, Bette! NO ONE voted for Anne.
What R3 said.%0D\
The more likely story is that people had had enough of the Queen Bee of Warners.
Suck it, bitches.
OP, have you read the book "All About ''All About Eve'' by Sam Staggs? I think you''d enjoy it. Dishy fun. Covers the movie and the Bacall musical.
OP, Sam Staggs other books about Sunset Blvd (Close Up on Sunset Blvd.), A Streetcar Named Desire (When Brando Met Blanche) and Imitation of Life (Born to be Hurt) are also great fun. Just finished the Desire book. When you read them, you immediately want to watch the movies again. So much detail in his books about the actors, production, problems on and off set and critical reception. The issues Warner Bros and director Elia Kazan confronted with the censorship boards and Legion of Decency over Streetcar edits could make up an entire book.%0D
The vote was not split with Baxter, it was split with Gloria Swanson. What happened in 1950 was the same thing that happened in Best Actor 1989. Tom Cruise and Morgan Freeman were the odds-on favorites, splitting the votes which would normally go to only one favorite allowing Daniel Day Lewis to sneak in for the win. Same with Marissa Tomei against the cream of the crop of the British Empire in 1992.\
And to those who say Baxter shouldn''t have been up for supporting actress, every time Margo Channing WASN''T in a scene, the viewer is wondering where''s Margo, when will she come back? That last ten minutes of the film WITHOUT Margo is interminable.
Judy Holliday was No. 1.%0D\
Bette Davis and Gloria Swanson were batting for No. 2.%0D\
Eleanor Parker was No. 4.%0D\
Anne Baxter was the fifth spot. On the list. Not so much for the votes.
If I were Anne Baxter, I would have had my pussy placed in Supporting an walked away with a second Oscar in under five years. Suck on that, Josephine Hull.
that was a most confusing headline.
I''m not sure I get the mathematics.%0D\
If say, there were 1000 votes and Bette and Gloria were supposedly each odds-on favorites then they each got, say 300 votes. %0D\
But Eleanor got say, 50 votes and Anne just voted for herself, leaving Judy with 349. %0D\
So how does that not make Judy the odds-on favorite?
But isn''t "All About Eve" really another variation on Mankiewicz''s previous hit "A Letter to 3 Wives" as I am sure if you timed them that Margo, Eve and Karen (Celeste) are all parts of about equal size. Margo dominates the first half but is side-lined as the film goes on and Eve and Karen and Addison take centre stage - which is why we see no more of Birdie once the action moves away from Margo''s duplex. %0D\
Baxter was cast because of her resemblence to Claudette Colbert who was meant to be Margo. (no, I cant imagine it either). Davis and Baxter both being nominated as best actress must have split their votes. %0D\
For me the great performance of 1950 is Swanson as Norma Desmond - a full length role that dominates the film.
Norma Desmond? She used to be in pictures... she used to be big....
William Holden, Best Actor of them all...
Wow. Debating Oscar votes from over half a century ago.\
This certainly defines the "pointless" in the DL tagline.\
If any thread needed "caftans! earrings!" this is it.\
I''ll be over there, patiently awaiting all the "fuck off!" replies...
I''ve never Judy Holliday in whatever she won for.\
But I loved Davis'' performance in Eve.\
It doesn''t have to have won her the Oscar for me to love it the most.
How nice. How nice for EVERYBODY!
Is the movie called "All About Margot"? I think not.
For a moment the OP had me convince Baxter was the dead monkey.
Jeanne Crain (a Fox contract player and Mankiewicz favorite) was originally cast as Eve but left in pre-production when she became pregnant and she looked nothing like Claudette Colbert or Bette Davis for that matter.
Not getting the Colbert/Baxter resemblance
Anne Baxter's performance as Eve in ALL ABOUT EVE is embarrassing. Anyone could see from the outset that she was a scheming phony. Maybe she was directed to act that way by Mankiewicz, but she was a very overrated actress anyway, and frequently a ham. Her cloying, affected delivery and over-enunciated line readings were pretty much the way she approached every part for the rest of her life.
But I think she was still at the end of her Fox contract, and as a contract player. promoting her was good publicity for the movie, and ultimately a plus for the studio, whether she won or not.
Davis and Swanson were the past, not the future, and neither were tied to any particular studio by contract, so no studio had a stake in either winning. Judy Holliday, on the other hand, had a big commercial hit with BORN YESTERDAY, and had signed a Columbia contract. She was the future (not really, but so it looked in early '51).
And Hollywood is always about the future, which is why predicting Natalie Portman's win over Annette Bening at the Oscars last year was a no-brainer.
I saw both Bacall and replacement Anne Baxter in APPLAUSE in New York. I had not had the opportunity to see ALL ABOUT EVE before seeing the musical. Back then, no TCM, no home video and no revival movie houses where I lived. Looking back, it would have been fun to see Baxter''s take on Margo after seeing her on screen as Eve.
Anne was one hammy actress, and was terrible in almost everything. Her early performances were good("King''s Row"), but her mannered overplaying got worse with each passing year.
I loved Baxter as Marsha, Queen of Diamonds on "Batman". At the cliffhanger, when she sat and knitted while Aunt Harriet hung, blindfolded and bound over a pit of boiling oil? Creepy. And Sadistic.\
Her second appearance, with Vincent Price as Egghead, not as good.
Tallulah Bankhead, the Black Widow dahling...
Excellent post, R21. %0D\
You can pretty much downgrade the idea of the Best Actress oscar for anyone over 50. I''d guess that it''s been won by someone over that age about 4-5 times since 1960: K. Hepburn, Mirren, Tandy, Geraldine Page...anyone else?
Baxter wasn''t in KING''S ROW, r23. She was in THE MAGNIFICENT AMBERSONS, where she is not bad at all. And she won the Supporting Oscar in ''46 for THE RAZOR''S EDGE. That is also not a terrible performance, but it is self-conscious, and the part of Sophie was so foolproof just about any actress in the part would have at least scored a nomination.\
Zanuck wanted Judy Garland, and she would have been brilliant, though there is no way on earth she could have done it.